Originally posted by quanchi112A lot, but not as strong as the LotR ones. Sure they'd prove useful against the humans, but when faced against stronger beasts, they will fall. Useful magic, just not great in the grand scheme of things.
Narnia has air support and a lot of beasts as well. The Minotaurs, Centaurs, etc. would assault normal men in combat such as from Westeros which comprise the bulk of the their army.We see her magic negate fire altogether. She can turn anyone into a statue is very powerful.
And just because I have not yet said so, I believe Westeros as of yet consists of the weakest army here.
Originally posted by BloodRainSo you agree Narnia beats Westeros. You agree with me. Everyone keeps riding my coattails.A lot, but not as strong as the LotR ones. Sure they'd prove useful against the humans, but when faced against stronger beasts, they will fall. Useful magic, just not great in the grand scheme of things.
And just because I have not yet said so, I believe Westeros as of yet consists of the weakest army here.
Originally posted by BloodRain
And just because I have not yet said so, I believe Westeros as of yet consists of the weakest army here.
The weakest, but likely the largest. Altogether Westeros can field about 210,000 men (Stark - 40,000 Lannister - 60,000 Baratheon - 100,000 Daenerys - 8,000). I don't know about Narnia but at most they have less than 10,000 just from eyeballing the battle scenes. Middle Earth has quite a lot of orcs, but I don't think they have as much as GoT.
Magic and better troops are good, but against overwhelming numbers they just don't match up. Beasts are good fighters, but 4 peasants with spears will still easily dispatch 1 of them. I think its obvious that Narnia is basically a non-entity here.
Originally posted by UtrigitaSeems that way, but it also depends on what period we're discussing it from. If it's all beings in Middle Earth the later in the series we discuss the harder it becomes. At the end of LoTR Sauron is crippled, Smaug is gone, I'm not sure any Balrogs remains, the Wizards are reduced save perhaps Gandalf, the undead army is dispersed, and most armies have been completely decimated from war.
On a more serious note, Middle Earth ripes the other two apart.
I'm not going to comment on who would win in any definitive way, though, because this is restricted to the movies and I can't recall much from the Narnia movies and have not seen Game of Thrones.
Also, Westeros has wildfire, which could seriously nuke the opposing armies if positioned correctly (by Tyrion).
1.40.
Originally posted by NephthysWhy can't the Queen of Narnia put it out ?
Also, Westeros has wildfire, which could seriously nuke the opposing armies if positioned correctly (by Tyrion).1.40.
