Re: Re: KMC Comic Book tiers 1st Voting thread
Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Adam Warlock to Mid Herald. - For.Aquaman (DCNU) to Low Herald. - For.
Circe to Mid Herald. - For.
Doctor Strange to High Herald. - For.
Flash (Wally West) to High Herald. - For.
Ghost Rider to Low Herald. - For.
Green Goblin (Osborn) to Mid Meta - For.
Hammerhead to Low Meta. - Against.
Iceman to Mid Herald. - Against.
Infinity Man to Trans. - For.
.
Iron Man to Low Herald - For.Nimrod to High Herald.
Nova Prime to Mid Herald - For.
Shaman X-Man to High Herald. - For.
Spider-Man to Mid Meta. - For.
Ultron to High Herald. - For. Some of his incarnations belong in Trans.
WBH to Trans. - For.
WBH to High Herald. - See above.
WWH to High Herald. - For.
agree with this^
Originally posted by yaadaveyaaSentry with all his matter manipluation,Telepathic abilites and immortality power,should be a trans,your right but since this ain't his peak lol his at best a Low trans.
sentry needs to be trans lvl in my opinion especially a voided out sentry (and prob not the right place but they need to be the same person as the comics intend)
Originally posted by TheHulk
Sentry with all his matter manipluation,Telepathic abilites and immortality power,should be a trans,your right but since this ain't his peak lol his at best a Low trans.
i would say low trans is fair he def belongs there tho i think they had voidtry listed as high herald originally he needs to b higher that was my vote but i dont think i get one im not sure
Originally posted by yaadaveyaaNote:This ain't a vote.
i would say low trans is fair he def belongs there tho i think they had voidtry listed as high herald originally he needs to b higher that was my vote but i dont think i get one im not sure
The Sentry-High Herald to Low Trans
Voidtry-Low Trans to Mid Trans
The Void-High Trans.
This is what tier I think they are in.
I haven't read everything, and I'm indifferent on various votes, but on the other thread's discussion of creating a Skyfather tier:
The definition of the Trans. tier makes an attempt at a Skyfather tier tricky. Because technically Trans. was created to go up to Odin (but not include him). Technically entire pantheons should be in Trans. but we omitted them because it muddied the waters and nobody really cared. So to actually create a Skyfather tier - that includes characters as powerful as the other pantheon heads - you'd have to dip into Trans. a little bit. You'd also have to redefine Trans. so that its upper limit is at a different point.
Otherwise, Odin would theoretically be the weakest of the Skyfather tier. It makes sense to cap the tier at him, but that would require redrawing the lines on Trans.
Just some food for thought. If you turkeys are committed to this, I might as well give a little guidance here and there.
Originally posted by Digi
I haven't read everything, and I'm indifferent on various votes, but on the other thread's discussion of creating a Skyfather tier:The definition of the Trans. tier makes an attempt at a Skyfather tier tricky. Because technically Trans. was created to go up to Odin (but not include him). Technically entire pantheons should be in Trans. but we omitted them because it muddied the waters and nobody really cared. So to actually create a Skyfather tier - that includes characters as powerful as the other pantheon heads - you'd have to dip into Trans. a little bit. You'd also have to redefine Trans. so that its upper limit is at a different point.
Otherwise, Odin would theoretically be the weakest of the Skyfather tier. It makes sense to cap the tier at him, but that would require redrawing the lines on Trans.
Just some food for thought. If you turkeys are committed to this, I might as well give a little guidance here and there.
couldnt you make the skyfather tier be solely those individuals who are Odins equals? with no lows or highs while the trans tier be split into two subcats.