Pre Crisis Superman plants, sticks his chest out.

Started by Stoic14 pages

Originally posted by operator616
@Stoic: Right, because you totally didn't say that based on the Pre-Crisis era (which you're only basing off the COIE arc, Anti-Monitor's waves), Superman would get destroyed:

But whatever.

True, but let's ignore everything else I said. Why didn't you jump in at that time? My last post came from a false realization, and I did not know that Superman could take even a little antimatter. You showed me something that I did not know. However your scan says that Superman was nearly destroyed by that rocket. Do you believe that, that rocket is more powerful than the Blue Marvel? If that rocket could make him say what he did, how much more would the Blue Marvel do to him?

Originally posted by Stoic
And Sentry was also KO'd by a fed up Blue Marvel. What does that say about his power? I guess that's not enough for you? What is he supposed to do exactly to impress you? It seems like he has to outdo every character in Marvel in order for you to stop low balling him, if that is indeed what you are doing. Seems like it to me, with you saying that he hasn't done shit.

Again if you didn't understand what I said. In comparison to the Savage Hulk, and Blue Marvel, they do not have the same power set, nor was PC Superman invulnerable to everything. In other words PC Superman may not be as hurt by the Hulk's punch as he would be to Blue Marvels, because he was shown to be vulnerable to antimatter. Adam has antimatter powers, you saying whatever it is that you are will not change that, and Superman was vulnerable to antimatter which was my point.

Are you having a problem comprehending that or something? If not I don't see why it would be a stretch for you to understand why I brought up the idea that Adam would be able to affect a guy that was said to be and shown to be vulnerable to antimatter?

The entire DC universe was vulnerable to antimatter at that time, which is the premise of this thread. "PC" get it? Pre effing Crisis. Are you still with me? At this point I really can not tell. PC characters are/were not Marvel characters, and they were vulnerable to antimatter, while Marvel characters were not. The Blue Marvel has antimatter powers. Do you need proof of this as well, or did you not realize this before I brought it up? What PC characters were vulnerable to, does not mean that present day Marvel characters are as well.

Since we know that PC Superman was vulnerable to antimatter, it is not hard, or outrageous to imagine that he would be vulnerable to the Blue Marvel's powers. If you somehow do not understand why I am saying this say so, but at this point I'm pretty tired of trying to explain it, because I'm sure that you understand why I'm saying it, and are simply attempting to be contrary for whatever reason it is that you are being this way.

Which was prior to Sentry's powerup and in the midst of a slew of bad showings for him.
Lol at lowballing. How in the shit is it lowballing if I don't think he's going to evaporate PC Superman? Did he evaporate abother trans level being that I'm not aware of? I'm not saying the character hasn't done shit either, I've repeatedly and repeatedly said his am hasn't done shit. My entire point is about his am. Everything revolves around his am.
Even with it, he's shown nothing battle wise above what Savage Hulk is capable of. Or is comparing him to the ****ing Hulk lowballing too?

No, you outright thought I was complaining about gauntlet placement. I wasn't. I was saying that BM hasn't done anything above what Hulk has shown. And if Hulk can't do it neither should BM.
But the issue isn't pain. If you're putting BM's am on AM's am level then PC Superman gets holes punched through him. Not based on anything BM has done mind you but power set.

Because BM hasn't done shit with it and you're comparing him to the most devastating event in DC history. Which is my issue there. Not to mention that it opens the door for BM to beat pretty much anyone in DC based on zero feats.

You keep saying vulnerability like it's some sort of weakness. It wasn't a weakness, it was because it ****ing tore through anything. It was an overwhelming power that destroyed an infinite amount of universes. Are you going to tell me that either King Hyperion is more durable than the entirety of DC or that King Hyperion and "all Marvel" characters have some secret X gene to defend against Anti Matter? Even though AM was destroying Red Skull with the Cube and, Galactus used it to ruin the Director of Galador's life. Weakened Thanos was disintegrated by a bomb. Etc.

And you see your problem is that BM has no God dammed feats with it. And it isn't like he hasn't hit people with it. It's extrapolating purely from everyone else but his own feats. What has he himself done with it to make you think he could hurt Superman? What has he done? Why should I extend other people who's am has devastating consequences over to BM who has pretty much used it as a blast? One ****ing feat is all that's needed here. One feat.

