KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald

Circe to Mid Herald

Doctor Strange to High Herald against

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald

Ghost Rider to Low Herald

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta

Hammerhead to Low Meta

Iceman to Mid Herald for.....will pm scans

Infinity Man to Trans

Iron Man to Low Herald

Nimrod to High Herald

Nova Prime to Mid Herald

Shaman X-Man to High Herald

If its Superior Spider-Man then Mid Meta

Ultron to High Herald (classic) current trans

WBH to Trans

WWH to high herald

Quasar to Mid
Black Bolt to High
Diana Pre-dcnu full gear to high
Imperiex probes to Low
Snowbird to mid
Doom to Mid

Originally posted by -Pr-
No new ones until these are done 😛

my bad

Don't worry, you weren't the only one. Just make note of them for the next time for when the thread is reopened.

Originally posted by Cogito
Damn. Seems a little late now, but this should probably be handled one tier at a time. Getting pretty ugly with the tallying process.

My 2 cents for what it's worth: The Mid-Herald group is pretty broken. Most of those characters are generally considered HH on these boards. I don't really think anyone thinks of anyone as a mid-herald. Either the herald tier should be better defined (with HH being more exclusive than generally regarded), or most of the mid-herald players need to move.

PS: There's even some mid-heralds that I would consider Trans

PPS: If you really want to do this right, you could create an Excel spreadsheet with every character. Assign #s to tiers (e.g. Low street = 1, mid street = 2, etc). Let people fill it in as they see fit (don't need to assign a ranking to every character since most people aren't all that familiar with every character, copy/paste them all into a master list, and average it out).

👆 👆

We should make this like the church does when trying to canonize a person.

Present the evidence for or against and then judges can decide based on that.

That will bring a lot of light about the characters and the battlezone will be pretty busy. 😄

Hey, I'm already tallying up the votes; you want to give me MORE work? 😂

Edit: Sorry I just saw the "no more votes for now" post.

You can vote for existing ones, just not suggest new ones.

In that case
For the original ones:

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For
Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For
Circe to Mid Herald. - For
Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For
Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For
Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For
Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For
Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against
Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against
Infinity Man to Trans. - For
Iron Man to Low Herald - For
Nimrod to High Herald - For
Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For
Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For
Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For
Ultron to High Herald. - For
WBH to Trans. - Against
WBH to High Herald. - For
WWH to High Herald. - For

Originally posted by -Pr-
Hey, I'm already tallying up the votes; you want to give me MORE work? 😂

You're welcome to it, if you like.

Only two I'll say are

Iron man to low herald: for

Spider-man to mid meta: for

Guys, stop asking questions, stop debating, stop arguing, stop baiting. Vote with a for or an against and let people make their own (un)informed decisions.

If you want to prove that someone should be at a certain level, create a VS thread with them - ideally against someone of a higher/same level if you want to move them up or lower/same if you want to move them down - and prove your case there.

You keep spamming the thread and it's just going to devolve into a thousand pages of bickering. I'd actually like this tier system to get updated. Each time you deviate from that is another reason the Mods have for closing the thread and throwing the idea away.

He's right, and he's only repeating what's been said already.

Because he doesn't want the tiers thread to end up like the last one, maybe.

Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - Against.

Circe to Mid Herald. - Against.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - Against.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta -Against.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to "MID" Herald - For.

Nimrod to High Herald.

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - Against.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Ultron to High Herald. - For.

WBH to Trans. - For.

WWH to High Herald. - For.

Originally posted by Raisen
He is right, but I question the intention. Why would a poster be doing this?

brownie points......but he is right, even if he is backseat modding

Originally posted by Tony Stark
Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.

Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - Against.

Circe to Mid Herald. - Against.

Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.

Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - Against.

Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.

Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta -Against.

Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.

Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.

Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to "MID" Herald - For.

Nimrod to High Herald.

Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For.

Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - Against.

Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.

Ultron to High Herald. - For.

WBH to Trans. - For.

WWH to High Herald. - For.

this isn't for new votes, just ones that have already been listed.

Originally posted by -Pr-
You're welcome to it, if you like.

I will warn people and discuss temp bans with other mods if you all insist on posting spam, senseless blather, arguments, etc. Get it through your skulls and stop, or test me.

Originally posted by Badabing
Nope, this is your project. biscuits

I will warn people and discuss temp bans with other mods if you all insist on posting spam, senseless blather, arguments, etc. Get it through your skulls and stop, or test me.

😂

WBH for high herald. For.

Remember those times I had a hard time arguing Kang for low herald? Now people want frigging Iron Man and Aquaman on it 🙁

Kang can beat both... At once.

So Kang for Mid Herald 😈