Revan/Bane v. Mace/Yoda

Started by Stealth Moose11 pagesPoll

Who wins?

Revan/Bane v. Mace/Yoda

Setting is a food court in a mall.

No PIS. Each is bloodlusted. Peak version of each canonically. (As in, no Darth Yoda)

Bonus round: Purely H2H version of the same fight.

"I'm just entirely out of Star Wars at the moment."
-Stealth Moose, Feburary 5th 2014

Your back? Anyway, I'm undecided at the moment. Bane and Yoda are comparable if Bane has his orbiskals, same goes for Revan against Mace. However, I feel the close quarters will give Revan a disadvantage, leading to the Jedi team's victory.

I'm just really really bored at work. Plus nothing else was lively around here.

I'll go for the latter two. They've got a few advantages, like having actually worked together and knowing each others styles, and they each performed well against a stronger Sith than Bane.

Not easily, what with Bane's armor, but I still bet on the latter.

Team 2. Better dueling skill, better physical feats, better Force powers.

Team 2 10/10. Revan has no feats to compete with Mace and Yoda and Bane, while more powerful than Revan, is still inferior to both Yoda and Mace.

Lol.

Assertions without evidence should be dismissed without evidence. Make your cases known here, not your opinions.

Is Bane equipped with his orbalisk armor?

Read the OP.

Some define peak versions as the strongest version of the character without some outside amplification, i.e no one would reference Dooku on Vjun if the OP said Dooku was at his strongest.

Standard gear is not the same as Nexus boosting. The location is a food court, so if you think a mall food court is a Force nexus, explain why.

The orbalisk armor could hardly be qualified as standard gear, though.

Why not? It was fused to his body for 10 years.

Because he has a lot of showings without them equipped. I'd agree with you if Exar's gauntlet was the amplifying item in question as he has very few [if any?] showings without them, but Bane? No.

Its standard gear of Banes strongest version.

Bane's strongest version without gear is almost certainly in Dynasty of Evil.

Why are you adamant that he not have orbalisks?

I'm not. I was asking if it was the case.

Because then he has a chance.

Banes strongest version is ROT. This is because of his orbalisks, but such a thing is irrelevant because they are standard gear for him in that version.

I don't see a reason to hamstring him. Orbalisks were standard gear for his peak form.