KMC Star Wars Community Tier effort

Nothing would ever "officially" rank any group of characters, its just to group them based on the power of their showings/skills. Believe it or not that can be done based on comparative analysis/conversation with fellow posters, which is what has been going on for thirteen pages now. No one is forcing to be apart of it, and I never made a claim it was wholly representative of the forum. Now unless you have anything to add, could you please refrain from derailing the thread with pointless protests?

DMB and carthage should get married tbh.

It's hardly pointless. I have a problem with this thread being made a sticky as if it was official. Feel free to continue, but I have a problem with this thread being specially stickied among the other thousands of threads on here when it is not officially representative. I don't care if you made it, or if one of my friends made it. I do not think this thread should be a sticky.

DMB's just mad because his year-long struggle to ban Carthage on account of sensitivity over Bane is being pushed to the wayside, tbh.

That said, this tier list is looking pretty messy as is.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
You can make this topic if you want. But I have a problem with it being made a sticky or somehow being considered "official" when it does not accurately reflect the views of the forum.

Yeah Dmb's right. It takes out the fun out of debating. Idk know about you guys.but i'd rather not all argument go. "X person is tier 6, and Y person is tier 5 there's a gap" or we could get this argument "everyone on Tier 6>Everyone on tier 5."that's just ridiculous and is an unfair way to judge characters. Dmb makes a great point. I couldnt careless who made the Tier list, im against Antoine Bandele's list on CV. Feel free to continue though, but this would kinda ruin the Vs.threads IMO.

EDIT: And Antoine's list on CV has Jaden right below Revan btw

No one claimed it was official 👆 so your complaints are without merit. No one complained in the comic threads when their characters were tiered, and it was strictly for the purposes of knowing when and what characters are and should be grouped with based off of feats/overall ability. If you really think its not representative of X members, then feel free to make claims on what we can do to rectify that.

Originally posted by Fated Xtasy
Yeah Dmb's right. It takes out the fun out of debating. Idk know about you guys.but i'd rather not all argument go. "X person is tier 6, and Y person is tier 5 there's a gap" or we could get this argument "everyone on Tier 6>Everyone on tier 5."that's just ridiculous and is an unfair way to judge characters. Dmb makes a great point. I couldnt careless who made the Tier list, im against Antoine Bandele's list on CV. Feel free to continue though, but this would kinda ruin the Vs.threads IMO.

Well the point of the thread was initially for the mods to know whether or not a certain match was spite from my understanding. List is for a general reference on where certain figures stack up, and that has potential.

Too bad you guys aren't contributing. :mmm:

I have always been against the idea of a tier thread. It's one of the reasons I don't care for Comicvine.

Again, feel free to continue making it, but I do not believe this thread should receive any special treatment from the mods, ie. A sticky

I'd probably love Comicvine if it actually had a SW forum.

People were being reported based on a poster getting mad accusing a match being "Spite". With even the most general outline for characters, Bada and or the resident mod could see for himself what characters belong where- and if the accusations merit the claim of a match being "spite thread".

Originally posted by carthage
Do you have the scan for that bombing run feat? I'm aware it was when he was walking to Iziz. But since you couldn't provide a scan for that "moving in a blur" to Ulic/Nomi-I'd just like to verify [/B]

There are two brand new respect threads from me and ILS, use them, that is half the reason they are there.

...I've gotta wonder what Mace is doing back on Tier 7. He's got some pretty nice AOE against Droid armies.

I guess it depends on how much merit you want to put into Old CW feats. I don't see how he goes from decimating entire armies, to not being able to lift an Ak dog and saying outright he couldn't lift a transport on Haruun Kal.

His best feat is gathering energy and pushing down that walker. I agree he was placed awfully low on CV, but thank you for your post.

Anyone else on moving Mace up?

Well...what was the last point on the timeline? The decimation of armies, or stupidly nerfed Mace?

Mace definitely needs to be higher, he isn't pulling Yoda level stuff by any means but Tier 7 is ludicrous.

The 'Nerfed' Mace was in his novel Shatterpoint/The TCW series, and his more controversial feats took place on the Animated 2003 TCW series

Would Ahsoka be tier 5 or 6?

Wherever Ayala is, tbh.

Force Power
Tier 10

Luke Skywalker
Darth Sidious
Tier 9

Yoda
Darth Plagueis
Starkiller
Kyp Durron / Darth Caedus
(You guys will need to help me out with high tier Force wielders, not my speciality whatsoever)

Tier 8

Darth Nihilus
Darth Traya
Revan
Galen Marek
Darth Vader / Anakin Skywalker
Darth Malgus / Leia Organa Solo
Count Dooku / Darth Krayt / Darth Malak / Xesh/Exar Kun/
Mara Jade Skywalker/Mace Windu
Tier 7

Shaak Ti
Darth Maul / Daegen Lok / Skal'nas
Corran Horn / The Exile / Neja Halcyon / Savage Opress
Plo Koon/Kenth Hamner
Asajj Ventress / Mace Windu / Saesee Tiin / Sora Bulq/Saba Sebatyne

Tier 6

Obi-Wan Kenobi
Quinlan Vos

Mace Windu moved to lower tier 8

Originally posted by |King Joker|
Would Ahsoka be tier 5 or 6?

For lightsaber skill or force ability?

No one ever made a tier 5, but it can be done if there enough posters willing to contribute duelists who'd fit in that level.