Vindican vs. Darth Talon

Started by Q998 pages
Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD

Floor-shattering feat is indecisive. In addition, when some debris was hurled at her like a missile from Skywalker, she was not able to tank it and was knocked out for a while. In contrast, Lord Vindican tanked a missile as if it was nothing. Missile is much more lethal offensive weapon then some debris that is hurled like a missile towards a target and also more difficult to counter accordingly. This is clear depiction of disparity between the Force abilities of both.

Hah, 'some debris' as in an entire spaceship well over twice as tall as a person and fairly long. That's a massive understatement for the purpose of misleading there. Wredd took out Ania Solo with 'some debris' (Ania being a non-force user, he just took some loose metal and wrapper her in it). Talon was hit with a space ship. Do you know how many people survive having a spaceship thrown at them and not only survived but gotten into serious lightsaber duels later that day? Not many!

Not to mention, she was able to escape and call for reinforcements- not only the thrown ship didn't knock her out for long enough for anyone to find her and finish the job, we don't actually have a sign that it knocked her out at all. Cade's force power shown there combined with still having other more trained force users to worry about just made her rethink the 'go it solo' approach.

You have overhyped Talon too much but I killed the hype in my previous post.

Nope, you fail at that.

Darth Talon has superior TK to Vindican. Talon has superior dueling to Vindican. Talon has superior physical ability. Talon has superior illusion (did you know she has illusion? She does, she was able to disguise herself as Marasiah Fel via the force).

And what you come up with in response is comparing her to someone... who flat-out killed Vindican anyway. Someone can be weaker than Kao Cen Darach and still kill Vindican.

Talon have never defeated an opponent as powerful and capable as Kao Cen Darach in single combat

Arguable, Sazen and Shado have some very good feats (even putting aside Cade), but as others have pointed out, she's not fighting Kao Cen Darach anyway, she's fighting Vindican, who is no Kao Cen Darach, and couldn't even stay alive against KCD with Malgus fighting alongside him.

You are way overhyping the *third* most powerful person in that fight by somehow requiring her being stronger than the *second* most powerful as a bare-minimum to beat the *third*. Think about that for a moment.

and neither she have taken out Sith Inquisitors. Let go.

She's been promoted over Sith Inquisitors.

Originally posted by Q99
Hah, 'some debris' as in an entire spaceship well over twice as tall as a person and fairly long. That's a massive understatement for the purpose of misleading there.

This;

Sazen tells Cade to take Marasiah to his ship and flee but Cade chooses to stay using the Force to pick up a pile of junk and hurl it at Darth Talon knocking her into the trees. (Wookieepedia)

Here is an image:

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/File:Talon_Vendaxa.JPG

I am not sure if this is the same wreckage but doesn't seems like an object that a well-trained Force-user cannot handle.

Originally posted by Q99
Wredd took out Ania Solo with 'some debris' (Ania being a non-force user, he just took some loose metal and wrapper her in it). Talon was hit with a space ship. Do you know how many people survive having a spaceship thrown at them and not only survived but gotten into serious lightsaber duels later that day? Not many!

Firstly, stop exaggerating. Secondly, did you see how even young Malgus tore through a large starship engine while it was hurled at him like a missile? That starship engine is about the size of engine of a large passenger plane in real life. A large starship engine is a multi-tonned object full of machine inside it and ripping it apart in the manner as Malgus did requires great power, and experience can be lethal since this ripping apart a starship or aeroplane engine results in a powerful explosion but Malgus was unfazed and not injured.

Later on, Malgus tanked a missile that was fired at him by Jace Malcom, he did suffer some injuries from this development but he was fine. In-fact, Lord Vindican also found himself in the same situation as Malgus did on Aldeeran but the former not just outright tanked the missile but even dissipated the explosion of the missile in the process, more impressive.

