Silver Surfer vs Green Lantern

Started by Delta193839 pages
Originally posted by Sin I AM
💕💕💕 i heart u. But i will slay anyone who lowballs you included

And how is what I posted lowballing? 😬

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Surfer created a black hole as a simply side effect of his blast when destroying a planet

Surfer is just better.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Surfer is just better.

One feat does not make him better.

Both Hal and Kyle have better feat than Surfer. All you got to do is to look at the previous pages.

Originally posted by SquallX
One feat does not make him better.

Both Hal and Kyle have better feat than Surfer. All you got to do is to look at the previous pages.

I never said one feat made him better. His history and his advantages do. It's about the reasoning and how these guys match up not silly feats. All those years and the DC crowd still does not get it.

Originally posted by SquallX
One feat does not make him better.

Both Hal and Kyle have better feat than Surfer. All you got to do is to look at the previous pages.

Hal is way above top tier. Same with Kyle. Surfer is small potatoes compared to the top GL's. 😉

Originally posted by SquallX
One feat does not make him better.

Both Hal and Kyle have better feat than Surfer. All you got to do is to look at the previous pages.

This the Surfer feat being discussed?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Surfer created a black hole as a simply side effect of his blast when destroying a planet

If so, nice feat. If anybody thinks this supports Surfer>GLs, well, Kyle's construct created a black hole, then a quasar that Atom determined would cause the universe to "re-collapse" from consuming dark matter.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Oblivion also creates a black hole casually.

And something bigger, like a Quasar.

The punchline? He is just a construct who is using Kyle's power to do it.

Yeah, Kyle can create constructs who can create black holes and quasars.

Why is surfer more powerful again, eh?

I guess these feats don't count.
😆

Don't get into your feelings about it. I'm not trying to be provocative but it does seem like it's going that way.

Anyway, both black hole feats are fine and all, but what I think you're missing is the intent: Surfer's black hole was a side effect of his blast power whereas Oblivion's creations (I'm aware of his origin) were intentional.

This is kinda like why people went crazy back when Hulk's footsteps were about to make 1/5 of the United states star in the sequel to Titanic, something Black bolt has had to use his voice to replicate in scale was simply a byproduct of Hulk's casual advance forward.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Don't get into your feelings about it. I'm not trying to be provocative but it does seem like it's going that way.

Huh?

Originally posted by psycho gundam

Anyway, both black hole feats are fine and all, but what I think you're missing is the intent: Surfer's black hole was a side effect of his blast power whereas Oblivion's creations (I'm aware of his origin) were intentional.

This is kinda like why people went crazy back when Hulk's footsteps were about to make 1/5 of the United states star in the sequel to Titanic, something Black bolt has had to use his voice to replicate in scale was simply a byproduct of Hulk's casual advance forward.

I know what you mean. It "being intentional" doesn't have much relevance(the way you're arguing) with Oblivion being a construct and the ease of the black hole, and the scale of the quasar.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Don't get into your feelings about it. I'm not trying to be provocative but it does seem like it's going that way.

Anyway, both black hole feats are fine and all, but what I think you're missing is the intent: Surfer's black hole was a side effect of his blast power whereas Oblivion's creations (I'm aware of his origin) were intentional.

This is kinda like why people went crazy back when Hulk's footsteps were about to make 1/5 of the United states star in the sequel to Titanic, something Black bolt has had to use his voice to replicate in scale was simply a byproduct of Hulk's casual advance forward.


Oh right, GLs have never created black holes by sheer blasting.

A random Darkstar and a random GL create a black hole and actually kill Krona in his entropy form.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Don't get into your feelings about it. I'm not trying to be provocative but it does seem like it's going that way.

Anyway, both black hole feats are fine and all, but what I think you're missing is the intent: Surfer's black hole was a side effect of his blast power whereas Oblivion's creations (I'm aware of his origin) were intentional.

This is kinda like why people went crazy back when Hulk's footsteps were about to make 1/5 of the United states star in the sequel to Titanic, something Black bolt has had to use his voice to replicate in scale was simply a byproduct of Hulk's casual advance forward.

👆

Originally posted by abhilegend
Oh right, GLs have never created black holes by sheer blasting.

A random Darkstar and a random GL create a black hole and actually kill Krona in his entropy form.

yeah, black holes aren't all that impressive.

Originally posted by Delta1938
And how is what I posted lowballing? 😬

I don't think she really heart's you bro. Be careful.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Oh right, GLs have never created black holes by sheer blasting.

A random Darkstar and a random GL create a black hole and actually kill Krona in his entropy form.

Lots of stuff wrong about that claim.
Originally posted by Zack M
yeah, black holes aren't all that impressive.
😂

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Lots of stuff wrong about that claim.

😂

The tears are delightful.

Who's crying?

Post the rest of that scene, but you really don't have to cause for 1 it's a shared feat with one character involved not being a GL and 2 the supposed black hole barely existed, if you know anything about them you'd know their lifespan and scharzschild radius are dependent of their mass and lastly, it's said "the edge of a black hole" so it really depends what the writer is going for there

The funniest part is that Surfer could oneshot Krona if you take that dubious claim at face value

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Who's crying?

You of course.

Post the rest of that scene, but you really don't have to cause for 1 it's a shared feat with one character involved not being a GL and 2 the supposed black hole barely existed, if you know anything about them you'd know their lifespan and scharzschild radius are dependent of their mass and lastly, it's said "the edge of a black hole" so it really depends what the writer is going for there

So much crying.

Delightful.

Basically it works for a marvel character and doesn't for a DC character.

The funniest part is that Surfer could oneshot Krona if you take that dubious claim at face value

Except he opened your beloved Galactus and shit down his mouth.

durimshot

Arguing with you is only difficult because you get emotional when it's usually just a case of you simply having to back up a claim legitimately, at least whenever we cross paths. You're taking it as a personal attack or seemingly try to make it personal when it doesn't have to be at all

Look, at the end of the day the Darkstar guy's energy was required. This is irrefutable. It was also theorized by the other Darkstar what happened and you could clear it up by posting the part where Superman shows up to explain it but you didn't

Both sides are ridiculous the gap between Gls and Surfer is small

Originally posted by abhilegend
😂

The tears are delightful.

You don't think the fact it's such a shitty black hole and that it took both of them to create it..takes anything away from the feat?

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Arguing with you is only difficult because you get emotional when it's usually just a case of you simply having to back up a claim legitimately, at least whenever we cross paths.

😂

The only one emotional in any Surfer thread is a Surfer fanboy.

I'm just mocking you as usual.

You're taking it as a personal attack or seemingly try to make it personal when it doesn't have to be at all

Double 😂

Well, go ahead. I want a heartfelt laugh here.

Look, at the end of the day the Darkstar guy's energy was required. This is irrefutable. It was also theorized by the other Darkstar what happened and you could clear it up by posting the part where Superman shows up to explain it but you didn't

Yes, a mid tier guy who is basically nothing compared to GL.

Superman showed up to basically announce what he did in every damn title in that month, that timeline was being destroyed. It had nothing to do with the creation of black hole.

Anyway, John Stewart has also created a black hole.