The First Emperor's Wrath vs. TCW Maul

Which warrior wins? Fight takes place on flat, neutral terrain.

What kind of legs does Maul have and what weapons?

Scourge should win. Mauls too emotional, Scourge would get a nice boost from him and he'd fight smarter than Maul. He also has better equipment than Maul, is certainly comparable in skill and has much more experience.

Maul, IMO.

Originally posted by Nephthys
What kind of legs does Maul have and what weapons?

Scourge should win. Mauls too emotional, Scourge would get a nice boost from him and he'd fight smarter than Maul. He also has better equipment than Maul, is certainly comparable in skill and has much more experience.

Maul takes Scourge, and then his successor.

Scourge wins

Maul hasn't fought anyone as skilled as Factory security droids, Darth Xedrix, and multiple Sith apprentices

Maul.

Maul brings Scourge down in all categories.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Maul takes Scourge, and then his successor re-bifurcates him.

Scourge stalemated the Hero of Tython without trying to win. He's been directly empowered by Vitiate and has hundreds of battles worth of experience. He is sent by the Emperor to kill any Sith too ambitious and any Jedi that are too powerful. He is meant to be stronger than Jadus, Malgus or Marr as well.

I am thinking Wrath Scourge.

Act II Hero is in no way on par with Maul, and Scourge probably isn't above any of those characters.

Assuming end of Act II HoT is much less than Act 3, who is more than on par with Maul. Except he is clearly capable of killing anyone in the Empire bar Vitiate himself.

Yeah, he kind of is inferior to his Act 3 incarnation. That's kind of how the game works - you progress through the story, and as you do, you grow more powerful.

Yes but the difference in time between end of Act II and Act III is essentially nil.

Based on what? The idea is that you progress throughout the game and constantly get stronger. You don't stop at Act II. It's comparable to the level-up system - it's a continuous improvement throughout the course of the entire game.

It's more reliable to just use the Hero's feats up to and of Act II as a measuring stick for Scourge. And that's not enough to beat Maul.

Because when Act II ends, obviously Act III begins. You realise how little actually takes place once you escape with Scourge right? Now if you had said end of Act II isn't as powerful as Act IV I would absolutely agree.

The Hero trains for an unspecified amount of time between Act II/Act III under Vitiate's influence. Also, HoT's feats are just better in Act III. His Dark Temple run, for instance.

Act II ends with Vitiate's training finished and his influence broken IIRC.

Isn't that the start of Act III? It's been too long, I don't remember.

Originally posted by carthage
Scourge wins

Maul hasn't fought anyone as skilled as Factory security droids, Darth Xedrix, and multiple Sith apprentices

LOL 👆