Anakin Skywalker vs. Mace Windu

Anakin in a good fight

Mace sweeps

It's a good fight, but Skywalker prevails.

Force goes to Anakin, sabers and all out go to Mace by micromajority.

If we're assuming that Anakin is in a sound state of mind, like he was on the Invisible Hand, then I'm not seeing Mace winning sabers, either. At worst, Anakin has been depicted as the equal of Count Dooku (Mace's equal), and that was in a source that portrayed the Count very favorably. At best, Anakin has been depicted as dramatically overwhelming Tyranus.

Either way

Anakin is not going to be in the same state of mind when he fights Mace, he's going too be on the conflicted side - and looses.

Palpatine-fight Mace > Zonakin > regular serious Mace > regular serious Anakin > regular Anakin > regular Mace > Mustafar Anakin

fugged up but it's true

all hail star wars

No limbed Mace > Anakin. Windu channels all of his anger and absolutely pummels the fake chosen one.