But dancing around the subject isn't proving dick. His AM is the literal weakest AM ever shown in comics. It goes against everything we were taught by our great comic ancestors. And you think we should use it at "DC" level just because of its name?

Which is again what I mean when I say his AM ain't shit. It'd be like him having entropy powers but everyone he hits takes it like a champ. It flies in the ****ing face of everything we know to a point that it should be considered a special case.

Originally posted by carver9
It said Superman body went limp after the punch. Superman didn't show back up until a lot of panels later when Hulk was on the verge of nearly destroying the city. Reread the book you suppose to have.

Scan or I call bullshit.

Originally posted by Stoic
It's still anti-matter though, unless DC antimatter is somehow different than Marvel's antimatter. Also Adam seems to hold back a lot, so I'm not sure if it would be within his character to obliterate someone with an antimatter blast. Just saying an antimatter punch from him would probably light PC Superman up. /Shrug

We've seen what happened to Thanos when Drax attached an anti matter pack to his chest.

Total obliteration.

Originally posted by Stoic
True, but let's ignore everything else I said. Why didn't you jump in at that time? My last post came from a false realization, and I did not know that Superman could take even a little antimatter. You showed me something that I did not know. However your scan says that Superman was nearly destroyed by that rocket. Do you believe that, that rocket is more powerful than the Blue Marvel? If that rocket could make him say what he did, how much more would the Blue Marvel do to him?

And I quote:

EEEAAA! I never felt such force! Those asteroids.....being blown to dust! Can even I survive this?

PC Superman's invulnerability. Effected. Antimatter. Didn't destroy the Universe.

Spin this spin doctors.

Originally posted by operator616
Anti-matter is portrayed in varying power levels throughout comics (much like entropy). Here is PC Superman surviving planet-busting anti-matter missile point blank in Superman #205 (the reason is attributed to Superman having a "super matter body"😉

http://i.imgur.com/WL7OmKY.jpg

Superboy did the same in Superboy #244.

Yet, we know that Superman can't survive Anti Monitor's anti-matter waves. Because he was literally destroying whole universes with them.

👆

While this goes against some of what I've said, it still shows BM's am isn't close to AM level.

And considering who has tanked it from BM, this only farther hurts his case. Which means we should actually look at what BM has done as opposed to what other anti matter has done.

In other words, Anti matter from Blue Marvel ain't shit.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Which was prior to Sentry's powerup and in the midst of a slew of bad showings for him.
Lol at lowballing. How in the shit is it lowballing if I don't think he's going to evaporate PC Superman? Did he evaporate abother trans level being that I'm not aware of? I'm not saying the character hasn't done shit either, I've repeatedly and repeatedly said his am hasn't done shit. My entire point is about his am. Everything revolves around his am.
Even with it, he's shown nothing battle wise above what Savage Hulk is capable of. Or is comparing him to the ****ing Hulk lowballing too?

No, you outright thought I was complaining about gauntlet placement. I wasn't. I was saying that BM hasn't done anything above what Hulk has shown. And if Hulk can't do it neither should BM.
But the issue isn't pain. If you're putting BM's am on AM's am level then PC Superman gets holes punched through him. Not based on anything BM has done mind you but power set.

Because BM hasn't done shit with it and you're comparing him to the most devastating event in DC history. Which is my issue there. Not to mention that it opens the door for BM to beat pretty much anyone in DC based on zero feats.

You keep saying vulnerability like it's some sort of weakness. It wasn't a weakness, it was because it ****ing tore through anything. It was an overwhelming power that destroyed an infinite amount of universes. Are you going to tell me that either King Hyperion is more durable than the entirety of DC or that King Hyperion and "all Marvel" characters have some secret X gene to defend against Anti Matter? Even though AM was destroying Red Skull with the Cube and, Galactus used it to ruin the Director of Galador's life. Weakened Thanos was disintegrated by a bomb. Etc.

And you see your problem is that BM has no God dammed feats with it. And it isn't like he hasn't hit people with it. It's extrapolating purely from everyone else but his own feats. What has he himself done with it to make you think he could hurt Superman? What has he done? Why should I extend other people who's am has devastating consequences over to BM who has pretty much used it as a blast? One ****ing feat is all that's needed here. One feat.

But dancing around the subject isn't proving dick. His AM is the literal weakest AM ever shown in comics. It goes against everything we were taught by our great comic ancestors. And you think we should use it at "DC" level just because of its name?

