c.t.d. from previous page..
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
However, even granting you that false equivalency, my argument is hardly dependent on that quote. I have Ahsoka, at worst, stalemating Maul on an implied nexus as a direct comparison. I have Ahsoka confronting and contending with Vader on a nexus while Maul chickened out in fear of him(even witwer, who you consider to hold weight agrees) for holistic intent.
Hmm it's almost as if Maul isn't willing to fight people he can't defeat..
Heroes on the other hand are always willing to sacrifice themselves. Let's not pretend Ahsoka fought Vader because she ever had a shot at actually defeating him. Even Filoni's confirmed she couldn't.
As for Witwer.. We know he's quick to tell us who Maul can't take. Yet he's always talked about Ahsoka as a peer to Maul, not an inferior or superior.
So it's clearly not cut canon to everyone at Lucasfilm that Maul can't defeat Ahsoka.
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
You may have a point about errors if there was any basis to assume what was said by Feloni was erroneous. However there are no contradictions present in either Ahsoka or Maul's fight, what the sw,com quote explicitly says, or even your specific interpretation of the sw..com quote. All three can easily be reconciled without assuming the existence of some context in Felon's words aside from what he has stated.
Additionally Feloni's statement is supported both by on screen evidence and Maul and Ahsoka's holistic potryal.
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
However you play it, Maul still loses. Shame. 馃檨
Careful you're starting to sound like a Maul Hater 馃槢
Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Nah, the false equivalency you're trying to create here is the only reaching I'm seeing 馃槈
Oh there's certainly some Reaching going on with that SW.COM quote 馃槢