Hulk vs Sinestro

Originally posted by Bentley
Sinestro has many great feats and so does Pharallax. We've seen Lanterns weilding entities before. Considering the lack of feats, we have a rather big amount of elements to make a discussion.

Would arguing with feats be better? Of course, I said as much in my post. But if Sinestro were to lose his entity in two books, without any extensive feats so to speak we could still extrapolate a lot of his power out of what we know of the entity and Sinestro. Then you'd sound biased as hell if you just said "he has no feats, hence he can only be considered as powerful as regular Sinestro". But you could still do it by claiming there is no proof, but you'd know then, there is no possible proof.

The current state is similar, but we have a much more healthy option of waiting and seeing. There is nothing irrational about trying to gauge an amalgam without feats in hand, it's just not as sound of a discussion.

Not saying he isn't more powerful than his previous self, what I'm asking is, how does he fight with the entity. The last time I seen his usage of it, he used it to chew on his enemy which wouldn't fly here. I'm not going to guess how Sinestro fight with this power up. Thats why I'm asking for showings. Will he blast with it? Use it as a teleportation device. Blow up the planet with it? Do you see what I am asking now?

I don't mind giving him the majority but at least provide some type of evidence.

Originally posted by carver9
I don't mind giving him the majority but at least provide some type of evidence.

Well, you can aknowledge right now we can't provide evidence and there might never be evidence. If you can't admit the character under other considerations the only intellectually honest thing to do is ignore the thread because you cannot judge it properly.

What you don't do is ask people for proof you know doesn't exist. Proof that doesn't exist never matters.

Originally posted by carver9
Not saying he isn't more powerful than his previous self, what I'm asking is, how does he fight with the entity. The last time I seen his usage of it, he used it to chew on his enemy which wouldn't fly here. I'm not going to guess how Sinestro fight with this power up. That why I'm asking for showings. Will he blast with it? Use it as a teleportation device. Blow up the planet with it? Do you see what I am asking now?

We have rules for that. He fights at the best of his abilities.

Originally posted by Bentley
Well, you can aknowledge right now we can't provide evidence and there might never be evidence. If you can't admit the character under other considerations the only intellectually honest thing to do is ignore the thread because you cannot judge it properly.

What you don't do is ask people for proof you know doesn't exist. Proof that doesn't exist never matters.

We have rules for that. He fights at the best of his abilities.

I agree with your first statement.

He also fights In character unless we are in agreement that Hulk could reach Sinestro across the battlefield in less than the blink of an eye (and yes, Hulk is that fast) and pound him to sleep with planetary punches?

Originally posted by carver9
He also fights In character unless we are in agreement that Hulk could reach Sinestro across the battlefield in less than the blink of an eye (and yes, Hulk is that fast) and pound him to sleep with planetary punches?

CIS is part of the game. I'd point out lanterns are also uber fast. But see at least now we'd be discussing about things that are more tangible.

In the end I mostly wanted to explain my first statement, because for reasons we did cover I think discussing this battle will make more sense in a few weeks.

Originally posted by Bentley
CIS is part of the game. I'd point out lanterns are also uber fast. But see at least now we'd be discussing about things that are more tangible.

In the end I mostly wanted to explain my first statement, because for reasons we did cover I think discussing this battle will make more sense in a few weeks.

👆

With that said, I'm done.

Originally posted by carver9
The Parallax that just chewed up on Hal? Is this the same Sinestro that admitted he couldn't beat some random new gods?

Hulk unless sinestro gets back up from 2 or 3 rookie lanterns atleast

Sinestrollax wins.