Khan vs Khan
Original Khan vs New Khan.
Montalban vs Cumberbatch.
Takes place in a DS9 Holodeck mimicing a tropical jungle. Neither is aware that they are in a Holodeck. They start off at opposing end of the deck, and let's say about 30 meters apart.
Who outdoes the other in regards to:
Strength
Endurance
Intelligence
Just curious out of all the love I see for the character.
Physically, they're the same character. As the time-line split didn't change their birth.
Montalban's version is much older though. So Cumberbatch's has the youth advantage in a fight.
As far as iconic, Montalban is and will be the only true Khan Noonien Singh. Cumberbatch's version likely won't last the test of time.
Originally posted by Robtard
Physically, they're the same character. As the time-line split didn't change their birth.Montalban's version is much older though. So Cumberbatch's has the youth advantage in a fight.
As far as iconic, Montalban is and will be the only true Khan Noonien Singh. Cumberbatch's version likely won't last the test of time.
So being that Montalban's is older, and likely wiser, shouldn't that give him an edge?
Originally posted by RobtardNo, they aren't. We can see physically they aren't similar at all. It's like saying experience doesn't matter at all. So I guess by robs logic weight training wouldn't change your body because your birth was still the same day. Idiot. Their experiences are entirely different post wake up.
Physically, they're the same character. As the time-line split didn't change their birth.Montalban's version is much older though. So Cumberbatch's has the youth advantage in a fight.
As far as iconic, Montalban is and will be the only true Khan Noonien Singh. Cumberbatch's version likely won't last the test of time.
Nerdy Trekkers like yourself can speak for yourselves. Cumberbatch is the better Khan and empire also agrees.
NuKhan also let Kirk wail on him and he tired himself out hitting him. Whereas the original Kirk beat montalban's version one on one.
Khan Into Darkness rapes this weaker version with weaker experiences than Abrams Khan.
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, they aren't. We can see physically they aren't similar at all. It's like saying experience doesn't matter at all. So I guess by robs logic weight training wouldn't change your body because your birth was still the same day. Idiot. Their experiences are entirely different post wake up.Nerdy Trekkers like yourself can speak for yourselves. Cumberbatch is the better Khan and empire also agrees.
NuKhan also let Kirk wail on him and he tired himself out hitting him. Whereas the original Kirk beat montalban's version one on one.
Khan Into Darkness rapes this weaker version with weaker experiences than Abrams Khan.
You're incorrect again. The reason they look physically different is because two different actors did the same role. "It's different actors, that means the characters can't be the same!" 😂
Good lord, is your attention span as short as your height? I've explained this to you multiple times. Khan's birth wasn't altered by the time-line split.
Originally posted by RobtardTheir ages are different as are their experiences. That's the point. Experience shapes who people are and what they are capable of. Based off your claims Michael Jordan doesn't need to practice basketball and will end up the same.
You're incorrect again. The reason they look physically different is because two different actors did the same role. "It's different actors, that means the characters can't be the same!" 😂Good lord, is your attention span as short as your height? I've explained this to you multiple times. Khan's birth wasn't altered by the time-line split.
I never said his birth I said his experiences post reawakening. Completely different Khans. We see one Kirk beat him and one Kirk fail to even wind him after free shots.
😂
You love the old Khan. I love that you said it. I always knew, Trekkie.
Originally posted by quanchi112
Their ages are different as are their experiences. That's the point. Experience shapes who people are and what they are capable of. Based off your claims Michael Jordan doesn't need to practice basketball and will end up the same.I never said his birth I said his experiences post reawakening. Completely different Khans. We see one Kirk beat him and one Kirk fail to even wind him after free shots.
😂
You love the old Khan. I love that you said it. I always knew, Trekkie.
I said they're "physically the same character", because they are, just portrayed by two different actors. You disagreed and flipped out, stated that they can't be the same because they "look different". Now you're trying to backpedal because you realize what flop you produced.
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, they aren't. We can see physically they aren't similar at all.
😂 @ U RN
Originally posted by RobtardDue to training. That's why I referenced weightlifting/training. Just because they are the same person their training and activities clearly matter. You're too dumb to even follow along. Why do you think I said Jordan needs to practice to be great not that they end up the same because they were born on the same day.
I said they're "physically the same character", you disagreed and flipped out, stated that they can't be the same because they "look different". Now you're trying to backpedal because you realize what flop you produced.😂
I just love that you admitted you prefer the older khan to the Benedict version. This was indeed a victory for me.
LoLz, look at the backflips, you claimed they're entirely different characters, they're not. Sure they've had different life experiences starting at point 'X'. They're still the same Khan, despite being played by two different actors.
This is so sad:
Originally posted by quanchi112
No, they aren't. We can see physically they aren't similar at all.
Originally posted by RobtardNu Khan had training whereas old khan woke up and tried to take over the enterprise. Are you familiar with their experiences being different ? Their physiques are different. Benedict put on muscle for the role. But according to Robbie same bday is all that matters. You're always confused and I don't expect you to grasp a point.
LoLz, look at the backflips, you claimed they're different characters, they're not. Sure they've had different life experiences starting at point 'X1.This is so sad:
🙂