Originally posted by Zack M
[B]Many creators currently have been clear that DC has been very good to work with creative wise.
Apparently it's been spotty, like different sub-editors treat their creators differently. What's needed is consistently good editors.
I think the quality of editors of different lines have improved, but overall the people at top still need to get their heads around planning and consistency if they want to catch up.
And in terms of sales, DC is up and more healthy than they were pre DCnU. Ever since the DCnU rolled out, sales have been up, which is a good thing.
While they are up in absolute numbers, so is *everyone*, and comparatively they're lagging behind by an amount not dissimilar to pre-reboot. Ironically, it's arguable the relaunch helped the rest of the industry more than them, it got a lot of people into the stores, but those people then moved to other books.
Starfire for instance is a top seller for June and DC should be very close to Marvel in market share.
Doubtful- Marvel has Secret Wars.
Only reason why Marvel takes leads is because of Star Wars and constant events and relaunching.
Their month-to-month book sales are very solid, and they were consistently in the lead before Star Wars, that just widened the gap. They do do a 'season' method of ending books and starting new ones, but that's been their style for years now, and the launches are spread out so they don't produce big month sales spikes very often.
Heck, *DC* largely stayed in the game at all due to stuff like it's 3-d cover months and weekly comics (Batman Eternal and such). They've been leaning fairly hard on gimmicks recently, which is a limited well.
You can only chalk up events so much when DC's had some big ones, and they just lost in an event vs non-even month.
Without that, DC would have been like December, where DC and Marvel split.
Note in December, Marvel released 77 books to DC's 102.
That's the factor that allowed them to split, they put out a third more comics that month. In April, they both put out 88 exactly, DC with an event and Marvel not, and Marvel won by 4%.
In most months, DC tends to trail in double-digits, and their events are the only times they get close nowadays.