Superman VS Thor: STRENGTH RANKING

Started by 9jaboy37 pages
Originally posted by abhilegend
Book of eternity isn't book of limbo. Seriously stop posting from Wikipedia.
Originally posted by abhilegend
Book of eternity isn't book of limbo. Seriously stop posting from Wikipedia.

That magical book was nowhere near infinite weight. Funny how there are many characters stronger than superman, CM and ultraman on-panel and they are nowhere near having infinite strength and the fact that CM helped lifted the book and ultraman lifted it by himself but fans tend to forget this when asked who is stronger between supes,CM and ultraman. Pre-crisis superman could not lift infinite weight, sun-dipped superman cannot lift infinite weight, All-star superman could not lift infinite weight, but now to we have claims of regular superman, CM and ultraman being able to do it?? Common sense people.

right on target^

Applying the laws of physics to a magical book, which by definition defies physics, in order to quantify a feat sounds wonky.

The assumption that infinite pages = infinite weight which is normally valid gets thrown out the window when magic is concerned.

The book housing the "multiverse" doesn't mean it weighs as much the multiverse either. The soul gem houses soul-world inside it, yet the gem doesn't weigh as much as a universe though... unless you want to say Warlock has the strongest neck muscles in comics.

Originally posted by JBL
That magical book was nowhere near infinite weight. Funny how there are many characters stronger than superman, CM and ultraman on-panel and they are nowhere near having infinite strength and the fact that CM helped lifted the book and ultraman lifted it by himself but fans tend to forget this when asked who is stronger between supes,CM and ultraman. Pre-crisis superman could not lift infinite weight, sun-dipped superman cannot lift infinite weight, All-star superman could not lift infinite weight, but now to we have claims of regular superman, CM and ultraman being able to do it?? Common sense people.

This is a comic where Superman combines with Ultraman to transport to a higher reality where they then beat the shit out of Alan Moore. Common sense is thrown out the window.

Originally posted by JBL
That magical book was nowhere near infinite weight. Funny how there are many characters stronger than superman, CM and ultraman on-panel and they are nowhere near having infinite strength and the fact that CM helped lifted the book and ultraman lifted it by himself but fans tend to forget this when asked who is stronger between supes,CM and ultraman. Pre-crisis superman could not lift infinite weight, sun-dipped superman cannot lift infinite weight, All-star superman could not lift infinite weight, but now to we have claims of regular superman, CM and ultraman being able to do it?? Common sense people.

For once we agree on something.🙂

Originally posted by ares834
This is a comic where Superman combines with Ultraman to transport to a higher reality where they then beat the shit out of Alan Moore. Common sense is thrown out the window.

Indeed.

So why the phuck are people trying so desperately to credit Superman with this "feat"?

He has more than enough feats that establish superior strength.

Originally posted by One-Punch
Applying the laws of physics to a [b]magical book, which by definition defies physics, in order to quantify a feat sounds wonky.

The assumption that infinite pages = infinite weight which is normally valid gets thrown out the window when magic is concerned.

The book housing the "multiverse" doesn't mean it weighs as much the multiverse either. The soul gem houses soul-world inside it, yet the gem doesn't weigh as much as a universe though... unless you want to say Warlock has the strongest neck muscles in comics. [/B]


Again with the magical BS? Has nobody read animal man? Because when Merriman said a monkey wrote that book, Jr was describing grant Morrison himself who wrote that book and placed it in limbo. It is a metaphysical concept not magical. Stop that BS already.

And soul gem is a doorway to soul world, it doesn't really contains soul world. It is a different dimension.

Originally posted by JBL
That magical book was nowhere near infinite weight. Funny how there are many characters stronger than superman, CM and ultraman on-panel and they are nowhere near having infinite strength and the fact that CM helped lifted the book and ultraman lifted it by himself but fans tend to forget this when asked who is stronger between supes,CM and ultraman. Pre-crisis superman could not lift infinite weight, sun-dipped superman cannot lift infinite weight, All-star superman could not lift infinite weight, but now to we have claims of regular superman, CM and ultraman being able to do it?? Common sense people.
Haha, what a way to dismiss a feat.

abhilegend...he is right

sorry to say man

quanchi believes that superman is in another tier strengthwise than thor,that's why he is arguing for 10 times thor's strength....

And i like how some people ignored the absence of proof of WM for thor,and then attacked superman's lifting feat...

Superman on average is above thor and nearly every other HH.

😐

Originally posted by 9jaboy
quanchi believes that superman is in another tier strengthwise than thor,that's why he is arguing for 10 times thor's strength....

And i like how some people ignored the absence of proof of WM for thor,and then attacked superman's lifting feat...

lol

Originally posted by JBL
That magical book was nowhere near infinite weight. Funny how there are many characters stronger than superman, CM and ultraman on-panel and they are nowhere near having infinite strength and the fact that CM helped lifted the book and ultraman lifted it by himself but fans tend to forget this when asked who is stronger between supes,CM and ultraman. Pre-crisis superman could not lift infinite weight, sun-dipped superman cannot lift infinite weight, All-star superman could not lift infinite weight, but now to we have claims of regular superman, CM and ultraman being able to do it?? Common sense people.
Each page has mass and thus weight. Infinite pages implies infinite weight.

This was the writer's intentions. Stop acting like this stuff really happened. It didn't. We go off writer's intentions and what is shown and stated in the comic.

Originally posted by carver9
😐
He said NEARLY every other high herald. IMO, Superman is above ALL high heralds in strength. He simply has the best strength feats by a large margin.

Has any brought up Thors feat to lifting unimaginable tonnage piling on top of him and him escaping while being under the effects gravity equal to that of a neuton star?

that feat has been raised in the past. supes has held a black hole though. black hole trumps neutron star, as little sense as it actually makes....

Originally posted by h1a8
Each page has mass and thus weight. Infinite pages implies infinite weight.

This was the writer's intentions. Stop acting like this stuff really happened. It didn't. We go off writer's intentions and what is shown and stated in the comic.

He said NEARLY every other high herald. IMO, Superman is above ALL high heralds in strength. He simply has the best strength feats by a large margin.

Using that it should also have infinite size/volume, so explain why the book clearly isn't infinitely large.

Originally posted by h1a8
Each page has mass and thus weight. Infinite pages implies infinite weight.

This was the writer's intentions. Stop acting like this stuff really happened. It didn't. We go off writer's intentions and what is shown and stated in the comic.

He said NEARLY every other high herald. IMO, Superman is above ALL high heralds in strength. He simply has the best strength feats by a large margin.

Then that would mean that superman,CM and ultraman have infinite strength??? Answer this..... What does sundipping, sniffing kyrptonite and magical amp do the the three characters??? They all get stronger...... But wait!!!!! they by you and other fans have infinite strength so it is pointless for them to do those things right????? The only infinite thing about this is infinite BS and wishing. superman is not the strongest herald by the way, strong,but not the strongest. 🙁