World Breaker Hulk VS PIS/CIS Free Thor

Originally posted by carver9
You don't make one bit of sense though. Why would you apply real world logic to cartoons? Lol, I just don't get it. You have people with planetary power walking around like normal with out bending humans in half while hugging them and you want to use real world logic. No amount of holding back explains that. You have a man who was part of a radiation explosion gaining super powers from said affect and you want to use real world logic. A alien landing on Earth, never detected by the Government gaining powers from the sun and you want to use real world logic for everything. WTF.

LOGIC AND SCIENCE AREN'T THE SAME THING.

Originally posted by carver9
Lol...that was proven when Rulk slaughtered Odin Force Thor

Originally posted by Galan007
Didn't Thor beat the absolute shit out of Loeb-Rulk, like the issue right after Rulk pulled that Mjolnir business against him..?

Rick, Hulk's biggest fanboy (after Cho, lol) said he was the greatest warrior. Whilst Hulk AND Rulk were right there. Can't get any clearer than that.

Rulk even admits that Hulk saved his life. He was literally killing him.

👆

Thor utterly humbled Rulk--would have killed him if Hulk hadn't intervened. Goes to show you that Rulk's win in the prior issue was nothing but cheap parlor tricks. 👆

Didn't Hulk then go on to beat Rulk through weakness exploitation (taking advantage of his heat)?

Whereas Thor just straight up beat the snot out of him. IIRC.

Originally posted by Galan007
Didn't Thor beat the absolute shit out of Loeb-Rulk, like the issue right after Rulk pulled that Mjolnir business against him..?

Their first encounter, Rulk treating him like fodder. Rulk eventually lose to all when he started over heating and that started as soon as his fight was done with Thor (during the time he dive bombed back to Earth). Then Thor surprise attacked him...THEN Rulk had fought Hulk before hand. A lot of context there if you ask me.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
So, IYO Thor was fighting Bi Beast with the same power and intensity as Gorr?

With hammer strikes? During the end of his fight against Bi Beast, he pounced on him and didn't seem happy when he did it. Without his hammer, he was getting worked and overpowered. With it, he did get an advantage.

Originally posted by -Pr-
LOGIC AND SCIENCE AREN'T THE SAME THING.

💃

You've proven my point. Hulk knocking down a skyscraper with people in it and no one getting killed doesn't speak logic but it happened and his mathmatical mind being the reason why still doesn't make sense. The guy split New York in half during his fight against Ironman and a single person did not die. No logic or science involved there either and all of this was said to be his super computer mind at play. You can not apply real world logic to a comic book, let alone logic.

Originally posted by carver9
💃

You've proven my point. Hulk knocking down a skyscraper with people in it and no one getting killed doesn't speak logic but it happened and his mathmatical mind being the reason why still doesn't make sense. The guy split New York in half during his fight against Ironman and a single person did not die. No logic or science involved there either and all of this was said to be his super computer mind at play. You can not apply real world logic to a comic book, let alone logic.

Yes you can. You can't apply it to every situation within comics, but logic is a far grander thing that can't be somehow sent away because of one bad example.

Carver does not use logic, logic is for wimps...

Now, that explains a lot.

Originally posted by carver9
With hammer strikes? During the end of his fight against Bi Beast, he pounced on him and didn't seem happy when he did it. Without his hammer, he was getting worked and overpowered. With it, he did get an advantage.

Uh huh. So that's a total non answer.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Uh huh. So that's a total non answer.

Are you implying that Thor held back since his creation due to not cracking planets?

Originally posted by carver9
Are you implying that Thor held back since his creation due to not cracking planets?

Not at all, although he has admitted to restraining himself, while on Midgard.

I'm simply asking if you think Thor was fighting Bi-Beast with the same ferocity as Gorr.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
Not at all, although he has admitted to restraining himself, while on Midgard.

I'm simply asking if you think Thor was fighting Bi-Beast with the same ferocity as Gorr.

If I say yes, how what route would you take proving me wrong?

Thor words doesn't appear as if he is holding back.

Originally posted by carver9
If I say yes, how what route would you take proving me wrong?

Firstly, I'd point out the fact that Thor was trying to protect the brainwashed humans that were attacking him.

Originally posted by carver9
Thor words doesn't appear as if he is holding back.

All this proves is that, if Thor wants to take BB down, he's going down.

Originally posted by Khazra Reborn
All this proves is that, if Thor wants to take BB down, he's going down.

With Mjlonir, yes. When he used his fist against Bi Beast, BB didn't even register it.

Here Bi Beast overpowered him (and didn't seem harmed at all by Thor fist)...

And BB restrains him yet again leaving Thor helpless.

http://s118.photobucket.com/user/bigbran1/media/Thor/Thor_1982_315_19.jpg.html

He obviously had the physical advantage. Mjlonir gave Thor an edge.

Those scans are older than 15 years

Carver already argued this exact same thing before surprisingly in a thread to pump up Hulk...
http://www.killermovies.com/forums/showthread.php?threadid=560584&pagenumber=5

Basically, as soon as Thor stopped holding back he instantly put Bi Beast down. Twice.

Obviously not as good as World Breaker's feat, but Bi Beast is still nothing to a serious Thor.