Superman won't be able to hurt the Surfer.
Though his feats were scarce, we can infer the Surfer's power. He can easily transmute large masses of matter (making the holes), fly at incredible speeds, and turning himself into a planet-buster killer was powerful, though seemingly suicidal.
So considering the above, I'd bank on the guy who could possibly hurt the other guy, Surfer ftw.
Originally posted by God Cloth Seiya
Doom had stolen surfers powers and he could still get touched. Superman wins
Doom never showed the skill Surfer had with his powers, as he only had them for a short while. Surfer on the other hand reached near orbit in seconds, toyed with Johnny, easily phased through matter, batted aside missiles, and phased right through Sue's force field.
Originally posted by KingD19
Surfer can go intangible at a moments notice. So as soon as Supes moves he'd just fly through him.
No version of the Surfer beats this guy:
h**p://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Powers_and_abilities_of_Superman