I also recall Anakin Skywalker getting buried beneath large rocks inside a cave, rocks representing chunks of the ceiling of the cave that were ripped apart by Count Dooku to crush Anakin Skywalker beneath but the Jedi Knight broke free from the debris without much issue a while afterwards and was not injured.

These are the details that you need to focus upon. I think that both Lord Vindican and Darth Malgus can handle stuff that was thrown at Darth Talon. How many do you think have demonstrated the capability to tank missiles? Few.

Originally posted by Q99
Not to mention, she was able to escape and call for reinforcements- not only the thrown ship didn't knock her out for long enough for anyone to find her and finish the job, we don't actually have a sign that it knocked her out at all. Cade's force power shown there combined with still having other more trained force users to worry about just made her rethink the 'go it solo' approach.

I understand the part about bringing allies but your exaggerations other then this part are an issue.

Originally posted by Q99
Nope, you fail at that.

Darth Talon has superior TK to Vindican. Talon has superior dueling to Vindican. Talon has superior physical ability. Talon has superior illusion (did you know she has illusion? She does, she was able to disguise herself as Marasiah Fel via the force).

And what you come up with in response is comparing her to someone... who flat-out killed Vindican anyway. Someone can be weaker than Kao Cen Darach and still kill Vindican.


1. Have we seen Lord Vindican's telekinetic actions? Can we draw a comparison here? Nope. But since he is a Sith Inquisitor, it is logical to assume that he doesn't sucks with TK.

2. Superior dueling to Lord Vindican based on what? Lord Vindican went toe-to-toe against Kao Cen Darach for a decent amount of time. Kao Cen Darach have demonstrated much superior dueling ability then Darth Talon, unfortunately for you. Quite babbling and exaggerating.

3. Talon have superior physical ability? Vindican performed acrobatic actions, dodged Darach's assaults, survived lightsaber stab on his face and even the impalement action later on. Don't presume too much.

4. By virtue of being a Sith Inquisitor, Lord Vindican would have great understanding of the Force and might be aware of illusions based stuff.

5. Kao Cen Darach represents the benchmark for handling an opponent of Lord Vindican's caliber. Your speculation is baseless.

Originally posted by Q99
Arguable, Sazen and Shado have some very good feats (even putting aside Cade), but as others have pointed out, she's not fighting Kao Cen Darach anyway, she's fighting Vindican, who is no Kao Cen Darach, and couldn't even stay alive against KCD with Malgus fighting alongside him.

Did you watch the SWTOR Return trailer properly? I'd suggest you do it.

When the Jedi and Sith duos confronted each other, Darth Malgus fought Satele Shan while Lord Vindican fought Kao Cen Darach. As the duel progressed, Kao Cen Darach saved his apprentice's life from Malgus's killing blow but then she found herself getting subjected to Vindican's powers. Kao Cen Darach stopped Vindican from hurting Satele Shan by unleashing a blast of power on him at the right moment, and then convinced his apprentice to escape because she was utterly outclassed in this contest. After this, Kao Cen Darach began to fight both Malgus and Vindican simultaneously using multiple blades and successfully deflected Vindican's lightning towards Malgus with his extreme bladework and deflective capabilities which knocked out Malgus for a while. Then fight came back to 1 on 1 between Vindican and Darach but the latter had advantage of superior technical swordsmanship and was using multiple blades for dueling during this second phase, this permitted Darach to impale Vinidcan.

Stop generalizing and underestimating Vindican, focus on the available evidence.

Originally posted by Q99
You are way overhyping the *third* most powerful person in that fight by somehow requiring her being stronger than the *second* most powerful as a bare-minimum to beat the *third*. Think about that for a moment.

I am not overhyping anybody. I cam calling a spade a spade.

Originally posted by Q99
She's been promoted over Sith Inquisitors.

Her promotion is irrelevant to what Sith Inquisitors are capable of. She was so loyal to Darth Krayt that she was willing to give her life for him, such a puppet. No wonder, Krayt found her better candidate for being a Hand.

