Middle Earth vs. Westeros vs. Narnia

Actually, the Wildlings are on Westeros, since Westeros is the name of the continent, not the country. Thats the Seven Kingdoms.

A nice effort though. 😉

I included Dany and the Dothraki because quan has talked about allowing them.

Point about the Wildlings, but the Dothraki and Daenerys and friends are not in Westeros. I am sure quan will see my reasoning.

No taksies backsies.

Also, the wildlings have giants and mammoths, so Westeros isn't completely devoid of monsterous creatures, Quan.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I included Dany and the Dothraki because quan has talked about allowing them.

If I recall correctly, it was you who brought them up in the first place, by mentioning the 8000 Unsullied from Dany.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Since you cried they are allowed. It changes nothing and they still lose.

Do you disagree ?

Originally posted by Utrigita
If I recall correctly, it was you who brought them up in the first place, by mentioning the 8000 Unsullied from Dany.

Yeah, but Quan allowed it.

I meant included them in my tally of combined numbers.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Yeah, but Quan allowed it.

I meant included them in my tally of combined numbers.

To be used in the battle, or just be used as a indication of what the entire world of A song of fire and Ice could field?

Originally posted by NemeBro
Point out where I said that fgt.

On the other hand, you said that because we don't see 100,000 people, we can't use them. What an idiot.

Westeros wins.

Originally posted by quanchi112
We can see the cgi simulate these kinds of numbers. I gave them credit for the unsullied. You're lucky.

And if the Unsullied are allowed, I don't see with Drogo's khalasar shouldn't be.

Originally posted by Epicurus
So you concede that the Westeros armies number in the hundreds of thousands. Good. You're beginning to catch up, boy.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I don't *know*, but we can only go by what is shown. Wildfire is shown to be extremely destructive and difficult to put out. Phoenix fire has shown nothing. It drew a line in the grass. Whoopii.

The combined forces of all the Narnia movies gets stomped.

Originally posted by The Scenario
And is that it? It burned basically nothing but grass and some flesh. That some monsters didn't want to get burned isn't a feat.

So you have nothing.

Are you allowing the Dothraki and the Unsullied Quan?

Originally posted by NemeBro
Are you allowing the Dothraki and the Unsullied Quan?

Originally posted by quanchi112
It burned those it touches just like fire. Wtf. Halted a gigantic army and the Queen easily dispelled it.

Just like normal fire, woo. So it has no feats to put it above normal fire, while Wildfire apparently has feats of melting steel?

Wildfire is clearly better in that case.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Yes.

Then it's not Westeros, it's Essos and Westeros. I take it your including the Telmar as well?

Originally posted by Utrigita
Then it's not Westeros, it's Essos and Westeros. I take it your including the Telmar as well?

Originally posted by The Scenario
Just like normal fire, woo. So it has no feats to put it above normal fire, while Wildfire apparently has feats of melting steel?

Wildfire is clearly better in that case.

Originally posted by quanchi112
it is magical though in nature since the Phoenix is magical. Magic put it out. Why is wildfire better iyo ?

Fire always wins🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
it is magical though in nature since the Phoenix is magical. Magic put it out. Why is wildfire better iyo ?

Why would magic make it better? Does that make it stronger? (If so, prove it.) Does that make it harder to put out? (If so, prove it.)

"Magical" by itself does not mean anything.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Entire fictional worlds of each one save modern technology and the like as in Narnia.

Though they did not need it. Gregor Clegane solos.