Darth Vader Vs Mace windu

When did he state that?

Originally posted by Intrepid37
When did he state that?

One of the commentaries stating he wanted the PT to show the prime of saber combat, and that in ROTJ you only get half machines and old men dueling.

Fairly sure it's about TPM in that they were able to pull of a fast duel because we see Jedi in their prime.

he is still slow...no matter how they twist it.
he is no Greivous...Now Greivous was Fast....Faster than Vader.
30 yrs ago?

That armor slowed him down...
You ain't moving that fast in armor unless you are all machine
when he was flesh he was fast I give him that.. but in armor and half machine I don't think so.

just because some comic book comes along and say Vader's fast and etc. doesn't mean he's
fastest,ever ....not without a price....if he is that fast then the fatigue factor is a factor...

And with the right Master...which is Mace...This super Vader just gave him more Dark energy to
feed on and take him down....shatterpoint will pick up the flaws of the armor and Vaapad will do
the rest....Vader's dead....Mace won this fight before we even thought to reply to this thread.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VCWOsOsdvSs -> 0:20+
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ErU0Mk7dqfs ->> from 00:00, its about "Golden Age of Jedi".
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=liEtSzWZPFo -> 0:10

Nothing proves that Kenobi is a better swordsman. But thanks for the info.

Kenobi beat and crippled Anakin/Vader says he IS the better swordsman.

That info proves nothing....He beat Anakin /Vader....
facts is facts.....All day long dead and buried...He beat him
He crippled him.
Whatelse is there to say we saw it..
We read it....
He's better than Anakin...he is the better swordsman.
Where Anakin only rivaled from what I seen and read only Dooku and Ventress...

The movies, the novels, the internet, its there you just don't want to accept it .
So look again I found it why can't you?

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Nothing proves that Kenobi is a better swordsman. But thanks for the info.

ROTS Kenobi is a better swordsman than TPM Vader. But Anakin is a vastly superior swordsman than ROTS Kenobi.

Yes, TPM Vader hadn't even learned to use the Force properly.

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Yes, TPM Vader hadn't even learned to use the Force properly.

That's BS.

Yeah, I mean, TPM Vader was what, nine years old?

ok,I see your point,if he is superior why did he....lose?
I see what you're saying but he still lost...badly I might add...

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Yeah, I mean, TPM Vader was what, nine years old?

Bullshit. TPM Vader already was soloing Sebulba. biscuits

I meant ANH Vader

Lol.

Yes, he's a better swordsman than ANH Vader, so what? This does not prove he's a superior swordsman to RotJ Vader.

Lol...point taken stalemate....for now...lol ...

Originally posted by Intrepid37
Lol.

Yes, he's a better swordsman than ANH Vader, so what? This does not prove he's a superior swordsman to RotJ Vader.

He is a superior swordsman to ROTJ Vader. There is literally no canon evidence pointing to Vader being at the peak of his swordsmanship in ROTJ. Force power, could be argued, but not swordsmanship.

Except, you know, he becomes a better swordsman in between ESB and ANH?

^
Sources?