Which is again what I mean when I say his AM ain't shit. It'd be like him having entropy powers but everyone he hits takes it like a champ. It flies in the ****ing face of everything we know to a point that it should be considered a special case.

WTF do you mean it hasn't done shit???? IT DID WHAT THE DAMN ANIMATTER MISSLE DID, hurt a herald + level being! I'm sorry you talked yourself in a hole when YOU brought up Antimonitor, which was dumb. You are the one that said antimatter is depicted stronger in DC, yet this antimatter missle was largely tanked by Superman and his "Super matter." The problem is your DC brain can't accept that Sentry and King Hype could possibly be as durable as PC Superman. Your world view says it must be that BMs antimatter doesn't work correctly.

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
WTF do you mean it hasn't done shit???? IT DID WHAT THE DAMN ANIMATTER MISSLE DID, hurt a herald + level being! I'm sorry you talked yourself in a hole when YOU brought up Antimonitor, which was dumb. You are the one that said antimatter is depicted stronger in DC, yet this antimatter missle was largely tanked by Superman and his "Super matter." The problem is your DC brain can't accept that Sentry and King Hype could possibly be as durable as PC Superman. Your world view says it must be that BMs antimatter doesn't work correctly.
Didn't bring up Anti Monitor.
Never said Anti Matter in DC is stronger (outside of BM's pussy anti matter).
Straight up a big lol at my DC brain.
Lol at King Hype and Sentry being as durable as PC Superman.

Blue Marvel has shitty anti matter. Glad we solved that. Open and shut case.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
👆

While this goes against some of what I've said, it still shows BM's am isn't close to AM level.

And considering who has tanked it from BM, this only farther hurts his case. Which means we should actually look at what BM has done as opposed to what other anti matter has done.

In other words, Anti matter from Blue Marvel ain't shit.

Antimonitor was never a part of the debate, it's just some shit you wedged in to try and prove and point and it backfired. Your debating skills ain't shit. And no, it does not weaken BMs case, it totally validates it. PC Superman was hurt by an antimatter missle if you missed it, the same antimatter that you claimed automatically blows up and all matter in the DC verse.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Didn't bring up Anti Monitor.
Never said Anti Matter in DC is stronger (outside of BM's pussy anti matter).
Straight up a big lol at my DC brain.
Lol at King Hype and Sentry being as durable as PC Superman.

Blue Marvel has shitty anti matter. Glad we solved that. Open and shut case.

Correct, your loss record just went up by a factor of one. LOL at weaksauce notion of DC antimatter vs Marvel antimatter. Stare at the scan again, read Superman's own words and allow your brain to reprogram itself.

Originally posted by Branlor Swift
Which was prior to Sentry's powerup and in the midst of a slew of bad showings for him.
Lol at lowballing. How in the shit is it lowballing if I don't think he's going to evaporate PC Superman? Did he evaporate abother trans level being that I'm not aware of? I'm not saying the character hasn't done shit either, I've repeatedly and repeatedly said his am hasn't done shit. My entire point is about his am. Everything revolves around his am.
Even with it, he's shown nothing battle wise above what Savage Hulk is capable of. Or is comparing him to the ****ing Hulk lowballing too?

No, you outright thought I was complaining about gauntlet placement. I wasn't. I was saying that BM hasn't done anything above what Hulk has shown. And if Hulk can't do it neither should BM.
But the issue isn't pain. If you're putting BM's am on AM's am level then PC Superman gets holes punched through him. Not based on anything BM has done mind you but power set.

Because BM hasn't done shit with it and you're comparing him to the most devastating event in DC history. Which is my issue there. Not to mention that it opens the door for BM to beat pretty much anyone in DC based on zero feats.

You keep saying vulnerability like it's some sort of weakness. It wasn't a weakness, it was because it ****ing tore through anything. It was an overwhelming power that destroyed an infinite amount of universes. Are you going to tell me that either King Hyperion is more durable than the entirety of DC or that King Hyperion and "all Marvel" characters have some secret X gene to defend against Anti Matter? Even though AM was destroying Red Skull with the Cube and, Galactus used it to ruin the Director of Galador's life. Weakened Thanos was disintegrated by a bomb. Etc.

