Originally posted by red g jacks
he's left on taxes as in he wants to restore the clinton era rates, right?
He wants to cut taxes on the poor and middle class and raise taxes on the rich: a leftist policy in America.
Information is a bit outdated, here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_United_States_presidential_candidates,_2008#Tax_policy
But you can go to politicalfactcheck.com and go through all of his tax-related promises to see which ones fall on the political spectrum.
There should be no question that he holds leftist tax policies. Any politician that says he or she wants to redistribute wealth from the rich to the poor is a leftist on their tax policies: the actual taxes collected compared to historical data is meaningless when talking about whether a tax policy is leftist or right: it is how those taxes are collected that determines where they sit on the political spectrum. I should not that I support a strong tax policy on the "rich." I prefer a flat tax or no income tax, however.
Originally posted by red g jacks
i also agree that he's right wing in regard to the military and the police state... though i wouldn't necessarily say he is any 'worse' than bush in terms of his intent. i see it more as he has been building upon a lot of the precedents that bush first set.
IMO, things like "intent" don't matter nearly as much as what actually happened. Obama has expanded Bush era military operations (while running on a platform that he would pull out of Iraq and close down Gitmo) and made the police state business much worse.
That's worse than Bush regardless of who intended to do what: what actually got done is what makes Obama worse.
Originally posted by red g jacks
edit: i disagree that he's not a 'moderate' because each of these issues you are listing have their own left/right spectrum as the country evolves. for instance... the country has generally been shifting to the left in regard to social issues for some time now. so what was a 'leftist' viewpoint decades ago might be conservative today. same deal as i explained with the taxes above. all in all, with each issue you listed, i'd say obama's stances are more or less aligned with the status quo. both the 'far left' and 'far right' stances you highlighted are well within the bounds of mainstream american political opinion imo.
He's not a moderate, overall, but he can be a moderate on some issues, for sure.
If he were averaged he would be left, for America, but I do not think comparisons like those are fair. If that same average was compared to other countries, he'd be considered right.