Going for the kill: All out Hulk vs all out Thor (both current)

Started by Warlord9 pages

wasn't also Hulk recently taken out by a Mjolnir discharge when they were fighting frost giants? maybe I'm wrong

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Neither Thor nor Hulk had clean wins in that annual, tbh all of the fights could be marked with an asterix. Hulk buried Thor under a mountain in their 1st fight. Thor scored a brief ko win in their 2nd fight, and Hulk briefly ko'd Thor in their 3rd.

It can be argued Hulk cheapshotted Thor in the 3rd, but Thor couldn't stop the beatdown Hulk gave him either. It could be seen that Hulk dropped his guard in the instance Thor ko'd him, and the 1st fight can be contested because it was the mountain that did the damage not the Hulk himself. Both guys were still standing at the end ready to go another round.

In the first fight Thor didn't use his hammer. He even had to PROTECT the hammer so it wouldn't be broken when the enchantment was off. Thor wasn't buried beneath a mountain, and the only reason the Hulk managed to get that throw in is because Thor thought about his 5 minutes which were up!
http://s388.photobucket.com/user/OneDumbG0/media/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk05.jpg.html (ODG)

If we gave Thor 3 free attacks to the Hulk then there wouldn't be anything left.

And Hulk sure as shit didn't drop his guard he was grabbing for Thor when the lightning struck him in the head. Thor even had his back turned!

Originally posted by carver9
No, he can't tank it. With that said, if he does have the blade, it's a stomp. Is that what you want to hear Dark?

Well, as we know that's what Thor in character does (he was fighting Galactus, then went to go get it because he was pissed off at Galactus), Hulk has no chance.

no anihiliblade for this fight

You said any means possible...and the thread is already on page 5.

Good to see that Thor needs handicapping though 👆

maybe I missed something but is the necroblade part of his powerset?

You DID miss something.

You said no BFR.

Which means Thor can safely leave the battlefield, as it is not a defeat condition.

He did the same thing with Galactus. He went to get the Annihiblade.

Originally posted by krisblaze
In the first fight Thor didn't use his hammer. He even had to PROTECT the hammer so it wouldn't be broken when the enchantment was off. Thor wasn't buried beneath a mountain, and the only reason the Hulk managed to get that throw in is because Thor thought about his 5 minutes which were up!
http://s388.photobucket.com/user/OneDumbG0/media/Thor%20Fights/ThorvsHulk05.jpg.html (ODG)

If we gave Thor 3 free attacks to the Hulk then there wouldn't be anything left.

And Hulk sure as shit didn't drop his guard he was grabbing for Thor when the lightning struck him in the head. Thor even had his back turned!


If you read my post correctly you would know I was referring to the annual (2001) which they had 3 seperate fights. Thor used his hammer in all 3 fights and actually used his lightning before the one he ko'd Hulk with, but Hulk recovered from that one.

IIRC he was yelling at Thor to turn around and fight after he put the fire out, then as he approached and reached out Thor turned around and zapped him. Thor basically outsmarted him, I doubt Hulk was expecting him to do that.

@Saint: ok my bad... I meant to say with whatever means possible within their powerset.
Otherwise Thor has a shitload of options (destroyer, necroblade, casket of eternal winter, norn stones, whatever)

Originally posted by Warlord
wasn't also Hulk recently taken out by a Mjolnir discharge when they were fighting frost giants? maybe I'm wrong

Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps?

Originally posted by carver9
Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps?

Have you never seen a Godblast before?

Originally posted by carver9
Thor koed himself using that much power. I've never seen Thor exert that much power. Not a terrible showing based on Thor power showings. Why would you bring that up though? Are you saying Thor stomps?
not stomping but I believe Thor wins this

Originally posted by The Sorrow
If you read my post correctly you would know I was referring to the annual (2001) which they had 3 seperate fights. Thor used his hammer in all 3 fights and actually used his lightning before the one he ko'd Hulk with, but Hulk recovered from that one.

IIRC he was yelling at Thor to turn around and fight after he put the fire out, then as he approached and reached out Thor turned around and zapped him. Thor basically outsmarted him, I doubt Hulk was expecting him to do that.

Sorry, I read it as a reference to their first three fights 🙂

I still disagree that Thor caught Hulk unaware with the lightning as the Hulk was clearly attacking him.

Hulk's attack on Thor however was a cheapshot considering that Thor was in the process of saving Banner's life..

Originally posted by Warlord
not stomping but I believe Thor wins this

But he has a sh** load of options. How can Hulk win even one based off your posts which means you made a spite thread, right?

Originally posted by krisblaze
Sorry, I read it as a reference to their first three fights 🙂

I still disagree that Thor caught Hulk unaware with the lightning as the Hulk was clearly attacking him.

Hulk's attack on Thor however was a cheapshot considering that Thor was in the process of saving Banner's life..

Thor was looking right at Hulk.

Originally posted by carver9
Thor was looking right at Hulk.

Yes.

You can see the surprise on Thor's face.

Originally posted by krisblaze
Yes.

You can see the surprise on Thor's face.

Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?

Originally posted by carver9
Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?

Yes.

If I enter a room and three pirates jump at me and beat me that's a surprise attack.

Even if I see them jumping at me when I open the door it would be still be a surprise attack.

Originally posted by carver9
But he has a sh** load of options. How can Hulk win even one based off your posts which means you made a spite thread, right?

what are my posts that indicate that Hulk stomps?

Originally posted by carver9
Even though he is looking at Hulk before Hulk attacked? You still consider that a surprise attack? Do you know what a surprise attack is?
Technically someone can still surprise attack you even if you are looking at them.