Captain America: The best Super Hero trilogy?

Started by Quincy24 pages
Quincy Debaser

Thought the first Cap movie was lame and boring. The second and third were great though!

Zack M Senior Member
Originally posted by Quincy
Thought the first Cap movie was lame and boring. The second and third were great though!

The first one is definitely the weakest of the trilogy for me and the weak link.

Quincy Debaser
Originally posted by Zack M
The first one is definitely the weakest of the trilogy for me and the weak link.

When my friends all discuss the Marvel movies they get REALLY defensive about Cap 1. Anytime I'm like "That movie isn't so good" they POUNCE with "THOR 1 IS WORSE though!"

I disagree with that too...

Zack Fair Fanboy

Your friends are funny. Thor 1 is better than FA.

Quincy Debaser
Originally posted by Zack Fair
Your friends are funny. Thor 1 is better than FA.

Thank you! I'm going go to tell them you agree

CosmicComet Senior Member

Cap 1 is better than thor 1 easily. Thor doesnt have a good movie so far.

CPT Space Bomb Emperor Doom

Originally posted by Quincy
Thought the first Cap movie was lame and boring. The second and third were great though!
I loved the First Cap movie. It's definitely a good Origin for Steve and fairly true to the comics. PLUS, they introduced Bucky which has obviously been a home run for them. Sebastion Stan is the man.
Originally posted by CosmicComet
Cap 1 is better than thor 1 easily. Thor doesnt have a good movie so far.
Disagree. Thor 1 was a very good movie. Loki, Thor and Odin's dynamic was incredible. And the action was great. The only bad thing was too much time spent on Earth and too much time with humans. All the THOR stuff was great though.

Zack M Senior Member

Originally posted by Quincy
When my friends all discuss the Marvel movies they get REALLY defensive about Cap 1. Anytime I'm like "That movie isn't so good" they POUNCE with "THOR 1 IS WORSE though!"

I disagree with that too...

Thor 1 is better, but not by much. Never really cared for those, TBH.

Zack M Senior Member

BTW, here are the Comic book movies I give an A (Top of the heap).

Watchmen
Batman Begins
Avengers
GOTG
Incredible Hulk
TDK
Iron Man
Batman (89)
Blade
Spider-Man 2
Sin City
Ghost World
X-Men: First Class

Pretty much it.

StiltmanFTW CBvF
Originally posted by Zack Fair
Your friends are funny. Thor 1 is better than FA.

It is. Even a Thor hater like me can admit it.

Golgo is right about the "not by much" part, though.

StiltmanFTW CBvF
Originally posted by Zack M
Incredible Hulk

Really?

Darth Thor Senior Member

Thor 1 is still in my top 5 Marvel movies. I even have it ahead of GOTG.

Zack M Senior Member
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Really?

I loved both the Hulk movies. I know the Ang Lee one is a bad film, subjectively, but they're my guilty pleasures. Edward Norton one is an underrated movie, IMO.

StiltmanFTW CBvF
Originally posted by Zack M
I loved both the Hulk movies. I know the Ang Lee one is a bad film, subjectively, but they're my guilty pleasures. Edward Norton one is an underrated movie, IMO.

The game released at the time of Ang Lee's movie was cool...

As for the film... Hulk-dogs were terribly done, same with Absorbing Man/David Banner, but I liked the Hulk wrecking tanks and shit. Good stuff. Plus, that healing factor.

Actually enjoyed it a bit more than TIH, tbh.

Ruffalo Hulk/Banner remains the greatest, imo.

relentless1 Dark Overlord of KMC

the way I see it:

Begins is far far superior to TFA - 1 for TDK Trilogy

WS is great, but TDK is that much better - 2 for TDK Trilogy

Civil War is a lot better than TDKR - 1 for Cap Trilogy

2 to 1 for Bats trilogy IMO

Zack M Senior Member

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
The game released at the time of Ang Lee's movie was cool...

As for the film... Hulk-dogs were terribly done, same with Absorbing Man/David Banner, but I liked the Hulk wrecking tanks and shit. Good stuff. Plus, that healing factor.

Actually enjoyed it a bit more than TIH, tbh.

Ruffalo Hulk/Banner remains the greatest, imo.

👆

What did you think of Blade?

Zack M Senior Member

Originally posted by relentless1
the way I see it:

Begins is far far superior to TFA - 1 for TDK Trilogy

WS is great, but TDK is that much better - 2 for TDK Trilogy

Civil War is a lot better than TDKR - 1 for Cap Trilogy

2 to 1 for Bats trilogy IMO

Pretty much how I see it, but I still really liked TDKR. I gave it a B+. Bale was very good and Tom Hardy as Bane was awesome.

StiltmanFTW CBvF

Originally posted by Zack M
👆

What did you think of Blade?

Been too long... would need to re-watch, honestly...

But I liked both 1 & 2... haven't seen 3 (which was crap? so I've heard, at least)

Darth Thor Senior Member

Originally posted by relentless1
the way I see it:

Begins is far far superior to TFA - 1 for TDK Trilogy

WS is great, but TDK is that much better - 2 for TDK Trilogy

Civil War is a lot better than TDKR - 1 for Cap Trilogy

2 to 1 for Bats trilogy IMO

You should compare best with best and worst with worst for a fairer assessment IMO.

So Civil War or TDK, WS or BB and TFA or TDKR.

StiltmanFTW CBvF
Originally posted by relentless1
Begins is far far superior to TFA - 1 for TDK Trilogy

I don't agree. Superior, maybe. Far? Nope.

Originally posted by relentless1
WS is great, but TDK is that much better - 2 for TDK Trilogy

Depends on your mood, I feel... they are different movies...

Fighting scenes suck in Nolan's entire trilogy, for example... while in Russo's movies, they are without equal.

I'd say it's a tie, here...

Originally posted by relentless1
Civil War is a lot better than TDKR - 1 for Cap Trilogy

Yup, it is.