Thor vs HP Doomsday (CIS off)

Started by -Pr-11 pages

Originally posted by ODG
Death of Superman was published 1992. Blood and Thunder was published in 1993.

I wasn't talking about DOS. Nice try though. 😛

Originally posted by -Pr-
Badge? I've got a ****ing crown and sceptre, dude.

Those too. 😛

Originally posted by -Pr-
I wasn't talking about DOS. Nice try though. 😛
If you were talking about Doomsday Wars, then a bloodlusted Thor's herald-level team-busting rampage preceded H/P Doomsday by 5 years then.

excellent

Originally posted by -Pr-
Badge? I've got a ****ing crown and sceptre, dude.

You HAD a crown and scepter is what you meant to say.

Originally posted by ODG
If you were talking about Doomsday Wars, then a bloodlusted Thor's herald-level team-busting rampage preceded H/P Doomsday by 5 years then.

excellent

Doesn't count because... uh... uh... yeah, I got it now.

It doesn't count because Doomsday easily beat Darkseid in that story. And since Darkseid is naturally over Thanos, that makes Thor less impressive because he had severe problems with Thanos while he had the Power Gem.
And really, if we can't use Darkseid as a shining example of consistent above herald physical might, then who can we use?

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Doesn't count because... uh... uh... yeah, I got it now.

It doesn't count because Doomsday easily beat Darkseid in that story. And since Darkseid is naturally over Thanos, that makes Thor less impressive because he had severe problems with Thanos while he had the Power Gem.
And really, if we can't use Darkseid as a shining example of consistent above herald physical might, then who can we use?

From h1a8's brain to your keyboard.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Like I said, you can write a lot of people as a team buster over their peers.

This is true. But when you have a character that is only written as a team buster (the DD in question) then they become more than a peer imo.

Originally posted by ODG
If you were talking about Doomsday Wars, then a bloodlusted Thor's herald-level team-busting rampage preceded H/P Doomsday by 5 years then.

excellent

😂

I never claimed to be a Thor expert.

Originally posted by Odekahn
This is true. But when you have a character that is only written as a team buster (the DD in question) then they become more than a peer imo.

I'm not going to argue, like I said I can see where people are coming from.

Originally posted by -Pr-

I'm not going to argue, like I said I can see where people are coming from.

That's fair. I can see your line of thought as well. 👆

There is nothing Thor could do toDD. The Godblast is weaker than the OB in that arc. Thor's lightning is weaker than his Godblast. DD heals instantly. DD evolves greater resistance on the fly. DD evolves counter measures in the fly.

I want to hear one good argument how Thor can win.

Originally posted by -Pr-
Guys, get back on topic.

Abhi, stop carvering Superman.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Don't do this to me bro.

🙁

Originally posted by -Pr-
😂

Also, on topic, Thor wins, imo. I'm probably one of the few people that ranks HP/DD as high herald without hating him because he's DC.


High Herald?

facepalm

Its true that people like superman have better feats since then but he still isn't that much stronger than people like Orion who haven't got much feats since then as seen in DOTNG. Doomsday beating the shit out of J'onn and Orion in 52 seconds is beyond any high herald's capability.

Also lulz @ comparing B&T Thor to doomsday. Even DOS Doomsday would push his shit in. Guess I'm the only guy who remember BRB pushing his shit in under one page while heavily wounded no less.

Originally posted by abhilegend
High Herald?

facepalm

Its true that people like superman have better feats since then but he still isn't that much stronger than people like Orion who haven't got much feats since then as seen in DOTNG. Doomsday beating the shit out of J'onn and Orion in 52 seconds is beyond any high herald's capability.

At best, I would rate HP/DD, by current standards, as a low trans. Maybe mid at a stretch.

So listen, mister "ive destroyed the credibility of Superman fans on this forum", don't even attempt to patronise me.

😂

Originally posted by abhilegend
Also lulz @ comparing B&T Thor to doomsday. Even DOS Doomsday would push his shit in. Guess I'm the only guy who remember BRB pushing his shit in under one page while heavily wounded no less.

So let's ignore Thor stomping him prior to and after. Let's draw our conclusions for these scans alone and continue to make random claims. Thor beat Bill multiple times, Pluto and Ares, surfer and warlock, etc.

Beastly. Thor beats Doomsday.

Originally posted by -Pr-
At best, I would rate HP/DD, by current standards, as a low trans. Maybe mid at a stretch.

So listen, mister "ive destroyed the credibility of Superman fans on this forum", don't even attempt to patronise me.


That's acceptable. Anybody who can break an amped Superman's arm like a twig isn't high herald.

I didn't do anything but state what is on panel. Its not my fault that people are so close minded. I always post proofs in my favor. Also I wasn't patronizing you. I apologize if that seemed that way.

Originally posted by -Pr-
At best, I would rate HP/DD, by current standards, as a low trans. Maybe mid at a stretch.

So listen, mister "ive destroyed the credibility of Superman fans on this forum", don't even attempt to patronise me.

Originally posted by Galan007
😂

Originally posted by abhilegend
Its not my fault that people are so close minded. I always post proofs in my favor.

The irony threatened to overwhelm me.

Originally posted by Damborgson

The irony threatened to overwhelm me.


😂

You're still cool dambo. Just accept Superman is the king of feats.

With CIS off, here is exactly what I would do if I was Thor. Toss Mjolnir just right so that the strap at the base of the handle snags the bone protruding from Doomsdays' chest. While he's face down in the dirt, and unable to get back to his feet I'd God blast the shit out of him.