And you see your problem is that BM has no God dammed feats with it. And it isn't like he hasn't hit people with it. It's extrapolating purely from everyone else but his own feats. What has he himself done with it to make you think he could hurt Superman? What has he done? Why should I extend other people who's am has devastating consequences over to BM who has pretty much used it as a blast? One ****ing feat is all that's needed here. One feat.

But dancing around the subject isn't proving dick. His AM is the literal weakest AM ever shown in comics. It goes against everything we were taught by our great comic ancestors. And you think we should use it at "DC" level just because of its name?

Which is again what I mean when I say his AM ain't shit. It'd be like him having entropy powers but everyone he hits takes it like a champ. It flies in the ****ing face of everything we know to a point that it should be considered a special case.

When did I say that he was going to evaporate PC Superman when I said that he would light him up? You're one to talk, do you recall how you rated this gauntlet? When did Ironfist ever show the power that you seemingly gave him in this thread? i said that Adam would light him up. Maybe you don't understand what that means, but when i said it, I meant that he would be knocked for a loop, at the very least. When at that point did you get evaporate? I'm not understanding why you are comparing the Hulk to Blue Marvel, when they do not have the same power set? i never said that he hits harder than the hulk, but that he possesses a power that PC Superman was vulnerable to. Again do you have trouble understanding this?

No I was guessing that you were complaining about the gauntlet, because the hulk was at a lower peg than the Blue Marvel. If this was not what was on you mind so be it, who cares anyways. I never placed BM on AM's level either. You were the one that began comparing the two. I only kept saying that if PC Superman was vulnerable to antimatter that Blue Marvel should be able to light him up. Should I explain what light him up means again?

No again. What I said was that PC anything was stated to be highly vulnerable to antimatter. Don't tell me that i said things that I didn't. And since when was PC Superman greater than anyone, and everyone in DC? Did I ever say any of that? You better go back and look at the OP, because what I understood, was PC Superman was going to be standing there, and taking a fully powered hit from the people in the gauntlet while bracing. Check you own shit out before going thought mines. Look at what you said about number 4. Ridiculous!

I keep saying vulnerability because it was stated that antimatter could affect him. Not like a weakness like Kryptonite. Stop playing word games, I know fully what the words mean, which is why i chose vulnerability. Operator just made it clear that antimatter did not in fact tear through any and everything. Check the scan.

Originally posted by operator616
Anti-matter is portrayed in varying power levels throughout comics (much like entropy). Here is PC Superman surviving planet-busting anti-matter missile point blank in Superman #205 (the reason is attributed to Superman having a "super matter body"😉

http://i.imgur.com/WL7OmKY.jpg

Superboy did the same in Superboy #244.

Yet, we know that Superman can't survive Anti Monitor's anti-matter waves. Because he was literally destroying whole universes with them.

If he has no feats, then Koing the Sentry must have been nothing Despite Doom being humbled by him in seconds. King Hyperion wasn't a feat? Nearly breaking the moon in two with a medal isn't a feat either I guess?

This like I said before has nothing to do with striking power, or strength, but as I keep stating, on power set. BM's power derives from antimatter, and PC Superman was vulnerable to it. Meaning it could hurt him. What you said about BM was that he would basically do nothing to PC Superman. I disagree.

Originally posted by Stoic
True, but let's ignore everything else I said. Why didn't you jump in at that time? My last post came from a false realization, and I did not know that Superman could take even a little antimatter. You showed me something that I did not know. However your scan says that Superman was nearly destroyed by that rocket. Do you believe that, that rocket is more powerful than the Blue Marvel? If that rocket could make him say what he did, how much more would the Blue Marvel do to him?

Stoic my boy, didn't you know that was DC antimatter? I mean it's stated that DC antimatter is stronger than Marvel antimatter.....somewhere.....I think. 😆

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Correct, your loss record just went up by a factor of one. LOL at weaksauce notion of DC antimatter vs Marvel antimatter. Stare at the scan again, read Superman's own words and allow your brain to reprogram itself.

So what if we compare marvel anti matter to marvel anti matter?

Brans main point isn't to compare anti matter's.. It's that, blue simply doesn't have the feats to claim he could do what Drax's anti matter pack did to Thanos there, or anything close to it.

Basically, BM's anti matter is portrayed as a glorified, amped up Master Blow..

Still waiting on those scan's carver.😂

Originally posted by Stoic
Check you own shit out before going thought mines. Look at what you said about number 4. Ridiculous!
.

