KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For
Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For
Circe to Mid Herald. - For
Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For
Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For
Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For
Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For
Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against
Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against
Infinity Man to Trans. - Against
Iron Man to Low Herald - Against
Nimrod to High Herald - For
Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For
Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For
Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For
Ultron to High Herald. - For
WBH to Trans. - For
WBH to High Herald. - Against
WWH to High Herald. - Against

Changes to my votes:

Nimrod to High Herald.

Ok

Ultron to High Herald.

Ok

WBH to High Herald

Ok

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For now

Circe to Mid Herald. - For

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against

Infinity Man to Trans. - For
.
Iron Man to Low Herald. - For

Nimrod to High Herald. - For

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For

Ultron to High Herald. - For

WBH to Trans. - For

WBH to High Herald. - Against

WWH to High Herald. - For

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - Against

Circe to Mid Herald. - For

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against

Infinity Man to Trans. - For
.
Iron Man to Low Herald. - For

Nimrod to High Herald. - Against

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For

Ultron to High Herald. - For

WBH to Trans. - For

WBH to High Herald. - Against

WWH to High Herald. - For

For: Ironman, Aquaman, Ultron, Nimrod, Shaman Nate, Nova Prime

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

For

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

For

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

For

Iceman to Mid Herald.

Debating. I think his powerset lets him be there, but other factors might hold him back.

Iron Man to Low Herald

For

Aquaman to low meta or below.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For.

Circe to Mid Herald. - For.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to Low to Mid Herald - For.

Nimrod to High Herald.

Nova Prime to Mid to High Herald - For.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Ultron to High Herald. - For. Some of his incarnations belong in Trans.

WBH to Trans. - For.

WBH to High Herald. - See above.

WWH to High Herald..fluctuates depending on how pissed he is; starts off as high Herald but got greater in power. - For.

Ultron for High Herald.

Nova Prime for Mid Herald. Just to keep the thread from inflating ad infinitum, people just want to bump pretty much all characters into higher categories.

Shaman X-Man to high herald.

*still deciding the rest

Iron Man To Low Herald. No

Nova Prime to Mid Herald.Yes

Ultron To High Herald.Yes

Guys, not a debate thread.

Originally posted by TheHulk
Lol I know but they replied to me so...partially my fault. Where can we debate this stuff?

you debate it by voting. makes it simpler, and shorter.

Originally posted by -Pr-
you debate it by voting. makes it simpler, and shorter.

Iron Man to Low Herald. No

Ultron to high herald. Yes

Nova prime to mid herald.yes

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For
.
Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For
.
Circe to Mid Herald. - For
.
Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For
.
Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For
.
Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For
.
Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For
.
Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against
.
Iceman to Mid Herald. - For
.
Infinity Man to Trans. - For
.
Iron Man to Low Herald. - For
.
Nimrod to High Herald. - Against
.
Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For
.
Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For
.
Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For
.
Ultron to High Herald. - For
.
WBH to Trans. - For
.
WBH to High Herald. - Against
.
WWH to High Herald. - For

Which Ultron?
All of them?

DCnU Aquaman - For

WBH to High Herald - For

WBH to Trans - Against

Damn. Seems a little late now, but this should probably be handled one tier at a time. Getting pretty ugly with the tallying process.

My 2 cents for what it's worth: The Mid-Herald group is pretty broken. Most of those characters are generally considered HH on these boards. I don't really think anyone thinks of anyone as a mid-herald. Either the herald tier should be better defined (with HH being more exclusive than generally regarded), or most of the mid-herald players need to move.

PS: There's even some mid-heralds that I would consider Trans

PPS: If you really want to do this right, you could create an Excel spreadsheet with every character. Assign #s to tiers (e.g. Low street = 1, mid street = 2, etc). Let people fill it in as they see fit (don't need to assign a ranking to every character since most people aren't all that familiar with every character, copy/paste them all into a master list, and average it out).

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

For

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

For

Circe to Mid Herald.

For:

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

For

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

For

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

For

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

For

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

Against: 0

Iceman to Mid Herald.

For
Infinity Man to Trans.

For

Iron Man to Low Herald

For

Nimrod to High Herald.

For

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

For

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

For:

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

For

Ultron to High Herald.

For

WBH to Trans.

Against

WBH to High Herald.

For

Originally posted by -Pr-
As a consensus is reached, I'll be closing the voting on certain characters. To that end, once they're underlined, voting is over until this thread is closed.

[b]Adam Warlock to Mid Herald.

For: 2 (abhilegend, Raisen)
Against: 0

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald.

For: 5 (-Pr-, Badabing, curryman, Damborgson, TheHulk)
Against: 0

Circe to Mid Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, Jake, Raisen)
Against: 0

Doctor Strange to High Herald.

For: 8 (Jake, curryman, Badabing, Damborgson, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, dmills)
Against: 1 (Raisen)

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Ghost Rider to Low Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta.

For: 1 (Oliver North)
Against: 0

Hammerhead to Low Meta.

For: 1 (StiltmanFTW)
Against: 0

Iceman to Mid Herald.

For: 1 (eaebiakuya)
Against: 0

Infinity Man to Trans.

For: 3 (abhilegend, -Pr-, Raisen)
Against: 0

Iron Man to Low Herald

For: 3 (Galan, Jake, Naija)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Nimrod to High Herald.

For: 1 (Sin I Am)
Against: 0

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

For: 2 (eaebiakuya, dmills)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Shaman X-Man to High Herald.

For: 2 (Id, curryman)
Against: 0

Spider-Man to Mid Meta.

For: 6 (Badabing, Raisen, Blair Wind, TheHulk, Oliver North, dmills)
Against: 0

Ultron to High Herald.

For: 2 (Jake, Raisen)
Against: 2 (TheGodKiller, Sin I Am)

WBH to Trans.

For: 9 (Jake, -Pr-, curryman, Damborgson, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, TheGodKiller, Raisen)
Against: 1 (eaebiakuya)

WBH to High Herald.

For: 2 (Badabing, dmills)
Against: 1 (Jake)

WWH to High Herald.

For: 7 (Badabing, -Pr-, Jake, Naija, abhilegend, TheHulk, Raisen)
Against: 1 (curryman)

Gonna need someone to nail down where they think Batroc will go if we're going to vote for him.

Anything I missed or tallied incorrectly, let me know please. [/B]