Goten & Trunks vs. The Gero Family...

Started by cdtm4 pages
Originally posted by Galan007
And again: the boys had suppressed the blast that #18 freaked out about.

Counter point: There's also the fact they weren't taking #18's head off with a single punch.

I'm not contesting that the boys are higher then #18. I think the ki attacks do prove that.

But we're also not talking about Vegeta vs Recoome or Imperfect Cell vs the Android gap in power.

I mean, the Saibaman were, what, 1,200? And Ten, Krilling, and Yamcha were't even in the 2k's, yet they walked all over them.

Originally posted by Galan007
Lol? This was NOT a "casual" punch from Vegeta:

He became visibly pissed when Trunks actually managed a glancing blow, and punched Trunks like he would an enemy. Given the power Vegeta was packing during the Buu saga, to say that the same punch would not have incapacitated the Androids(at the very least) is to drastically lowball Vegeta, imo. By the end of the Cell saga he had become SEVERAL times more powerful than the Androids--and Buu saga Vegeta>Cell saga Vegeta, so...

Every person Vegeta fought in the Buu Saga he fought with intent to kill. He also put a lot more effort into knocking Goku out while he was distracted than the hit against Trunks. Vegeta was not hitting Trunks with that much force on a reflex. For comparison this is what Vegeta was hitting at when trying to kill Goku.

It's Goku doing the hitting but the two are more or less equal at the time(sans SSJ3 of course). My point is that Vegeta was trying to knock Trunks away, not kill him. Given his "oops" he probably didn't even mean to hurt Trunks.

Originally posted by Galan007
We both know those blasts were completely different. The blast you mentioned barely singed Gotenks' clothing. Conversely, the blast Trunks fired at #18 created a rather large explosion:

C'mon, don't lowball.

I'm not lowballing. I'm using a ki blast from a heat of the moment move done without thinking(Trunks uses his left hand when he'd made a conscious choice not to earlier) to one that is significantly more powerful(though as you have said multiple times, it isn't Trunks' full power).

Just like how a punch thrown in the heat of the moment(when he'd not been attacking at all) will logically lack the power of a punch meant to kill or even seriously harm.

Originally posted by Galan007
Not true. The boys mentioned that #18 used to be more powerful than Goku/Vegeta, and as such, they weren't going to underestimate her. However, if they didn't think their ki blasts would have been able to harm her, they wouldn't have consciously suppressed the blast to make sure she didn't get hurt.

#18's own reaction to the blast tells us all we need to know:

If they aren't underestimating her then they aren't going to hold back a massive amount of power. Trunks is specifically not trying to kill her but he is almost certainly trying to hurt her. Because otherwise there is no point to the Ki blast.

Eh my copy doesn't have her say it is dangerous. She says "in that case...I better end this quickly!" But that is playing semantics. And while she reacted to their blast that way it is important to note that Goten and Trunks similarly dodged her attack to get out of the way. She can certainly harm them.

Originally posted by Galan007
I know. I said that. none

Those panels were simply meant to demonstrate Trunks acting in a 'bloodlusted' capacity. Obviously I'm not comparing the boys to Fat Buu. srsly

I know you said that sir. Was just agreeing with you. 😛

Oh Trunks and Goten are massively strong when they are mad. That is non-negotiable. But they are also stupid kids and being half blooded Saiyans seem to lack talent for fighting, instead compensating with sheer power(note how they underestimate Buu, Future Trunks failed to see the failure in his USSJ mode, and Goten being able to generate enough Ki to go SSJ and shoot blasts but not be able to fly). For instance I don't disagree that they would beat 19 and 20. But I do think that Gero would be able to hide, wait for a ki blast, absorb it, then hide again. Trunks and Goten aren't intelligent fighters. They are inventive and unpredictable at times. But they are also very dumb(see where they counted on Buu to let them fuse).

I also wouldn't take Gohan's showing against Buu compared to Trunks' to mean something. Gohan had fought with Dabura and previously already been hit with an attack by Buu(the same kind that knocked Dabura out for a bit). He's pretty weakened by that point.