This guy doesn't know about The Fist. Proving that his entire side is wrong by default

Originally posted by cdtm
We've seen what happened to Thanos when Drax attached an anti matter pack to his chest.

Total obliteration.

Thanos was still in a weakened state.

Stoic:

The Iron Fist is MAGIC. It even bypassed Speedball's kinetic field because of magic properties.

PC Superman dies. 😆

Originally posted by Lek Kuen
This guy doesn't know about The Fist. Proving that his entire side is wrong by default

So Ironfist could completely evaporate PC Superman, and punches even harder than an IMP punch from the Flash? Like i said ridiculous.

Originally posted by Stoic
When did I say that he was going to evaporate PC Superman when I said that he would light him up? You're one to talk, do you recall how you rated this gauntlet? When did Ironfist ever show the power that you seemingly gave him in this thread? i said that Adam would light him up. Maybe you don't understand what that means, but when i said it, I meant that he would be knocked for a loop, at the very least. When at that point did you get evaporate? I'm not understanding why you are comparing the Hulk to Blue Marvel, when they do not have the same power set? i never said that he hits harder than the hulk, but that he possesses a power that PC Superman was vulnerable to. Again do you have trouble understanding this?

No I was guessing that you were complaining about the gauntlet, because the hulk was at a lower peg than the Blue Marvel. If this was not what was on you mind so be it, who cares anyways. I never placed BM on AM's level either. You were the one that began comparing the two. I only kept saying that if PC Superman was vulnerable to antimatter that Blue Marvel should be able to light him up. Should I explain what light him up means again?

No again. What I said was that PC anything was stated to be highly vulnerable to antimatter. Don't tell me that i said things that I didn't. And since when was PC Superman greater than anyone, and everyone in DC? Did I ever say any of that? You better go back and look at the OP, because what I understood, was PC Superman was going to be standing there, and taking a fully powered hit from the people in the gauntlet while bracing. Check you own shit out before going thought mines. Look at what you said about number 4. Ridiculous!

I keep saying vulnerability because it was stated that antimatter could affect him. Not like a weakness like Kryptonite. Stop playing word games, I know fully what the words mean, which is why i chose vulnerability. Operator just made it clear that antimatter did not in fact tear through any and everything. Check the scan.

If he has no feats, then Koing the Sentry must have been nothing Despite Doom being humbled by him in seconds. King Hyperion wasn't a feat? Nearly breaking the moon in two with a medal isn't a feat either I guess?

This like I said before has nothing to do with striking power, or strength, but as I keep stating, on power set. BM's power derives from antimatter, and PC Superman was vulnerable to it. Meaning it could hurt him. What you said about BM was that he would basically do nothing to PC Superman. I disagree.

"Light him up", as in like an antimatter missile. 😮‍💨

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Antimonitor was never a part of the debate, it's just some shit you wedged in to try and prove and point and it backfired. Your debating skills ain't shit. And no, it does not weaken BMs case, it totally validates it. PC Superman was hurt by an antimatter missle if you missed it, the same antimatter that you claimed automatically blows up and all matter in the DC verse.
😂

Stoic brought up AM.

Originally posted by Stoic
Wasn't Superman and other Kryptonians vulnerable to antimatter during the Crisis of Infinite Earths?

You being the master of debating would carry the most weight in who can debate I think. Maybe I'll go back to the drawing board.

Though I admitted it goes against some things I said. I'm glad you posted that scan to prove me wrong on some aspects... When you posted that scan.

Originally posted by Blue Area Vet
Correct, your loss record just went up by a factor of one. LOL at weaksauce notion of DC antimatter vs Marvel antimatter. Stare at the scan again, read Superman's own words and allow your brain to reprogram itself.
Did I lose to you in this debate? In your angry tiny no point posts? Well, dang, thanks for the loss doc.

I have never stated anything about DC antimatter vs Marvel antimatter. In fact I stated the exact opposite.

You do realize that if anti matter is variable that that farther pushes BM's abilities with out in its own corner don't you? I was just arguing that it's a special case. Now you think AM being variable helps in any way? I don't get it.

All this does if indeed correct and not another example of a special am case is mean we should take Blue Marvel in a bubble. IE, judge him of his own merits, not of others. If indeed the case it's the difference between Galactus' PC and Surfer's PC.

I don't get why I'm trying to explain this to a halfwit though. Maybe I do indeed lose again.