Nihilus and Vitiate vs. Sidious and Yoda

* Prime versions for all combatants.
* Sidious gets two sabers.
* No prep time.

Setting: Theed Royal Palace, Naboo.

Who wins?

Nihilus is the weak link

Assuming this is Ziost Vitiate and DE Sidious with Prime Yoda....

Vitiate can't carry Nihilus, who's got nothing on combatants this strong.

Nihilus and Vitiate

Yoda = Sidious > Vitiate >>> Nihilus

Team 2 comfortable

Team 2. Each is stronger than either opponent.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Team 2. Each is stronger than either opponent.

I have no doubt team 2 wins this but how is Yoda stronger than prime Vitiate?

Because he demonstrated comparable prowess to Sheev, who's more powerful than any incarnation of Valkoriate as of ROTS.

He is? I thought you yourself put Vitiate above ROTS Sidious after Ziost(which surprised me cause I myself am still not sure how that fight would go)?

Nah, doesn't sound like me. Sidious is confirmed as the most powerful Sith Lord as early as ROTS by various sources.

Power isn't everything.

Very true. But there's no reason to believe that Valkoriate is a superior warrior.

Vitiate gets stomped, then the duo wins at their leisure.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Nah, doesn't sound like me. Sidious is confirmed as the most powerful Sith Lord as early as ROTS by various sources.

Except Im pretty sure you did say that along with S66 when the new patches came out but anyway, it appears you don't believe that (anymore).

The OP should specify if Vitiate has a physical form cause if so, team 1 doesn't stand a chance.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Very true. But there's no reason to believe that Valkoriate is a superior warrior.

True, probably not. But as a Force User, I believe even you've admitted he may have the advantage right?

Originally posted by Sinious
I have no doubt team 2 wins this but how is Yoda stronger than prime Vitiate?

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Because he demonstrated comparable prowess to Sheev, who's more powerful than any incarnation of Valkoriate as of ROTS.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
Sidious is confirmed as the most powerful Sith Lord as early as ROTS by various sources.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Good thing Vitiate is no longer a Sith.

Huh, another one of Legends arguments turning out true. Creepy.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Good thing Vitiate is no longer a Sith.

Yeah, I recall you using the same argument with Nihilus. You ended up conceding.

You simply saying Valkoriate isn't a Sith doesn't make it true.

Originally posted by Sinious
Except Im pretty sure you did say that along with S66 when the new patches came out but anyway, it appears you don't believe that (anymore).

The OP should specify if Vitiate has a physical form cause if so, team 1 doesn't stand a chance.

You're free to remind me where that was said.

Originally posted by Nephthys
True, probably not. But as a Force User, I believe even you've admitted he may have the advantage right?

Than who?

Originally posted by The_Tempest
You simply saying Valkoriate isn't a Sith doesn't make it true.

Uh, Eternal Empire lol. He's undeniably aligned with a third-party faction and wants the Sith destroyed..