Originally posted by Galan007
This is how the Daizenshuu defines FPSSJ:

So Gotenks/Trunks were FPSSJ, according to the official/canon definition of the form. 👆

Gotten rid of their wild personality huh?

Keep in mind how Goku and Gohan, the two most noteworthy FPSSJs since we see them doing it most, trained it. They stayed as Super Saiyans. One translation I read said they only stopped it when they slept and another didn't have that. Picnics, going to Namek, Dragonball hunting, driving the car, and so on. The two were never not transformed and they were completely calm and relaxed. The only time it stopped was when Cell killed people.

Trunks and Goten couldn't have done that. They couldn't stay in Super Saiyan mode for days upon days. The former because his dad didn't even know he could be a SSJ(which logically means Bulma probably didn't know as she never told him) and the latter because Chi-Chi outright forbade him from transforming(and we know he never did so around Gohan until it was tournament training time). They don't have the time to get used to the form. Also they deliberately got out of the form when they neared Majin Buu for the first time so they wouldn't be detected. But if Vegeta is to be believed then a FPSSJ is indistinguishable from their normal form unless they make a conscious effort to flex their power.

Also both Goten and Trunks are surprised that there is a form surpassing SSJ(when they are training in the ROSAT). If the Cell Saga is to be believed the chain of logic for discovery goes SSJ->ASSJ->USSJ->FPSSJ->SSJ2. Gohan got to skip 2 and 3 because Goku pointed out their flaws but Vegeta and Trunks both went to ASSJ and USSJ. Regardless Trunks and Goten seem surprised that SSJ can be surpassed at all which wouldn't make sense if they were Full Powered Super Saiyans. It would honestly surprise me if it ever occurred to them that one could get stronger by just staying Super Saiyan for a while.

I just don't really believe that in addition to becoming Super Saiyans they also became perfect Super Saiyans at the same time. Doesn't add up to me.

Dude, up to that point becoming a SSJ PERIOD didn't add up without a ton of training and a soul crushing event. Even Future Trunks didn't hit SSJ until Gohan died.

Yet 'Geta clearly wasn't even training them, Goku was dead, and Gohan was as surprised as anyone about their power. And they had a pretty nomal, pain free childhood up until Buu came along.

With all that, why not go fpssj? Would make no less sense then anything else about them.

By that logic they could be SSJ2 lol.

I just assume they are children who one day they discovered could do a neat trick and then left it at that, though of course they told each other.

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Every person Vegeta fought in the Buu Saga he fought with intent to kill. He also put a lot more effort into knocking Goku out while he was distracted than the hit against Trunks. Vegeta was not hitting Trunks with that much force on a reflex.
You originally said that Vegeta punched Trunks "casually", and now you're backpedaling a bit. As made clear in the scene I posted: that was NOT a casual punch. That was a powered up/pissed off punch from a guy SEVERAL TIMES more powerful then all of the Androids put together. HUGE difference.

Originally posted by AuraAngel
It's Goku doing the hitting but the two are more or less equal at the time(sans SSJ3 of course). My point is that Vegeta was trying to knock Trunks away, not kill him. Given his "oops" he probably didn't even mean to hurt Trunks.
Vegeta didn't originally intend to punch Trunks. He punched Trunks because his defenses were clearly getting overwhelmed:
http://i.imgur.com/QbPxoFN.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/r3qpE3o.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/9yInnEp.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/1GDmOsb.jpg

...Hence the "oops."

Originally posted by AuraAngel
I'm not lowballing. I'm using a ki blast from a heat of the moment move done without thinking(Trunks uses his left hand when he'd made a conscious choice not to earlier) to one that is significantly more powerful(though as you have said multiple times, it isn't Trunks' full power).
It's a faulty analogy regardless. The ki blasts were vastly different in terms of lethality.

Originally posted by AuraAngel
If they aren't underestimating her then they aren't going to hold back a massive amount of power.
Except they did hold back... Because we were told they held back. Despite this, #18 was still awestruck at the power of the blast.

