Qui-Gon Jinn vs Asajj Ventress

Started by chingchangwalla4 pages

Qui-Gon Jinn vs Asajj Ventress

Round 1: Sabers only
Round 2: Force only
Round 3: All out

- Both at their peak

Not too familiar with amps the Legends variant has given him. As far as Disney canon is concerned, Ventress slaughter house. I have prime Ventress above TPM Maul who was most certainly above Quigon Jinn.

Originally posted by Dark-Kenshin
Not too familiar with amps the Legends variant has given him. As far as Disney canon is concerned, Ventress slaughter house. I have prime Ventress above TPM Maul who was most certainly above Quigon Jinn.
No you don't.

Maul was almost Dooku-level, the hell?

And that was before he came back in TCW.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
No you don't.

Maul was almost Dooku-level, the hell?

And that was before he came back in TCW.

Again, Disney Canon. Nothing in Disney canon to suggest Quigon was almost Dooku level, much less a peer with Mace.

Oh wait, you're suggesting TPM Maul is almost Dooku-level? Eh . . . I don't see that. I know people like to brush TPM Kenobi's feat against Maul aside, but it certainly spoke volumes of Maul's flaws as a duelist. He's a great duelist, don't get me wrong, but there are certain things that keep him from being Dooku's peer and that is one of them. Ask yourself how Dooku would've performed in that exact same situation and the answer will be clear.

Ventress was a very competent duelist but this is both at their peak. Jinn was said to be one of the order's best with a lightsaber.

Ventress, but Qui-Gon gives her one hell of a fight.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Ventress, but Qui-Gon gives her one hell of a fight.

Originally posted by Dark-Kenshin
Oh wait, you're suggesting TPM Maul is almost Dooku-level? Eh . . . I don't see that. I know people like to brush TPM Kenobi's feat against Maul aside, but it certainly spoke volumes of Maul's flaws as a duelist. He's a great duelist, don't get me wrong, but there are certain things that keep him from being Dooku's peer and that is one of them. Ask yourself how Dooku would've performed in that exact same situation and the answer will be clear.
You should, its canon, it was in Fightsaber.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
You should, its canon, it was in Fightsaber.
What did Fightsaber say specifically?

There was an entire by page baased around the battle, a few pages, actually, and the consensus was that Dooku took it, but JUST barely, and this was before TCW.

Ventress in all.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
There was an entire by page baased around the battle, a few pages, actually, and the consensus was that Dooku took it, but JUST barely, and this was before TCW.

Yeah, TCW Maul is only barely above Kenobi. In saber combat, Dooku is solidly above any incarnation of Maul, except perhaps Rebels.

Ventress, decent fight, though.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
You should, its canon, it was in Fightsaber.
Wasn'it said that Fisto would beat TPM maul in one of those fightsaber too? Aniway Ventress in a good fight

Bump. They're about even in terms of straight up skill; Qui-Gon's physically stronger and could strain Asajj that way but Ventress is faster and more nimble. The big thing is that Ventress' stamina is better than Qui-Gon's. I suspect most people would favour Ventress, including myself at first, but I'm wondering if Qui-Gon's encyclopedic knowledge of Makashi would give him the edge he needs to win a majority here.

Ventress vs tpm maul is a better fight tbh

Maul's better. And Maul doesn't have an encyclopedic knowledge of Makashi as Qui-Gon does.

As of tpm?

Yeah.