Superman VS Thor: STRENGTH RANKING

Originally posted by ODG
I'm suggesting that if you want to believe the dust speck black hole would instantly destroy the solar system, rather than gradually as most people have concluded, then Batman surviving it's warping makes him solar system level in durability. Read the comic. It's right there in the four corners of the page.

Actually, it has no weight at all on these forums. Comics do. And I'm sure you enjoyed how terribly at every turn this conversation has progressed. 👆

Common keep whining and twisting it, you're a champ 😂

Originally posted by abhilegend
👆

You tell him, Batman survived Darkseid's multiversal black hole which was dragging entire multiverse down.

Though now lowballing through Batman is hilarious.

Originally posted by Golgo13
The debate is over and Rick confirmed the feat. House of El, FTW.

The House of El ALWAYS wins!

^ Great. Batman has multiversal black hole durability now. Whatever it takes for Superman and Green Lantern to get an innocuous feat replicated by an unextraordinary magnetic field.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
I command you it seems 👆

Common keep whining and twisting it, you're a champ 😂

I suppose I had a hand in that. /shrug

Originally posted by Reflassshh
Please don't give him ideas, even though that sounds like something hard to do. He will lowball that too with 'on panel evidence' and 'others have already discussed it so i won't adress it' tactics.

Originally posted by LordofBrooklyn
The House of El ALWAYS wins!

9/10 times, maybe. House of Orion solos everyone.

Originally posted by ODG
^ Great. Batman has multiversal black hole durability now. Whatever it takes for Superman and Green Lantern to get an innocuous feat replicated by an unextraordinary magnetic field. Reduced to making random nonsensical comments? That far gone, already.

I suppose I had a hand in that. /shrug

Originally posted by abhilegend
Seems like he would. I would like to see him flailing around to demean it.

Like a clockwork. Its not like Atom said something about the black hole and the writer merely confirmed him.

Simply ANYTHING to deny a feat. Ask him where the black hole was supposed to grow and consume the solar system. Atom said ANY screw up and the solar system would be gone.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I sure hope you know better than the actual writer.

What does a shady unofficial email (which is against forum rules) going to prove? In fact it doesn't even contradict anything I said. Where does it say the black hole started at solar system busting levels.

If that were the case It would mean Batman tanked a solar system busting black hole. Then again, you just admitted to thinking Batman tanked a multiversal black hole.

Congratulations you've now joined the ranks of nutcases like h1 and board walker. Is losing your mind worth elevating Superman to a fantasy tier that only exists in your dreams? Dumb question, of course it is.

Originally posted by One-Punch
😂

What does a shady unofficial email (which is against forum rules) going to prove? In fact it doesn't even contradict anything I said. Where does it say the black hole started at solar system busting levels.

If that were the case It would mean Batman tanked a solar system busting black hole. Then again, you just admitted to thinking Batman tanked a multiversal black hole.

Congratulations you've now joined the ranks of nutcases like h1 and board walker. Is losing your mind worth elevating Superman to a fantasy tier that only exists in your dreams? Dumb question, of course it is.

And its not something he was pulling out of his ass, he just confirmed what was said in the comic by Atom.

Why don't you prove that the black hole was supposed to consume solar system by growing?

And that wasn't the "Batman has multiversal durability" argument. You and me both know that Batman survives things he has no chance of surviving. What did you expect, that batman die in that comic?

ODG likes to use the logic:
If it didn't destroy A as an indirect result then it must have not been that powerful.

If we use his logic then almost all feats are invalid due to character's clothes not being destroyed, lack of collateral damage, beings not being disintegrated, etc.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So if that black hole was so weak, how come DCs greatest scientist said it would destroy the whole solar system or superman said it would rip his hands off?

Originally posted by abhilegend
It stands more weight than your word. You can ask Golgo, he got the same reply

And its not something he was pulling out of his ass, he just confirmed what was said in the comic by Atom.

Why don't you prove that the black hole was supposed to consume solar system by growing?

And that wasn't the "Batman has multiversal durability" argument. You and me both know that Batman survives things he has no chance of surviving. What did you expect, that batman die in that comic?

You've been here long enough to know the rules. Your shady email exchange is meaningless here.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t461496.html

An obscure interview given by someone involved in a story arc is not proof to refute feats. Neither is a random post by a supposed writer on a message board, blogs, tweets, etc. There have been too many of these so called interviews which go against what's shown on panel. Especially when there is no dialogue to refute what's happening on panel. Most writers are clear with the intentions of the plot and story arc.