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Eh my copy doesn't have her say it is dangerous. She says "in that case...I better end this quickly!" But that is playing semantics. And while she reacted to their blast that way it is important to note that Goten and Trunks similarly dodged her attack to get out of the way. She can certainly harm them.
Of course they wanted to dodge her Kienzan. Do you think they'd want to get decapitated? How on earth does that reflect poorly on the boys? No one has ever withstood a direct hit from a Kienzan in the manga. srsly

Originally posted by AuraAngel
I know you said that sir. Was just agreeing with you. 😛
Oh, my bad. 😛

Originally posted by AuraAngel
I also wouldn't take Gohan's showing against Buu compared to Trunks' to mean something. Gohan had fought with Dabura and previously already been hit with an attack by Buu(the same kind that knocked Dabura out for a bit). He's pretty weakened by that point.
There is no reason to assume Gohan's fight with Dabra weakened him very much at all. Dabra only landed one shot successfully(two if you count the spit), and Gohan seemed just fine afterward--there was also a considerable amount of time between Gohan's encounter with Dabra and his encounter with Buu, to boot... And while Buu had punched Gohan once, before he delivered the cheap-shot, nothing indicated that he was weakened by some vast margin.

Trunks' cheap-shot-kick was just SO much more impressive than Gohan's that it's staggering, really. But again: I don't think the boys are on par with the adults. I DO, however, think they're much closer to that level then most realize, and/or want to believe.

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Gotten rid of their wild personality huh?
These pages literally do not disprove anything at all in regards to the boys being classified as FPSSJ... Especially the Gotenks pages(not only is Gotenks an entirely different person, but he also displayed a level of arrogance that the boys NEVER displayed individually.)

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Keep in mind how Goku and Gohan, the two most noteworthy FPSSJs since we see them doing it most, trained it. They stayed as Super Saiyans. One translation I read said they only stopped it when they slept and another didn't have that. Picnics, going to Namek, Dragonball hunting, driving the car, and so on. The two were never not transformed and they were completely calm and relaxed. The only time it stopped was when Cell killed people.
I just posted the Daizenshuu's definition of a FPSSJ(Super Saiyan Grade Four.) Goten and Trunks fit the description perfectly.

A calm/playful/relaxed demeanor certainly doesn't fit the description of Grades I, II, or III, after all, so where would YOU rank them, if not Grade IV? srsly

Originally posted by AuraAngel
Also both Goten and Trunks are surprised that there is a form surpassing SSJ(when they are training in the ROSAT). If the Cell Saga is to be believed the chain of logic for discovery goes SSJ->ASSJ->USSJ->FPSSJ->SSJ2. Gohan got to skip 2 and 3 because Goku pointed out their flaws but Vegeta and Trunks both went to ASSJ and USSJ. Regardless Trunks and Goten seem surprised that SSJ can be surpassed at all which wouldn't make sense if they were Full Powered Super Saiyans. It would honestly surprise me if it ever occurred to them that one could get stronger by just staying Super Saiyan for a while.
No. In the Buu saga(which is the arc in question), SSJ2 is noted as 'the Super Saiyan which surpasses a Super Saiyan':

The 'levels within levels' theme was confined solely to the Cell saga, and is certainly NOT what the boys were referring to when they were training in the RoSaT(they didn't have time for that.)

Originally posted by cdtm
Counter point: There's also the fact they weren't taking #18's head off with a single punch.
Not a very good counter point.

The boys didn't throw any physical blows at #18 after going SSJ--they just fired that one blast before she DQ'd them with her Kienzan. We don't know what their SSJ-level punches would have done to her one way or the other...

Originally posted by cdtm
I'm not contesting that the boys are higher then #18. I think the ki attacks do prove that.
Cool beans. 👆

They weren't fighting as SSJ's?

Did the manga specify/imply their power up? Because if they were holding their own as base Saiyans, either #18 was seriously holding back (And as she told Krillin, that's not so easy for her), they're pretty strong even at base (Low SSJ level or somewhere close), or it's just a bad showing for her.

And as I recall, nobody else was holding back from one shotting the scrubs. Plus, #18 was pretty motivated to win that money. 🙂

In a nutshell: they fought #18 in their base levels for a bit, transformed into SSJs(yes, the SSJ power-up was shown/stated), fired one suppressed blast(the one #18 freaked out about), and were DQ'd by her Kienzan.

