Reeve's Superman vs Dr. Manhattan

Started by NemeBro4 pages

Originally posted by Impediment
Manhattan can control and manipulate matter. Superman, even with his demigod-like physiology enhanced by Earth's yellow sun, is matter. Manhattan can literally de-atomize Superman.

Manhattan could also create Kyrptonite out of thin air, just like he made a glass castle out of Martian sand and created cold water and milk for Laurie to drink while flying around Mars.

Superman might be light speed/FTL and could potentially vaporize Manhattan, but Manhattan would just re-create himself and split into multiple bodies like did for his scientific research while banging Laurie in the bedroom.

Manhattan also has precog; He can see his own future. Unless Superman has some tachyons in his back pocket, then Manhattan will already have the advantage.

Manhattan couldn't create Kryptonite because he doesn't know what Kryptonite's chemical composition is. He'd have to have seen it before. Manhattan isn't omniscient, not even close.

So Star Trek shuttles are hundreds if not thousands of times more powerful than Superman?

Manhattan stomps

Originally posted by Kotor3
Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
You make a thread, pretty much EVERYONE tells you that Manhattan wins; and you REFUSE to accept it. Sorry champ; you lose.

Originally posted by Silent Master
So Star Trek shuttles are hundreds if not thousands of times more powerful than Superman?
I don't know about Star Trek (never watched), but to use the example of Star Wars, despite their massively FTL capabilities, they achieve this in a way that is inapplicable to combat.

Now, if you were to tell me that these ships could, say, withstand ramming another ship at massively FTL speed, then yeah, they realistically would be.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
You make a thread, pretty much EVERYONE tells you that Manhattan wins; and you REFUSE to accept it. Sorry champ; you lose.
He may have lost, but you did not win.

It doesn't matter. Manhattan wins..

Originally posted by Tattoos N Scars
He always is according to you. Should Hebe stripped of yes Herald status? Even in the comics?
What status ? Can you prove this is official ?

Originally posted by quanchi112
What status ? Can you prove this is official ?

Superman is herald level on these boards, except to you. You downplay his powers here and in the comic vs forum. Your view of Superman is somewhere between street level and low meta. Since you believe that, you are not qualified to post in any Superman thread.

Originally posted by Tattoos N Scars
Superman is herald level on these boards, except to you. You downplay his powers here and in the comic vs forum. Your view of Superman is somewhere between street level and low meta. Since you believe that, you are not qualified to post in any Superman thread.
I do not downplay his power level. He is a peer to Thor, Hulk, etc. so at least be accurate.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
You make a thread, pretty much EVERYONE tells you that Manhattan wins; and you REFUSE to accept it. Sorry champ; you lose.
Nice jump on the bandwagon because you can't come up with a decent argument to support your claim.

Your concession is accepted.

So how does SM beat him without going back in time. giving that Manhattan can see his past and future and will stop this.

Originally posted by Kotor3
Nice jump on the bandwagon because you can't come up with a decent argument to support your claim.

Your concession is accepted.

Manhole covers hurt the guy and he was unable to beat three Knians without depowering them. Make sense, k.

I think Kortor is a troll

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
I think Kortor is a troll
A dumb one too.

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
So how does SM beat him without going back in time. giving that Manhattan can see his past and future and will stop this.
When you are able to make one decent argument then I will explain how Superman's wins. Until then I'll leave you with quanchi112 so the both of you can continue to discuss who is a troll and who isn't.

Originally posted by Kotor3
When you are able to make one decent argument then I will explain how Superman's wins. Until then I'll leave you with quanchi112 so the both of you can continue to discuss who is a troll and who isn't.
Lets see this through. How does Superman win when he was unable to best Knians through sheer power. What makes Manhattan easier to best despite the fact he can make copies and has more formidable powers than Knians.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Lets see this through. How does Superman win when he was unable to best Knians through sheer power. What makes Manhattan easier to best despite the fact he can make copies and has more formidable powers than Knians.
You are such an idiot dying for attention. For entertainment purposes, please name one power that Dr. Manhattan has that is more formidable?

Originally posted by Kotor3
You are such an idiot dying for attention. For entertainment purposes, please name one power that Dr. Manhattan has that is more formidable?
Control over matter on a subatomic level. Now your turn.

Would Manhattan be able to blow up superman like he did Rorschach? I mean I know Rorschach is just a normal human being so there's a huge difference since superman is bullet proof and all