Originally posted by JBL
Name a black hole that could not destroy a room or batman??????????????????????????????? Pretty strong huh?????? 🙄

Originally posted by One-Punch
You've been here long enough to know the rules. Your shady email exchange is meaningless here.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t461496.html

At least what writer said was supported in the comic. Where did you get that black hole was supposed to grow and consume the solar system? Let me guess, just pulled out of your behind to undermine this feat? Along with Batman survived it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
😂

Like a clockwork. Its not like Atom said something about the black hole and the writer merely confirmed him.

Simply ANYTHING to deny a feat. Ask him where the black hole was supposed to grow and consume the solar system. Atom said ANY screw up and the solar system would be gone.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Darkseid's multiversal black hole which was dragging the whole multiverse down with him.
And your wild theories too.

At least what writer said was supported in the comic. Where did you get that black hole was supposed to grow and consume the solar system? Let me guess, just pulled out of your behind to undermine this feat? Along with Batman survived it.

Atom said ANY screw up and the solar system would be destroyed. What do you have to refute that statement? Did Atom say that "Wait, that black hole would grow and destroy the solar system"

Originally posted by One-Punch
You've been here long enough to know the rules. Your shady email exchange is meaningless here.

http://www.killermovies.com/forums/f77/t461496.html

😂

This is downright amusing.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
We didn't discuss any Thor ft. You just stick up to an unproven statement.

Originally posted by JBL
Common sense should tell you that the black hole escaping that field, would expand (grow) and gain power to destroy the solar system, as it stood, lanturn and superman prevented it from expanding to that point, it was weak, it did not even affect the room they were in let alone the solar system. That black hole was nowhere near full power, if it was at full size, then the solar system would be toast, but low and behold! you superman fans try and give that thing full power and at the same sweep of the hand, try and dismiss lanturns part in containing that thing in a joint effort to elevate superman. You then turn around and insult anyone that see through your folly and of course other superman fans will support you, right down to socks and the house of el. I consider you my friend, so i can tell you this..... Stop. Just stop. Make me proud of you,not correcting you every turn. And don't get mouthy with me either.

http://comicboards.com/php/show.php?msg=superman-2003051204363900&search=veitch&searchcommand=multi&layout=thread

I don't think we actually worked out the physics of the black hole, but I think SUPERMAN was able to keep the mechanism from releasing the black hole completely. When he threw it into the wormhole it released.
But then again, maybe not

That's an e-mail 11 years ago if you didn't know. And it says the same thing the writer said here. The only thing that was stopping the black hole from getting released completely was Superman.

Just give me something from the comics and not some ass pull. Ok? Because we saw the black hole at the end of the comic among debris and it wasn't getting bigger.

And Lantern was assisting Superman because he was getting tired of holding the black hole and thought it would rip his hands off. Superman doesn't have infinite stamina. But enough of your babbling. Prove that the black hole was going to grow and destroy the

Originally posted by abhilegend
Common sense? Superman grabbed a black hole in his hands. How's that for common sense? The writer flat out admitted that he didn't think of physics.

http://comicboards.com/php/show.php?msg=superman-2003051204363900&search=veitch&searchcommand=multi&layout=thread

[/size]

That's an e-mail 11 years ago if you didn't know. And it says the same thing the writer said here. The only thing that was stopping the black hole from getting released completely was Superman.

Just give me something from the comics and not some ass pull. Ok? Because we saw the black hole at the end of the comic among debris and it wasn't getting bigger.

And Lantern was assisting Superman because he was getting tired of holding the black hole and thought it would rip his hands off. Superman doesn't have infinite stamina. But enough of your babbling. Prove that the black hole was going to grow and destroy the

An obscure interview given by someone involved in a story arc is not proof to refute feats. Neither is a random post by a supposed writer on a message board, blogs, tweets, etc. There have been too many of these so called interviews which go against what's shown on panel. Especially when there is no dialogue to refute what's happening on panel. Most writers are clear with the intentions of the plot and story arc.

Quit breaking the rules. We go by the scans. Shared feat anyways.

But then again maybe not......

Do you read your own responses ??

Originally posted by psycho gundam
You don't know what you're talking about at all. I quoted your post not Leo's. No offense to him but I don't even know what post you're referring to, anyway, you're just as wrong as ever and under the guise of this mathematician thing you're out here giving false information.

We went over this feat years ago and it's tiring that it's still being talked about today.

The guy in the email say that Superman kept the mechanism from releasing the black hole. The black hole wasn't even released due to Superman. He said when Superman threw it in the wormhole, that's when the black hole released.