Originally posted by Reflassshh
They make it pass Semi-perfect Cell after a hard fight. Cell junior stomps them.
Just saw this.

Anyway, you've summed up all the reasons behind my stance. (ie: Almost overwhelming a FPSSJ, #18 fight etc)

I see a lot of feats pertaining to Trunks, but how does Goten stack up next to him?

Originally posted by john allerdyce
I see a lot of feats pertaining to Trunks, but how does Goten stack up next to him?

Well, Goten can do Kamehamehas, but he has terrible aim. Nearly hit the crowd and clipped a few buildings.

Trunks told Vegeta he's a little bit weaker when they fight.

Which made him mad, because he felt at a year older, Trunks should be more then a little ahead of him.

Originally posted by Galan007
In a nutshell: they fought #18 in their base levels for a bit, transformed into SSJs(yes, the SSJ power-up was shown/stated), fired one suppressed blast(the one #18 freaked out about), and were DQ'd by her Kienzan.

The question then, is why was #18 even going easy on them when they were at base. KRILLIN of all people two shot a chump in the early rounds.

Originally posted by john allerdyce
I see a lot of feats pertaining to Trunks, but how does Goten stack up next to him?
When the boys both powered up to maximum, Goku noted that Trunks was only "slightly stronger" than Goten, and attributed that difference exclusively to Trunks being a year older:


(Also note Piccolo's utterly shocked expression on the first page when he senses the boys' power.)

That's why Goten was able to nearly overwhelm Gohan's defenses when they sparred:
http://i.imgur.com/TgOSo8y.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/n89NYEr.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/fbl7MeI.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/3naPmXB.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/vnax7tE.jpg
...Much like Trunks nearly did to Vegeta

Perhaps, but I'm imagine learning the two snot punks you had a hand in raising and seeing through the odd temper tantrum could wipe the floor with you now. 🙂

Originally posted by cdtm
The question then, is why was #18 even going easy on them when they were at base. KRILLIN of all people two shot a chump in the early rounds.
Not really sure what you're asking here..?

I believe #18>base Goten/Trunks(she's also > base Goku/Vegeta for what it's worth), and SSJ Goten/Trunks>>#18.

Originally posted by Galan007
Not really sure what you're asking here..?

I believe #18>base Goten/Trunks(she's also > base Goku/Veget

a for what it's worth), and SSJ Goten/Trunks>>#18.

I'm asking why she didn't clobber them when she had a chance.

Seems ooc that she was holding back to such an extent, that the kids could sneak in attacks and draw the fight out.

Sure, Goku does that stupid stuff all the time, but everyone else seemed content on one shotting every weakling in the tourney.

Originally posted by cdtm
I'm asking why she didn't clobber them when she had a chance.

Seems ooc that she was holding back to such an extent, that the kids could sneak in attacks and draw the fight out.

Sure, Goku does that stupid stuff all the time, but everyone else seemed content on one shotting every weakling in the tourney.

Seemed like she was trying to fight 'Mighty Mask' long enough to figure out who he really was, because she knew he was far too powerful(and looked far too disproportionate, lol) to be a normal adult earthling. It wasn't until the boys went SSJ that she figured out Mighty Mask's true identities.

Originally posted by Galan007
And again: the boys had suppressed the blast that #18 freaked out about.

Still while she was worried about how dangerous this was. She was confident she would still win. She went on to say "Trunks! Goten! I'm going to win!" or to that effect. At no point did she ever feel worried about not beating them. If anything she could have been worried about the explosions they were unleashing and that her daughter was in the crowd.

^ Incorrect.

Immediately after(literally) #18 made that "OMFG!!" statement, she used a Kienzan to split Mighty Mask apart, because she knew it would result in an automatic DQ for the boys... After seeing the type of power they could casually generate, she wanted no part of a continued battle--her dumbfounded/awestruck narrative was indicative enough of that.

Even if she wasn't weaker then them, I think she'd still opt for the cheap win. Partly because all she cared about was the money, and partly because dinner parties would be pretty awkward after beating the crap out of their kids. 😉