Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Ive never seen Hulk stop a 100Ton+ Chitauri Leviathan with a single punch!
Well you have to power scale as well. Thor can stop Hulk's arm with one arm, and hold it there with 2 arms. So that would suggest Hulk being something like 1.5 times stronger than Thor.
3* stronger is a helluva claim.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Well you have to power scale as well. Thor can stop Hulk's arm with one arm, and hold it there with 2 arms. So that would suggest Hulk being something like 1.5 times stronger than Thor.3* stronger is a helluva claim.
The fact that Thor can hold Hulks arm doeant mean he can stop a 100+ Ton beast with one punch.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Well no, because that would make Thor's strength = to Hulk's, which it obviously isn't.Although he probably could with Mjolnor.
No. Thor has never replicate such a feat. No even with Mjolnir.
Thor hasnt faced anything of the magnitude of that Leviathan. Nor he has ever shown to depower his opponents the way Hulk depowered that Leviathan.
Movie Feat Wise Hulk is easily more than 3x stronger.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No. Thor has never replicate such a feat. No even with Mjolnir.Thor hasnt faced anything of the magnitude of that Leviathan. Nor he has ever shown to depower his opponents the way Hulk depowered that Leviathan.
He doesn't have to have shown those things. He only has to have grappled Hulk to prove Hulk is likely not even twice as strong as him. Let alone 3 times as strong.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No. Thor has never replicate such a feat. No even with Mjolnir.Thor hasnt faced anything of the magnitude of that Leviathan. Nor he has ever shown to depower his opponents the way Hulk depowered that Leviathan.
Movie Feat Wise Hulk is easily more than 3x stronger.
Hulk has never been able to bust up a whole town with a single hit either. Nor was he able to take down multiple leviathans like Thor did.
Originally posted by FrothByte
Hulk has never been able to bust up a whole town with a single hit either. Nor was he able to take down multiple leviathans like Thor did.
Except Lightning doesnt count as Strength. And Mjolnir's magic neither.
To say Thor is in par with Hulk is Fanatism. To say Hulk is 2x stronger than Thor is ignorance. To say Hulk is 3x+ stronger than Thor is proven the moment Hulk stopped that Leviathan with his fist.
Originally posted by Darth Thor
He doesn't have to have shown those things. He only has to have grappled Hulk to prove Hulk is likely not even twice as strong as him. Let alone 3 times as strong.
No. That shows Hulk wasnt anger enough. Or that he knew it was Thor and didnt want to break the shit out of him.
You cant compare a fight between enemies and a fight between allies.
This is a MVF. They are fighting to Death.
Hulks punch on the Leviathan is a striking feat. Thor has the best striking feats in the MCU. A charged hammer strike would do the same.
Based on the after credit scene in Ragnarok, the fight was a draw.
Grandmaster ended the fight when Thor was getting going, and was worried about Hulk losing.
These are inarguable. The fact is, Thor tanked everything Hulk gave him, he never looked stunned. Hulk didn't either, aside for a brief moment after a lightning punch. The fight was a draw. Hulk was stronger, Thor was on powerful and came out looking better
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
No. That shows Hulk wasnt anger enough. Or that he knew it was Thor and didnt want to break the shit out of him.You cant compare a fight between enemies and a fight between allies.
This is a MVF. They are fighting to Death.
The Hulk was angrier during the Thor scene.
Originally posted by Josh_Alexander
Except Lightning doesnt count as Strength. And Mjolnir's magic neither.To say Thor is in par with Hulk is Fanatism. To say Hulk is 2x stronger than Thor is ignorance. To say Hulk is 3x+ stronger than Thor is proven the moment Hulk stopped that Leviathan with his fist.
And the strength of a strike doesn't necessarily correspond to a person's strength. That's why heavyweight boxers can punch harder than strongmen champions.
Nobody here, nobody, ever claimed that Thor was AS strong as Hulk. But the fact that Thor was able to block Hulk's punch with 1 arm and hold it down with two is the best metric we have which shows Hulk being around 1.5-2x stronger than Thor.
Originally posted by FrothByte
And the strength of a strike doesn't necessarily correspond to a person's strength. That's why heavyweight boxers can punch harder than strongmen champions.Nobody here, nobody, ever claimed that Thor was AS strong as Hulk. But the fact that Thor was able to block Hulk's punch with 1 arm and hold it down with two is the best metric we have which shows Hulk being around 1.5-2x stronger than Thor.
I have been here like a week. It is long enough to tell that guy is an absolute clown with no debate skills. No REAL ones. He isn't taking into account Thor's feats, not objectively. He is doing it in a biased manner. His entire argument is confirmation bias which is technically a fallacy. His arguments are invalid by the very way he presents them. With biased logic to support his perspective and exclusively discredit Thor.
There is a reason data that is reached from experiments with confirmation bias is inconclusive. The guy has already lost, there is no reason to debate him. It just reinforces it.