You keep on saying circumstances when I've already proved there weren't circumstances when he beat Anakin. You labeled him fighting offensively as circumstances.. that isn't a circumstance. You listed him being focused... that isn't circumstances. Those are regular things he can do if he so chooses and on a regular basis. Circumstances would be him fining the most powerful lightsaber ever and winning because of it. Or him finding an amulet that boosted his powers. Those would be circumstnaces. What happend in the fight wasn't. Kenobi just plain beat Anakin... plain and simple.. and by anakin's own words.. because he wasn't powerful enough.
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You labeled him fighting offensively as circumstances.. that isn't a circumstance.
It was, because his aggressive offensive surprised the brothers according to Shadow Conspiracy.
Just like Opress probably surprised Kenobi with his immense strength in their previous encounters. Like the very previous one which Kenobi clearly lost!
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
You listed him being focused... that isn't circumstances. Those are regular things he can do if he so chooses and on a regular basis
He was specifically noted as being above his normal peak focus for that fight. He was at peak focus against Maul in their One on One. And then "even more focused" against the Brothers after Adi died. I.e. clearly above his norm.
It was simply put a Peak performance for Kenobi. Just like it was a Peak performance for Opress when he was Force smacking both Kenobi and Skywalker together.
Yes, there is. Ventress is a trademark dual-weapons specialist. She is extremely limited when using a single saber, putting her at a distinct disadvantage against Savage. Even so, she survived for quite a bit without a weapon. In fair combat, Savage may not win.
Therefore A>B>C does not work in this instant.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
It was, because his aggressive offensive surprised the brothers according to Shadow Conspiracy.Just like Opress probably surprised Kenobi with his immense strength in their previous encounters. Like the very previous one which Kenobi clearly lost!
He was specifically noted as being above his normal peak focus for that fight. He was at peak focus against Maul in their One on One. And then "even more focused" against the Brothers after Adi died. I.e. clearly above his norm.
It was simply put a Peak performance for Kenobi. Just like it was a Peak performance for Opress when he was Force smacking both Kenobi and Skywalker together.
Be show for the narration that says "PEAK" form or "PEAK" focus. I don't believe it says that at all and simpy says he was focsued. You're not understanding that Focus for a Jedi isn't that difficult. Shit, it's not that difficult for us regular humans to simply focus... so for a jedi it's even easier. Point is, neither fighting offensively nor being mroe focused are circumstances that would allow a fight to be listed a PIS. That just isn't so. Circumstances would be what I listed happening.
Originally posted by DARTH POWER
Ok, so then Maul was at a big disadvantage every time he faced Kenobi in TCW. After all his speciality is also Dual Blades.Ventress's form is Makashi, so she should be fully capable with 1 Blade. Besides which she got 2 chances to fight Opress with a sinfle blade.
Originally posted by Vensai
Maul is not dependent on his double bladed saber. The first time we seen him on screen he's only using one saber. And there's a difference between using a single saber with two sides and two separate sabers.
Ventress almost never fights without two sabers so she's rather dependent on them due to habit.
She shouldn't be due to her form being Makashi.
Any Jedi/Dark Jedi worth their salt should be fully competent with a single saber.
Besides hwo many times has Ventress taken on both Kenobi and Skywalker together tackling each one with a single saber. But then I'm supposed to believe she can't properly tackle one opponent with a single saber? Nah I don't buy that at all.
Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
Be show for the narration that says "PEAK" form or "PEAK" focus. I don't believe it says that at all and simpy says he was focsued. You're not understanding that Focus for a Jedi isn't that difficult. Shit, it's not that difficult for us regular humans to simply focus... so for a jedi it's even easier. Point is, neither fighting offensively nor being mroe focused are circumstances that would allow a fight to be listed a PIS. That just isn't so. Circumstances would be what I listed happening.
No it was said he was properly focused in his one on one with Maul. And then EVEN MORE Focused after Adi died. So clearly it was a peak performance for him and not a normal one. Which is obvious otherwise he wouldn't have lost to Maul and Opress in the past.
And if your going to argue that Peak Focus is normal for a Jedi and something they can do any time, then I will argue that Peak Rage is normal for a Sith and also something they can do any time..
In which case it was normal for Opress to take on and constantly force slam both Kenobi and Skywalker together. So then really all you have is Opress winning sometimes and Kenobi winning other times.
Have you ever played sports Darth? If you have, then you would know that even us normal humans can dial in and become more focused at the task at hand. Shit, we even do so at work. So, imagine then how much easier it is for a Jedi to do so. My point is, he can easily be that focused most of the time. THis is different than rage.. and you kinda need something to piss you off. Being more focused is easier and happens way more than fits of rage
So I was correct it NEVER said PEAK PERFORMANCE OR FOCUS at all.. that is something you added to exaggerate the sequence. The point is fighting offensively and being focused aren't really circumstances at all. They can be normal everyday occurance when you choose. Finding a magical saber on the ground is circumstances. Coming upon a hologram that tells you how to beat somebody right before you face them is a circumstance. Merely fighting offensively or being focused is not.
Originally posted by NewGuy01lol are you saying Kenobi using a different strategy makes it unfair?
But fighting in a cave where the duo can't properly fight without getting in each other's way is a circumstance, and Kenobi using a strategy that he usually doesn't to surprise them really doesn't make for the fairest fight.