Sazen tells Cade to take Marasiah to his ship and flee but Cade chooses to stay using the Force to pick up a pile of junk and hurl it at Darth Talon knocking her into the trees. (Wookieepedia)

This is the image:

http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/File:Talon_Vendaxa.JPG

That picture is of Talon disarming the crew, but nice try. Cade throws a destroyed ship at Talon, and she recovers fairly quickly.

Talon is quite possibly my least favorite Sith LeGenD, but you are criminally underrating her.

This is the ship Cade throws:

Note how it's a lot taller than Cade.

And this shows just how far it is at the start (consider that with the size-perspective, the ships probably bigger than it looks), as well as some general Talon kicking butt:


1. Have we seen Lord Vindican's telekinetic actions? Can we draw a comparison here? Nope. But since he is a Sith Inquisitor, it is logical to assume that he doesn't sucks with TK.

'Not sucking' and 'as good as Talon' are two very different things.

2. Superior dueling to Lord Vindican based on what? Lord Vindican went toe-to-toe against Kao Cen Darach for a decent amount of time. Kao Cen Darach have demonstrated much superior dueling ability then Darth Talon, unfortunately for you.

Based on 'holding on for awhile- with help- and then dying' not being nearly as good as 'stabbing Cade in a practice duel,' 'holding on for a long time against known badasses and *not* dying,' and the page above.

And... Kao Cen Darach doesn't have all that much in the way of dueling feats himself. Don't get me wrong, he's good! But he's not, say, Ven Zallow.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Talon is quite possibly my least favorite Sith LeGenD, but you are criminally underrating her.

Maybe this is the object:

Seems like a starship part. I will check the comics today for greater clarity.

Please keep in mind that it is not my intention to criminally underestimate Darth Talon. However, I am noticing criminal underestimation of Lord Vindican.

Also, about the floor-shattering feat:

http://i20.photobucket.com/albums/b219/Q99/LegacyWar5TalonvsCade.jpg

This action is not on the scale on that of Lord Adraas, comics are very vague at depicting details properly (entire scenery omitted on purpose). I was correct, Talon was fighting Cade on a rocky surface and the magnitude of damage inflicted upon the floor is hard to determine because the floor was not a proper floor to begin with and scenery is not properly depicted.

Lord Adraas shattered a portion of a proper hardened floor inside the Jedi Temple, causing a nearby pillar to collapse and killing a dozen Republic troops in the process.

Originally posted by Q99
This is the ship Cade throws:

Note how it's a lot taller than Cade.

And this shows just how far it is at the start (consider that with the size-perspective, the ships probably bigger than it looks), as well as some general Talon kicking butt:


Thanks for providing some scans. I will check the comics as well.

However, these scenes do not properly depict the size of starship part. The top image is better at depicting the size though. Large object indeed.

Originally posted by Q99
'Not sucking' and 'as good as Talon' are two very different things.

You cannot even make a comparison in this case.

Originally posted by Q99
Based on 'holding on for awhile- with help- and then dying' not being nearly as good as 'stabbing Cade in a practice duel,' 'holding on for a long time against known badasses and *not* dying,' and the page above.

Practice duels are not to be taken at face value.

Show me real battles between Cade and Talon. Oh wait, Cade overwhelmed Talon in the first duel and one-shotted her in the final duel. Not a good picture.

Originally posted by Q99
And... Kao Cen Darach doesn't have all that much in the way of dueling feats himself. Don't get me wrong, he's good! But he's not, say, Ven Zallow.

Yeah right. 🙄

Kao Cen Darach demonstrated the capability to handle Darth Malgus and Lord Vindican simultaneously for a while and the technical prowess he demonstrated with multiple blades is something that you don't see in the mythos generally, in-fact, such display of skill is one of its kind. Don't be asinine.

