Originally posted by carter9
😕
Since that guy brought-up speed, you never gave a reason why Thor wins scenario 2. Even if Mjolnir does give him some type of striking advantage, have a reason why that would balance out the speed advantage when someone slower and weaker than Supes did this to Thor?
http://s1199.photobucket.com/user/Delta1938/library/Alternates/Miscellaneous/Mongoose/THOR_408
Originally posted by riv6672
I call it 7-10 Superman in scenario one.
Both characters are mostly equal in strength and against energy attacks, but Superman's been shown to have an edge in strike damage and blunt force trauma. It'll serve him well here.I call it 8-10 Thor in scenario two.
As shown quite well in JLA/Avengers, where he needed all the help he could get in the final battle, Superman cant strike with the power of Mjolnir, which he'll be facing, and he's not as invulnerable as Captain America's shield, which Thor has dented.
Superman will get more hits in using his speed, but the hits Thor gets in will do greater damage. Two roughly equal opponents, one with a weapon, which the other cant take away and use, is what it breaks down to.Also, if quoting oneself when no one responds and trolling
Is going to be the gist of the thread, now that i've made my point, i...am...outta here! 👆
Originally posted by BentleyThat kid the teen titans put in a coma. Heavens no. I mean Thanos the master of all.
You might be confusing Thanos with Superboy Prime.How do you figure a hammerless Thor is as strong and durable as Superman for the first match? My take on their feats don't add to that.
He has more damage soak, has a higher pain tolerance, and has more warrior training.
Thor splits despite not being as strong.
Originally posted by Bentley
You might be confusing Thanos with Superboy Prime.How do you figure a hammerless Thor is as strong and durable as Superman for the first match? My take on their feats don't add to that.
Considering how much of a Superman hater and detractor he is, him saying Thor only gets an even split is effectively a vote for Superman wins.
Superman wins both scenarios
Second scenario is more interesting as historically Thor has been shown to have SOME problems with speed more often than not, but speed is not an auto win vs Thor of course depending on the writer
Superman is know to have some problem with magic,but unknown to most non-Superman readers magic is not a auto win tool vs Superman of course depending on the writer
Based on this two things, I believe Superman will have the advantage in the second scenario but Thor could have variable ratio from 3 to 5 wins out of 10 on the second scenario.
The first scenario in my opinion Thor has the disadvantage he could probably win 1 out of 10.
Originally posted by quanchi112
That kid the teen titans put in a coma. Heavens no. I mean Thanos the master of all.
At least SBP can take anti-matter without being reduced to a skeleton 😖hifty:
Originally posted by quanchi112
He has more damage soak, has a higher pain tolerance, and has more warrior training.Thor splits despite not being as strong.
I'll give you the warrior training. Which damage soak feat strikes you as being above Superman?
Originally posted by BentleyThat was a weakened Thanos. Context, kiddo. Am was also weakened in that scene. 🙂
At least SBP can take anti-matter without being reduced to a skeleton 😖hifty:I'll give you the warrior training. Which damage soak feat strikes you as being above Superman?
The Teen Titans aren't bludgeoning Thanos like they did to Boy Prime.
Thor being tortured and fighting with serious injuries when he was cursed.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Thor wins 5 out of 10 in both.
jawdrop Quani is giving Superman a 1/2 and 1/2 ratio vs Thor???
That is a surprise development I have never expected
Honestly coming from Quanchi this is a victory for the House of El.
Seriously if Quan thinks this We should just leave it that and thank him for his opinion.
Originally posted by quanchi112Thor splits despite not being as strong.
Translation Superman is stronger than Thor
This is coming from Quan
jawdropjawdropjawdrop
Originally posted by Bentley
At least SBP can take anti-matter without being reduced to a skeleton 😖hifty:I'll give you the warrior training. Which damage soak feat strikes you as being above Superman?
That just shows either her inability to read, or her desperation on detracting Superman. This is a standard slugfest and a modified slugfest, skill/training is irrelevant.
But, even though expanding on Thor's skill is off-topic, I should point-out Orion beats Thor here on paper and in practice from what I've seen, and it's never been any real advantage against Superman after his DOS era power level.