Hero of Tython and Lord Scourge vs. ROTS Sidious and ROTS Kenobi

1. Pure saber combat

2. All-out

Setting: Naboo plains

Sidious speedblitzes Scourage rightofthebat then Kenobi engages the Hero(im sure he could last like 15seconds against the Hero in saber combat, right?). Then Sidious jumps over and the two PWN the Hero.

Sidious would probably blitz them both for a solo victory.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Sidious would probably blitz them both for a solo victory.

You do realize the Hero beat Vitiate, right?

Well they don't have any good speed feats so they get blitzed. Remember, Sidious blitzed a guy who was so fast that he could blur his lightsaber into a cyclone!

Spoiler:
JK

Anyway, team 2 should win.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
You do realize the Hero beat Vitiate, right?

I don't see Sidious blitzing the HoT, but nor do I think that the latter has the feats to beat or really compete with Sidious in a forum duel.

Maybe, but I definitely don't see Sidous blitzing him.

I can point to my rather impressive list of Hero of Tython feats, but at the end of the day the HoT is the new Revan, where she's obviously near top-tier, but due to a lack of feats and information about her abilities we can't actually debate in her favor versus those who should be on her level.

She's a she? Didn't know that was confirmed.

But I'd say beating the supremely powerful Emperor puts her in the top-tier list, not near top-tier.

My HoT is a she.

Yes. *cue someone claiming Vitiate is Dooku level*

Originally posted by Nephthys
*cue someone claiming Vitiate is Dooku level*

Who the hell would say that? Clearly Vitiate is below Dooku's level.

biscuits

fffuuu

LOL.

Yeah, that's so not true.

Both teams can win or loose depending upon the circumstances and setting, IMO.

HoT and Scourge are excellent swordsmen in their own right much like individuals of Team 2. Once again, it is impossible to determine that which individual is the finest swordsman in this contest. A case can be made for HoT being a match for Sidious in martial aspects of combat at minimum.

Also, Scourge shouldn't be underestimated. He have his share of victories and losses which is the case with almost every prominent character but his accomplishment on the whole is extremely impressive even by Star Wars standards.

Hero of Tython, Lord Scourge and ROTS Kenobi vs ROTS Sidious would be much closer.

^^^ overkill for Sidious.

HoT is both:-

1. Among the most powerful Force-users of the mythos
2. Among extraordinarily talented combatants of the mythos

Not just hype but actual credibility.

The fact that HoT defeated Vitiate should be enough to rank him among the best of the best.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
^^^ overkill for Sidious.

HoT is both:-

1. Among the most powerful Force-users of the mythos
2. Among extraordinarily talented combatants of the mythos

Not just hype but actual credibility.

Uh, both of these points would also apply to Obi Wan, and Agen Kolar.

He isn't beating Sidious.
Scourge isn't beating soresu-god Kenobi.

They die.

The Hero of Tython is way above Obi-Wan and Agen Kolar though. 😬