The Official Tier List of Comic Book Ranks For Non-Comic Characters

Started by Wei Phoenix55 pages
Originally posted by Sacred 117
Uhh... who is this about?

Stewie Griffin. His strength is always situational to a joke or gag. Huey and Riley Freeman are more consistent than he is.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
Good hasn't the same destructive capacity as Evil due to lack of Beast form alone, which is evident of Good not seeking power, and thus having less. Omni-Cole is, of course, a combination of both, which broadens his power spectrum significantly.
Ohh I thought you means just good vs evil without the beast. Theres already Cole and Cole!Beast in the tier lis, and Cole!Beast wouldn't gain a boost from obtaining those ice powers.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Superhuman strength for a baby is still human strength and once again it's always situational, there are plenty of times when he can't break free of his parent's grasps, he's been carried to his room and to bed against his will numerous times while fighting to break free.
Cartoons are cool like that.

However unlike Peter or Homer, whose skills and superhuman damage soak are only situational, for Stewie it can at least become possible for the sheer amount of times its done which kinda syncs with what he should be capable of.

That and great marksmanship with laser guns :T

Originally posted by BloodRain
Ohh I thought you means just good vs evil without the beast. Theres already Cole and Cole!Beast in the tier lis, and Cole!Beast wouldn't gain a boost from obtaining those ice powers.

I still call for re-label to Good/Evil. Otherwise, 'Beast! Cole' arguably implies Evil Cole in Beast form, which is not perpetual, or even necessary for Mid Meta rank. I would still argue Good + Evil tier climbing. Cryokinesis isn't the only addition. Even his electrokinesis behaves differently depending on moral standing.

As a cartoon he's very inconsistent, I'll admit he's accurate, rarely seen him miss but in terms of physical strength he's as strong or weak as the joke/plot needs him to be. One second he can whoop Brian's ass and injure him, the next he can't break out of a hug or snap his child leash off. Looking at the low street levelers from the comic list, I see that a lot of them would whoop his ass in a fight.

Got a point there. For the sake of it, who's the minimum for mid street?

Originally posted by Sacred 117
I still call for re-label to Good/Evil. Otherwise, 'Beast! Cole' arguably implies Evil Cole in Beast form, which is not perpetual, or even necessary for Mid Meta rank. I would still argue Good + Evil climbing. Cryokinesis isn't the only addition. Even his electrokinesis behaves different depending on moral standing.

Evil Cole would just point to normal, pyro Cole. Beast Cole states that is only when using the powers of the Beast, not his own as they don't stack up. The reason Beast is in that tier is because that specific power can bring down attacking jets with a gesture and regenerate from atoms. His pyro and electro powers come after this, with the subtle variations of electricity and ice powers after that.

The OP has been edited with the first revision of the Tier List.

Major props to ScreamPaste for such awesome work helping everyone out. He did a bang up job!

I'm also going to stick this thread to the top of the forum so it will always be available.

Scream did great, you did great, this thread is great. I just have one question. The hell is fluttershy doing above applejack?

Originally posted by Impediment
The OP has been edited with the first revision of the Tier List.

Major props to ScreamPaste for such awesome work helping everyone out. He did a bang up job!

I'm also going to stick this thread to the top of the forum so it will always be available.

Thanks for the edits and making this official. 🙂 You may delete most of my original statements if you wish. I'd prefer it actually.

Originally posted by Impediment
Major props to ScreamPaste for such awesome work helping everyone out. He did a bang up job!
Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Scream did great, you did great, this thread is great.

By the mighty beard of Santa Clause, I nominate ScreamPaste to be official Tier Master!

Originally posted by Yamcha
I'm curious as to where the Undefeated of the East would rank

YouTube video

No love for the former King of Hearts ;~;?

Originally posted by Sacred 117
Thanks for the edits and making this official. 🙂 You may delete most of my original statements if you wish. I'd prefer it actually.

M'kay!

Can't look at that Zoidburg set and not smile..

Edit: This isnt the Bar O.o

Curious. Where would Mephiles the Dark rank?

Originally posted by Yamcha
No love for the former King of Hearts ;~;?

High meta, caught bullets.

He's physically comparable to Sonic with a ton more hax. Even though a clone army of him lost to Shadow, the hax could be enough for a tier jump.

Originally posted by NotAllThatEvil
Scream did great, you did great, this thread is great. I just have one question. The hell is fluttershy doing above applejack?
I missed one instance of Fluttershy, I was removing characters who were placed in more than one tier, or removing them from tiers they had the least votes in if they had multiple votes in one tier, for the front page version.
Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
High meta, caught bullets.

1 King of Hearts for High Meta.

Has anyone changed their vote on Stewie Griffon, and what should we do with Cole? He's in multiple tiers and needs to be discussed.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
High meta, caught bullets.
Ah thanks, yeah I wasn't too sure on Master Asia but for a man who beats up Gundams bare handed I would agree he fits right into High Meta haha.

Cole's actually only in one tier right now. We'll discuss that some time.

Originally posted by Wei Phoenix
Stewie Griffin. His strength is always situational to a joke or gag. Huey and Riley Freeman are more consistent than he is.

Where would you put Stewie? Also, I don't think Huey's actually won a fight against anyone but his brother Riley. mmm

I believe I see three votes for Master Asia as High Meta.

Tallying.

Originally posted by Sacred 117
Cole's actually only in one tier right now. We'll discuss that some time.

Cole is in two tiers, I think, he only shows up in one tier on the front page because he had multiple votes for one category and only a single for the others, so I edited the others out until he's finalized.