Khan Noonien Singh vs. Palpatine

Started by quanchi11293 pages

Originally posted by playa1258
Curbstomp for Palpatine.
Based on ?

Originally posted by Robtard
So someone who hits some targets and misses others is "superhumanly accurate"? LoLz.

Anyhow. Characters like Legolas and even Hawkeye have what would be considered super-human accuracy. See now?

You have to remember who you're talking to, even if Khan missed 99.9% of his shots, quan would claim that the .1% of the time Khan hit his target would be proof that he's "superhumanly accurate".

Originally posted by Silent Master
You have to remember who you're talking to, even if Khan missed 99.9% of his shots, quan would claim that the .1% of the time Khan hit his target would be proof that he's "superhumanly accurate".
Kirk referred to his actions in that scene as extraordinary. They also referred to him as a superman based off that scene. Quit ignoring the evidence.

Are people supposed to care about their opinions?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Are people supposed to care about their opinions?
Considering they were involved in the scene. It's evidence. You can pretend he was not portrayed as superhuman in the scene. It's amusing to me so see you act this way.

It's evidence of their opinion, but why should anyone care about their opinion?

Originally posted by Silent Master
It's evidence of their opinion, but why should anyone care about their opinion?
Their opinion matters and is evidence. He saw it and considered it superhuman. Do you think the director portrayed him as superhuman in the scene ?

Why does their opinion matter?

Originally posted by Silent Master
Why does their opinion matter?
They are in the movie describing what they saw. Do you feel they were wrong ?

You still haven't told my why their opinions matter.

Originally posted by Silent Master
You still haven't told my why their opinions matter.
I just said so. You refuse to answer my questions while I answered yours. You're such a silly troll.

No, you just keep repeating that it's their opinion about what happened, I'm asking why should anyone care what their opinion is.

Picard is right

Palpatine wins and Quan is busy crying in his racecar bed right now.

Originally posted by quanchi112
In the film we see him handle the lightning. Palpatine gets scarred. 💃

Final version, sport.

Windu beat Palpatine. abc logic. Different fighting styles and environment. Windu won. Fact.

To be fair, windu was struggling in both movies and books. In the books he says he can't handle fighting against his own blade since Sidious was bending it. Also it's recognized that Sidious used a SITH mask technique which was needed for his double life. His face was already basically like that windu just used Sidious lightning to burn it off.

To be fair to both. The newer versions are the ones Lucas wants cannon.

I'm of the opinion that Sidious threw the fight however more than enough evidence points to the other direction however this evidence that points to him throwing the fight. I just wanted to clear up that, Lucas considers the newer version over the older ones I think

Originally posted by quanchi112
Not in the same skill sets as Khan. How strong ?

We see them comment on the force not a force user. Palpatine isn't the force nor can anyone use the force in this manner. He was referencing the force itself.

😂

He was able to push back maul someone who we know is definitely strong and he was able to hold back the strikes of windu someone who was amped with vaapad.

Well he sure is commented as being the nearest thing to the son we have. He is know as a black hole in the force just like nihlus and vitiate. However I understand that he said the force and not a force user. Unlike you I can actually comprehend movies by myself. Sidious however is powerful second only too Luke and his knowledge and mastery force is not to be underestimated and with that speaks a high volume of power in which he could easily destroy khan. What does khan have agaisn't I don't know precog with force speed and lightening capable of burning someone to ash.

Originally posted by Silent Master
No, you just keep repeating that it's their opinion about what happened, I'm asking why should anyone care what their opinion is.
I already answered now you answer my question.

Originally posted by TheVaultDweller
Palpatine wins and Quan is busy crying in his racecar bed right now.
Proejcting. False. Khan would kill the old man.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
To be fair, windu was struggling in both movies and books. In the books he says he can't handle fighting against his own blade since Sidious was bending it. Also it's recognized that Sidious used a SITH mask technique which was needed for his double life. His face was already basically like that windu just used Sidious lightning to burn it off.

To be fair to both. The newer versions are the ones Lucas wants cannon.

I'm of the opinion that Sidious threw the fight however more than enough evidence points to the other direction however this evidence that points to him throwing the fight. I just wanted to clear up that, Lucas considers the newer version over the older ones I think

He prevailed though. Palpatinr was under his mercy. Speculation. We see Thr lightning scar him and Palaptine later even mentions this before the senate. See I use movie evidence. I'm exceptional.

Lucas is no longer in charge. To be fair it's Disney's show now. 🙂

You have no evidence to support the claim. This sums up your debating. Bias and claims you can't prove. Lucas is out, kiddo.

Originally posted by EmperorSidious2
He was able to push back maul someone who we know is definitely strong and he was able to hold back the strikes of windu someone who was amped with vaapad.

Well he sure is commented as being the nearest thing to the son we have. He is know as a black hole in the force just like nihlus and vitiate. However I understand that he said the force and not a force user. Unlike you I can actually comprehend movies by myself. Sidious however is powerful second only too Luke and his knowledge and mastery force is not to be underestimated and with that speaks a high volume of power in which he could easily destroy khan. What does khan have agaisn't I don't know precog with force speed and lightening capable of burning someone to ash.

Yes, he pushed back maul because his force powers were greater. His skill was also greater. He beat up someone less advanced win the same powerset as himself irrelevant to Khan.

Hyperbole. Nothing in the films support this flowery language which holds no value either way. So you admit the quote has no bearing on these versus match ups. I'm excellent.

Watch the film and find out. 🙂