KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Originally posted by Damborgson
Sentry should stay high herald

Sentry is always High Herald in power but sometimes not in formidability/effectiviness due to being a mental wreck. And when he is in control, his power can shoot past Herald level.

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Sentry is always High Herald in power but sometimes not in formidability/effectiviness due to being a mental wreck. And when he is in control, his power can shoot past Herald level.

i think i was more concerned when his power shoots past that high herald lvl and then with void i think they had him at high herald which is WAY off if u ask me

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Sentry is always High Herald in power but sometimes not in formidability/effectiviness due to being a mental wreck. And when he is in control, his power can shoot past Herald level.

👆

he should be put in low herald, mid herald, high herald, and trans tier all at once

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. Yay.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - Yay.

Circe to Mid Herald. - Yay.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - Yay and Yay.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - Yay.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - Yay.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - Yay.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Nay.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Nay.

Infinity Man to Trans. - Yay.
.
Iron Man to Low Herald - Yay.

Nimrod to High Herald.- Nay

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - Yay.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - Yay.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - Yay.

Ultron to High Herald. - Yay.

WBH to Trans. - Nay and Nay.

WBH to High Herald. - Yay.

WWH to High Herald. - Yay.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
couldnt you make the skyfather tier be solely those individuals who are Odins equals? with no lows or highs while the trans tier be split into two subcats.

Maybe. But I feel like having ONLY Odin's equals in a tier would make for a relatively small, pointless tier. My point was just that the earlier discussion wasn't taking everything into account, and there would need to be some re-drawing of lines, so to speak, unless you want a tier with literally no more than 5-12 characters in it, or tiers whose definitions are contradictory.

which ghost rider??

Aquaman low herald yes

wwh high herald yes

wbh high herald yes he's not otherwise cuz he can't wish amp outside of that one comic hulk can still go worldbreaker he just won't be as op.

Dr strange should be high herald to trans

ironman mid herald yes

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. Yes
Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. Yes
Doctor Strange to High Herald. Yes
Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. No
Ghost Rider to Low Herald. Yes
Hammerhead to Low Meta. Yes
Iceman to Mid Herald. Yes
Iron Man to Low Herald. Yes
Nimrod to High Herald. Yes
Nova Prime to Mid Herald. Yes
Shaman X-Man to High Herald. Yes
Ultron to High Herald. Yes
WBH to Trans. No

Originally posted by mighty adam
Aquaman low herald yes

wwh high herald yes

wbh high herald yes he's not otherwise cuz he can't wish amp outside of that one comic hulk can still go worldbreaker he just won't be as op.

Dr strange should be high herald to trans

ironman mid herald yes

Originally posted by TheHulk
Enough with the damned wish amp thing! anyone who thinks WBH was amped by the well is a clear cut fool for this topic! clear cut fool!

Wally west should be made high herald

ice man to mid herald hmmm he has the powerset to be high but no really good feats so no and no

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald - For.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Iron Man to Low Herald - For.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Originally posted by mighty adam
your a clear fool to think otherwise

1.BZ it! though admittingly i'm reluctant to do one.

or

2.create a thread and put it to a poll!

lol you will see,whose right or wrong...

All right, i'm closing this. I've already caught up with most of the votes, and i'll be crossing some people off of the list. anyone who isn't definitively ready to be moved will be included in the next round of votes.