Kas'im vs. Shaak Ti

Started by Nephthys15 pages

The question mark, deeeerp.

What question mark. I don't understand you.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Doesn't the book give the dimensions of the Rakatan temple?
Originally posted by Nephthys
Retconned.

It's not difficult mmm

I've never read where the temples dimensions have been retconned

Clearly because you suck at reading.

Or more likely, it hasn't been retconned mmm

I wasn't actually suggesting that as an option, it was a statement of fact. Don't worry, you'll get the reading thing down some day.

Neph's kind of shooting himself in the foot with this "the guy who regularly out-debates me can't read" thing.

I don't think I've debated Tempest for quite some time actually. It's certainly not a regular thing.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
I've never read where the temples dimensions have been retconned

You can't exactly retcon something that's a fallible character statement that's contradicted by every visual depiction of the thing :hmm

It also withstood turbolaser blasts while still being structurally intact.

Nah. The temple was most likely destroyed.

The Bane novel has been retconned. :woah:

Nope, lol.

Given the many centuries that separate Bane from SWTOR, there's no evidence to indicate a retcon. Perhaps the temple is reconstructed or renovated in that time. 👆

Originally posted by Nephthys
I wasn't actually suggesting that as an option, it was a statement of fact. Don't worry, you'll get the reading thing down some day.

Your hostility is most gratifying. excellent

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Given the many centuries that separate Bane from SWTOR, there's no evidence to indicate a retcon. Perhaps the temple is reconstructed or renovated in that time. 👆

No-one lives on the planet and it was explicitly hidden from the galactic records. The temple is noted as ancient and it still had Revan's holocron inside, undamaged. There's also absolutely no reason why anyone would do as you suggest.

And there was a retcon, from Kotor to Swtor.

That didn't prevent travelers from visiting Lehon in SWTOR. At some unspecified point in the many centuries between SWTOR and Bane, the temple could have very well been modified. "Ancient" is also a pretty vague term; a value has not been assigned to preclude the possibility that construction could have occurred that would still be "ancient" to Bane's eyes.

You have presented no compelling evidence of a retcon between Bane and SWTOR.

Lehon was a protected historical site and preserve. As in, they were preserving it. Revan's holocron was undisturbed. And there's Rakatan writing on the walls of the temple which no-one can reproduce. There's absolutely no evidence of the temple being reconstructed and no reason why it would be. No-one lived on the planet.

And as I said, it was factually retconned between Kotor and Swtor. Bane's descriptions were based on the Kotor version which was retconned. That's the actual reason for the change, there isn't another one. You're entirely making this up and speculating on nothing more than a desire to restrict Bane's feats.

Agreeing with Neph at the moment.

Originally posted by Nephthys
Lehon was a protected historical site and preserve. As in, they were preserving it. Revan's holocron was undisturbed. And there's Rakatan writing on the walls of the temple which no-one can reproduce. There's absolutely no evidence of the temple being reconstructed and no reason why it would be. No-one lived on the planet.

And as I said, it was factually retconned between Kotor and Swtor. Bane's descriptions were based on the Kotor version which was retconned. That's the actual reason for the change, there isn't another one. You're entirely making this up and speculating on nothing more than a desire to restrict Bane's feats.

Doesn't sound like me tbh.

But you have no means of actually proving that. Why couldn't the writings have been duplicated? How do you know travelers couldn't have gotten there to perform construction? Where is the evidence for the idea that it's simply s retcon?

It quite honestly seems more likely that you're trying to wank Bane further here.

Yeah, you never try to restrict the abilities of character's who aren't Sheev. Like Nihilus, Kreia, Vitiate, Kun etc. Never ever. 😉

Lol, I don't need to prove anything. The burden of proof is on you. You're the one trying to argue it was rebuilt based on nothing. No one can write in Rakatan. There's no point in rebuilding the temple considering they can't live there and there's no other reason to do so and it's a restricted and preserved planet. And there clearly was a retcon between Kotor and Swtor by Bioware. The descriptions in the Bane novel were based off of the Kotor design, written by a Bioware writer, which has been retconned.

I wasn't trying to do anything, you're the one who brought it up specifically to weaken Bane, I merely responded. It's so transparent I dunno why you're even bothering to deny it.