Originally posted by S_W_LeGenD
Please keep in mind that it is not my intention to criminally underestimate Darth Talon. However, I am noticing criminal underestimation of Lord Vindican

Except it's really not. Saying Vindican would lose to the 4th greatest Sith of another era isn't anywhere near as bad as saying the 4th greatest Sith of another era loses to any random ass Darth in SWTOR.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Except it's really not. Saying Vindican would lose to the 4th greatest Sith of another era isn't anywhere near as bad as saying the 4th greatest Sith of another era loses to any random ass Darth in SWTOR.

Talon being 4th best in her era is subjective assessment, not an officially determined position. In addition, Talon doesn't have Kao level dueling ability and power. It is subjective and speculative to assert that she can handle Vindican.

Talon's feats have been exaggerated while Kao and Vindican have been lowballed, this is what I have witnessed in this thread. Vindican lost to a much superior opponent then Talon and it was still a fight. Talon's chances aren't so bright.

- Vindican tanked a rocket without an issue, I don't see anybody praising him for this performance. This feat alone is a display of great command of Force.

- Vindican's powers were potent enough to overwhelm young Darth Malgus, I don't see anybody taking note of this.

- Talon's vulnerability to offensive actions due to her insignificant dressing have not been noted by anybody but only me.

- No acknowledgment of Kao's remarkable dueling skills either. Such level of skill was needed to outduel Vindican.

SW Legend
You cannot even make a comparison in this case

So you're just going to *assume* equality with someone who's been shown to be actively very strong in the area?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Except it's really not. Saying Vindican would lose to the 4th greatest Sith of another era isn't anywhere near as bad as saying the 4th greatest Sith of another era loses to any random ass Darth in SWTOR.

I'd actually put her a bit lower than 4th (Maladi IMO is likely stronger, or at least effectively so due to being more experienced. Talon has raw power and training, but her tactics often aren't optimal for her skillset)... but still, yea, she's in the rankings!

Her job, literally, is to hunt down and capture or kill Jedi Masters. There's no particular shame in losing to a Sith who's job is 'personal assassin of the Dark Lord of the Sith.'

Those two Jedi she took down shortly before the ship throw? Well, there was just an incident where 5 sith took down a Jedi Knight and a Jedi Master, and then those two slaughtered the 5 without breaking a sweat. They are *good*, and they still had that happen to them (though to be fair, on other occasions they're able to stalemate her). They are noteworthy, major Jedi with plenty of feats under their belts.

Originally posted by Q99
So you're just going to *assume* equality with someone who's been shown to be actively very strong in the area?

Very strong in the area? I don't see anything from Talon that implies that she is "very strong" with TK by mythos standards.

Also, how can you even declare superiority of Talon over Vindican in the matters of TK? Do you even have an idea of Vindican's TK abilities? Your reasoning is not sound.

Originally posted by Q99
I'd actually put her a bit lower than 4th (Maladi IMO is likely stronger, or at least effectively so due to being more experienced. Talon has raw power and training, but her tactics often aren't optimal for her skillset)... but still, yea, she's in the rankings!

I believe that Maladi, Havok and Nihl are above her.

Originally posted by Q99
Her job, literally, is to hunt down and capture or kill Jedi Masters. There's no particular shame in losing to a Sith who's job is 'personal assassin of the Dark Lord of the Sith.'

There is no shame to loosing a Sith who is actually an Inquisitor in an era during which standards for becoming a Sith have been ridiculously high. Learn more about TOR era Sith Inquisitor class from here: http://www.swtor.com/holonet/classes/sith-inquisitor

Sith Inquisitors are masters of the dark arts, confirmed in a codex entry as well (evidence presented in this thread). Also, apparent from how easily Vindican tanked a rocket and dissipated its explosion.

