Rogue One: A Star Wars Story

Started by quanchi11290 pages
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Honestly my biggest problem with this film was the opening crawl
Spoiler:
or lack of it

One thing bugged me in the middle. Didn't like the need to justify

Spoiler:
the Death Stars weakness. But I got over that when I realised that was more to give Galen a noble purpose
.
Spoiler:
This movie blew you away. It also does make it well known what a glaring weakness this weapon has. All right before my Kelvin Trek will annihilate the Ot empire. Vader didn't looks good at all in the first scene. Ares was right he looked cheap as ****. He looked better in the last scene where he wasn't fast enough to get the plans. Oh Vader you slow failure once again vindicating my stance before your very eyes.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Already listed some on the page you posted on 😛

Without spoiler tags, I can only say it had average 3D, much inferior to Ep7...

I see. Yeah, personally I don't care much for 3D stuff either way.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Spoiler:
This movie blew you away. It also does make it well known what a glaring weakness this weapon has. All right before my Kelvin Trek will annihilate the Ot empire. Vader didn't looks good at all in the first scene. Ares was right he looked cheap as ****. He looked better in the last scene where he wasn't fast enough to get the plans. Oh Vader you slow failure once again vindicating my stance before your very eyes.

Spoiler:
Did you expect the large lumbering cyborg to be particularly fast?
Originally posted by Darth Thor
Honestly my biggest problem with this film was the opening crawl
Spoiler:
or lack of it

Yeah, the lack of the crawl was stupid. It should have given the basics of the Catalyst novel to the audience.

Another thing I was disappointed with was the score. It was terrible, just generic shlock. The only time it was any good was when it referenced the old themes, something it did far too little. This is the Empire at the height of it’s power and we got the Imperial March only two or three times and three times and all in conjunction with Vader. Such a shame. However, I was pleasantly surprised to hear the Imperial motif from ANH appear, though once again only in conjunction with Vader.

I wasn't too keen on the music either. However, I was listening to the soundtrack today and that's pretty decent. It doesn't seem to match the scenes very well.

And another thing. Everyone kinda likes how it ties in exactly with ANH. But I wonder how it goes from here. Do they just fly on normal speed all the way to Tatooine with a Star Destroyer on their butt? Do they go to light speed and then how does Vader track them down? Plus he says in ANH: 'several transmission were beamed to this ship by rebel spies.'

Firstly: they weren't beamed, they were brought.
Secondly: has Leia gone stupid saying they were on a diplomatic mission to Alderaan when her ship just fled the battle of Scarif? I mean, knowing Vader traced the right away why would Leia come up with such a stupid lie.
Vader seems to buy it 'You weren't on any mercy mission this time'. He means to say: you just fled the battle of Scarif where you stole the plans to the Death Star and I've been on your a$$ for the last couple of... hours/days... Why didn't they jump to light speed to Yavin 4??? Why did she go to OB1 first? 'My ship has fallen under attack", she lies... No, she attacked the Imperials...

All prequels are in a habit to make liars of our favourite OT characters. I think Ackbar's cousin should have really beamed it to Leia's ship somewhere far away before his ship was totally ravaged by a furious Vader. Just follow what the previously movies set out. Reinterpretation usually means the characters in the older movies lie.

It's weird sometimes in the PT and in this one: they fill up these movies to references to the OT (TFA and RO especially). Yet, sometimes I wonder if they actually watch these films...

WOW, such a great film.. I enjoyed the musical score. I liked this film a lot. Easily a top 3 Star Wars film , IMO. I ha no problem with no opening crawl. YT'was great seeing Vader speak and be freaking badass

10/10 5 star rating

Originally posted by quanchi112
Spoiler:
Vader didn't looks good at all in the first scene.

How can you possibly look good when you're

Spoiler:
taking a bath in a bacta tank...?

Originally posted by ares834

At this point I think we have a clear new frontrunner for Snoke,

Spoiler:
Vader’s servant.
Though I think that is unlikely as well.

Damn good call.

I was thinking what's the deal with him, but just wasn't thinking of TFA at all.

Whoever Snoke is, we know he's around in this time period, and we know Vader and Palpatine wouldn't just ignore him. Either he'd be hiding from them, or he'd be working for them.

And they did promise an Episode 8 connection in this.

Don't think it's likely - remember, in RotJ

Spoiler:
Palpatine was shown to have many cloaked servants like that one. I felt it was a homage to that scene.

Originally posted by Surtur
Spoiler:
Did you expect the large lumbering cyborg to be particularly fast?
Peoole claim he was. I have been decimating Vader fanboys for years now. I was right on the money once again.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
How can you possibly look good when you're
Spoiler:
taking a bath in a bacta tank...?
Spoiler:
Khan just regenerates but this ****** can't even heal after all that time with the bacta. Vader sucks.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Damn good call.

I was thinking what's the deal with him, but just wasn't thinking of TFA at all.

Whoever Snoke is, we know he's around in this time period, and we know Vader and Palpatine wouldn't just ignore him. Either he'd be hiding from them, or he'd be working for them.

And they did promise an Episode 8 connection in this.

As I claimed Snoke and Kylo are superior to Palpatine and
Spoiler:
bacta boy Vader.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Spoiler:
Khan just regenerates but this ****** can't even heal after all that time with the bacta. Vader sucks.

YouTube video

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
YouTube video
We all know how that duel ended up turning out. Luke kicked that ass.

Like how Quan thinks sitting in a Bacta tank makes you heal alot quicker like Wolve's HF.

Originally posted by Kazenji
Like how Quan thinks sitting in a Bacta tank makes you heal alot quicker like Wolve's HF.
I didn't compare him to wolverine I did compare him to his superior, Khan. Khan does it better because he is better.

Regarding those CG made actor's, Was reading about that there were two more, Gold Leader and Red Leader from A New Hope....i didn't even notice them

Neither did I. So four in total?

Spoiler:
Leia looked the worst.

Yeah it waaay too obvious with it.