Depa Billaba vs. Darth Maul

Started by Excalibur27768 pagesPoll

Poll

Who would win in a battle to the death?

34 total votes

Excalibur2776 Restricted

Depa Billaba vs. Darth Maul

Who would win in a battle to the death?
Setting: Open Field, Dantooine
Scenario One: Depa Billaba vs. Darth Maul (TPM)
Lightsabers:
Force:
All Out:
Scenario Two: Depa Billaba vs. Darth Maul (TCW)
Lightsabers:
Force:
All Out:

P.S. Depa is Dark Side in both scenarios.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

As far as I know, Depa's best 'feat' occurred when Mace stated that her bladework surpassed his own-- a compliment that was never proven, as Mace held back enormously when they fought in Shatterpoint. I can't even recall any force feats of note from her..?

Maul should take this handily.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Like I have stated in the Kenobi vs Depa..she fought Mace when he was only about 80-85% of his true power. When she was no longer being supported by the fear of citizens, I say she is around 70% of Mace's full power. It is also noted that Qui-Gon was able to duel evenly with Mace in his prime, and during Jinn's Prime to TPM was probably only ten years, therefore probably making it Jinn Prime=90% of Mace ROTS. Therefore, a Jinn TPM would=80% of Mace's full power. Since I just put Jinn>Depa, and I put Maul and Jinn equals, I think it's safe to say Maul TPM wins, as does the CW.

Lightsabers: Draw due to the fact that Maul is a better duelist, but Depa has Vaapad to aid her.

Force: I don't really think Force will be that big of a factor here, but I'm giving the edge to Maul with his feats shown in the CW.

ALL OUT: I'm giving both Mauls the win due to reasons said above. CW Maul has a slightly easier time.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Mace never so much as attempted to fight back against Depa-- he barely even began to tap into Vaapad(do I need to post the quotes?) Therefore, we have no way to approximate "what %" of his power/skill she equated to.

Furthermore, it has never been stated in a canon source that Qui-Gon=Mace. That, sir, is an internet rumor falsely propagated by Wookiepedia.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Originally posted by Galan007
Mace never so much as attempted to fight back against Depa-- he barely even began to tap into Vaapad(do I need to post the quotes?) Therefore, we have no way to approximate "what %" of his power/skill she equated to.

Furthermore, it has never been stated in a canon source that Qui-Gon=Mace. That, sir, is an internet rumor falsely propagated by Wookiepedia.

Well the % and = are opinions are they not? And Im a fan of Wookiepedia 🙂 but it has been stated in the Power of the Jedi soucebook im not correct..

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Well the % and = are opinions are they not?
You are absolutely entitled to your own opinions, but some of the info you mentioned is a bit... Skewed. No biggie. 🙂

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
And Im a fan of Wookiepedia 🙂 but it has been stated in the Power of the Jedi soucebook im not correct..
No, it has not. Believe me, I've looked. Thoroughly. Heck, I've scoured every SW-related sourcebook/handbook/guide/encyclopedia/etc. that Mace and Qui-Gon have ever been mentioned in, and have yet to find a quote stating Qui-Gon=Mace. That's why I can say, with a fair amount of confidence, that said quote doesn't exist in canon material.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Hmm..curious about the Jinn=Mace is fake..but until its proven noncanon, im classifying it has cannon.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

I proved the quote non-canon when I was unable to find it in the book Wookiepedia references(or any other book for that matter.) Don't be purposefully obtuse.

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66
Originally posted by Galan007
I proved the quote non-canon when I was unable to find it in the book Wookiepedia references(or any other book for that matter.) Don't be purposefully obtuse.

I classify Wookieedpedia as cannon until proven noncannon

Mizukage Yoda Lord of Winterfell
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Well the % and = are opinions are they not? And Im a fan of Wookiepedia 🙂 but it has been stated in the Power of the Jedi soucebook im not correct..

No it wasn't I have a PDF of the Power of the Jedi Sourcebook and the quote is no where to be found.

Mizukage Yoda Lord of Winterfell
Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I classify Wookieedpedia as cannon until proven noncannon

It is now a canon source considering even the official page links it for character bios but that's only because it is a collection of previous source material. Fan wanking doesn't count.

Galan007 |Quantum Observer|

Cool. I proved the quote non-canon by not being able to find it in any canon book(even the book Wookiepedia specifically referenced.)

...But I guess it's easier to be a 'tard than accept fact, so cheers to that. 👆

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

Originally posted by Galan007
Cool. I proved the quote non-canon by not being able to find it in any canon book(even the book Wookiepedia specifically referenced.)

...But I guess it's easier to be a 'tard than accept fact, so cheers to that. 👆

Aren't you sweet 😬

Excalibur2776 Restricted

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Aren't you sweet 😬

What's your YouTube channel? (Your title says YouTuber)

DarthAnt66 DarthAnt66

http://www.youtube.com/user/0827ant1

755 subscribers 288,915 views

CountDooku22 Member

Originally posted by Galan007
As far as I know, Depa's best 'feat' occurred when Mace stated that her bladework surpassed his own-- a compliment that was never proven, as Mace held back enormously when they fought in Shatterpoint. I can't even recall any force feats of note from her..?

Maul should take this handily.

Hardly.

I believe Mace implied that healthy or no, she had grown as deadly as him with Vapaad, and try as he might to at least defend - she was still able to stab him.

TPM Maul gets raped by Dark side Vapaad-Depa.

Depa also beats TCW Maul in a close fight.

Jedi Mom Restricted

Originally posted by CountDooku22
Depa also beats TCW Maul in a close fight.

Bold claim. Evidence for this?

Excalibur2776 Restricted

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
http://www.youtube.com/user/0827ant1

755 subscribers 288,915 views


Just subbed to you! 😄

CountDooku22 Member
Originally posted by Jedi Mom
Bold claim. Evidence for this?

Yep. It's one word.

It starts with a "V", ends with a "d" and has "apaa" in the middle.

And it seals the deal.

Jedi Mom Restricted

Won't help until you prove that Maul can't dominate her with the force.