Originally posted by Nephthys
I'm not very good at scanning or hosting images so if I screwed up I'll try again:

http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=23ic574&s=8#.U96x3WP8few
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=153qxw1&s=8#.U96yL2P8few
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=2lsuttx&s=8#.U96yoGP8few
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=eu53t4&s=8#.U96y1WP8few
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=2dl56b5&s=8#.U96zDmP8few
http://tinypic.com/view.php?pic=2je73no&s=8#.U96zPWP8few

Sorry for the poor quality.

I love you <3

Ants not here, marry me 😮

There is no shame to loosing a Sith who is actually an Inquisitor in an era during which standards for becoming a Sith have been ridiculously high. Learn more about TOR era Sith Inquisitor class from here: http://www.swtor.com/holonet/classes/sith-inquisitor

Sith Inquisitors are masters of the dark arts, confirmed in a codex entry as well (evidence presented in this thread). Also, apparent from how easily Vindican tanked a rocket and dissipated its explosion.

Sure, there's no shame... but, her feats *Surpass* his. Talon has a better dueling history (no, 'lasting awhile against one skilled duelist and dying' is not up to 'lasting a longer time against a skilled duelist and not dying,' actually stabbed Cade, or jumping into the middle of multiple major masters and using a combination of physical and force to scatter and wound them), better force feats, more agility. Actual victories.

And there's no doubt she's stronger than many Sith Inquisitors. If you're seriously suggesting every sith inquisitor is up to Rule of One Hand level...

Originally posted by Q99
Sure, there's no shame... but, her feats *Surpass* his.

I disagree

Rocket tanking feat >

Originally posted by Q99
Talon has a better dueling history (no, 'lasting awhile against one skilled duelist and dying' is not up to 'lasting a longer time against a skilled duelist and not dying,' actually stabbed Cade, or jumping into the middle of multiple major masters and using a combination of physical and force to scatter and wound them), better force feats, more agility. Actual victories.

Talon have been depicted fighting greater number of foes, Vindican have been depicted in just one duel. Your assessment is subjective, Q99.

Are you implying that Vindican cannot defeat other skilled combatants among Jedi and Sith? Actually he can. Unfortunately for him, he met Kao Cen Darach on Korriban.

Kao Cen Darach isn't just a skilled duelist, he is remarkably skilled duelist by mythos standards. If you are trying to formulate an assessment, kindly do so with fairness.

Of-course, Talon did give Cade some challenge, in the first duel, but it ended badly for her. In the second duel, Cade literally one-shotted her, this development doesn't helps Talon's reputation.

Better force feats? Subjective. Wrong.

More agility? Once again subjective. Vindican performed acrobatics and dodged Kao's attacks, he isn't slow or slower.

Actual victories? By virtue of greater exploration. I am sure that authors didn't intend to represent Vindican as a looser or not capable of winning battles.

Originally posted by Q99
And there's no doubt she's stronger than many Sith Inquisitors. If you're seriously suggesting every sith inquisitor is up to Rule of One Hand level..

Once again, you know this how?

She isn't an absolute master of the dark arts. She does have decent command of the Force but same is the situation with all Lords.

Sith Inquisitors of the Empire are prodigies, I suppose you haven't read the links that I provided.

Originally posted by Selenial
I love you <3

Ants not here, marry me 😮


I sensed a disturbance in my marriage and came.
---- ---- ----
Go **** yourself, you don't stand a chance.

I sensed a disturbance in my marriage and came.

Did you now?

Go **** yourself

Will that make you come as well? I bet Neph would[n't] be jealous.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Will that make you come as well?

I see what you did there.

Once again, you know this how?

She isn't an absolute master of the dark arts. She does have decent command of the Force but same is the situation with all Lords.

More than 'decent'. Good lightning, very strong TK, illusion, very good at hiding herself in the force, and mind-reading.


Sith Inquisitors of the Empire are prodigies, I suppose you haven't read the links that I provided.

Yea, Talon got one of the top slots right after coming out of apprenticeship. That rather defines 'prodigy.'


Talon have been depicted fighting greater number of foes, Vindican have been depicted in just one duel. Your assessment is subjective, Q99.

No, even if he's had less opportunity for good feats, she still has more feats.

Are you implying that Vindican cannot defeat other skilled combatants among Jedi and Sith? Actually he can. Unfortunately for him, he met Kao Cen Darach on Korriban.

I am in fact not implying that, there's plenty he could beat. Probably not this one, though.

Kao Cen Darach isn't just a skilled duelist, he is remarkably skilled duelist by mythos standards. If you are trying to formulate an assessment, kindly do so with fairness.

Oh yes, he's quite skilled, but he's not overloaded with feats himself.

Of-course, Talon did give Cade some challenge, in the first duel, but it ended badly for her.

With the force.

In the second duel, Cade literally one-shotted her,

No, in the second duel they clashed for a bit then Nihl showed up.

Third, she force-threw him, he did a weird zap-push combination on her, then threatened to shatterpoint her.

In the fourth duel, she stabbed him in the shoulder.

In the fifth duel (sorta duel?), she one-shot KOed him with the force from trying to sneak-zap him.

In the sixth duel, Talon was wounded all over from shrapnel, and in that state Cade one-shotted her.

this development doesn't helps Talon's reputation.

In the seventh duel she escaped completely unharmed after delivering a present.

In the eighth duel, that was the one with the floor-TK feat.

Also, of note, in all eight encounters? She suffers a single light-saber wound (during the sixth), all the others were force.


Better force feats? Subjective. Wrong.

Objective. Bigger is a measurement.


More agility? Once again subjective. Vindican performed acrobatics and dodged Kao's attacks, he isn't slow or slower.

Talon's specifically described as fast, agile, and in top physical condition. Talon also performs more acrobatics than, well, most anyone ^^

Actual victories? By virtue of greater exploration. I am sure that authors didn't intend to represent Vindican as a looser or not capable of winning battles.

But at the end of the day, she still has more victories over opponents of skill and ability.

Not saying that Vindican can't beat plenty of foes... just that you're trying to equate 'not being talon' with 'not beating anyone,' which is absurd. A limited track record can excuse having to assume some, but is not an excuse for assuming- Assuming, not shown!- superiority to a track record with good fights against some very impressive foes.

At best, you can say "Vindican may be stronger than we saw," while on the flip side, we can say, "Talon is this strong."

Originally posted by Q99
No, even if he's had less opportunity for good feats, she still has more feats.

I am in fact not implying that, there's plenty he could beat. Probably not this one, though.

Oh yes, he's quite skilled, but he's not overloaded with feats himself.

With the force.

No, in the second duel they clashed for a bit then Nihl showed up.

Third, she force-threw him, he did a weird zap-push combination on her, then threatened to shatterpoint her.

In the fourth duel, she stabbed him in the shoulder.

In the fifth duel (sorta duel?), she one-shot KOed him with the force from trying to sneak-zap him.

In the sixth duel, Talon was wounded all over from shrapnel, and in that state Cade one-shotted her.

In the seventh duel she escaped completely unharmed after delivering a present.

In the eighth duel, that was the one with the floor-TK feat.

Also, of note, in all eight encounters? She suffers a single light-saber wound (during the sixth), all the others were force.

Objective. Bigger is a measurement.

Talon's specifically described as fast, agile, and in top physical condition. Talon also performs more acrobatics than, well, most anyone ^^

But at the end of the day, she still has more victories over opponents of skill and ability.

Not saying that Vindican can't beat plenty of foes... just that you're trying to equate 'not being talon' with 'not beating anyone,' which is absurd. A limited track record can excuse having to assume some, but is not an excuse for assuming- Assuming, not shown!- superiority to a track record with good fights against some very impressive foes.

At best, you can say "Vindican may be stronger than we saw," while on the flip side, we can say, "Talon is this strong."

Take me, My body is ready