Where to rank Kit Fisto and/or Shaak Ti?

I have always been undecided on Fisto and the Shaak hype is gross, time to put her in her place.

Fisto approaches the higher tiers in dueling skill and is moderately powerful. One of the best highs council members.

Shaak is a decently powerful force user who like Fisto approaches the higher tiers in dueling skill ( at least as of TFU ) I'd place her above him due to her force edge though I'd favor Fisto slightly if it was lightsabers only.

Shaak does use Makashi, IIRC. That could give her the edge over Kit in a lightsaber duels, but I agree that Kit is faster and more skilled.

May I ask how Shaak gets the force edge? Fisto isn't just some sabers guy, he's a consular first and foremost :/

Because she has superior force feats?

She's got superior duelling feats too, tbh. Better hype and a far more relevant form, she beats him in ever category.

Huh? This isn't about him having a green saber, is it?

No?

Then what source declares that Kit Fisto is a Consular?

In his starwars wikia entry.

Shaak and Kit are pretty high up on the Council, besides Obi, Annie, Mace and Yoda they're probably the best.

But in regards to who'd win a fight between the two, Shaak definitely. Fisto's only edge is speed.

Makashi vs Shii-Cho. Any competent Makashi user should win tbh, although I like Fisto's chances with two sabers. Don't ask me why :/

She'd also beat him with Ataru 🙂

Originally posted by Selenial
She'd also beat him with Ataru 🙂

Oh no... Jensaarai fan

She'd probably accidentally gut herself

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Oh no... Jensaarai fan

Name a single duelling feat Kit has that places him above her.

Note that his form isn't just weak to Makashi, it's weak against every other form. He compensated for the weaknesses of his form with staggering speed, he's genuinely an insanely quick and insanely talented Duellist, but anyone approaching him with speed or skill will win a contest due to the form disadvantage he has.

He's a talented Lightsaber wielder, that doesn't make him a phenomenal duellist.

Joker just mad I've been shitting on Ahsoka recently 🙂

I'm guessing your lack of ability to actually engage me in a debate leads to quips to make yourself feel better 🙂

Originally posted by MythLord
Shaak and Kit are pretty high up on the Council, besides Obi, Annie, Mace and Yoda they're probably the best.

Yea, they're in the elite of the council IMO, go-to troubleshooters.

Originally posted by Selenial
Name a single duelling feat Kit has that places him above her.

Note that his form isn't just weak to Makashi, it's weak against every other form. He compensated for the weaknesses of his form with staggering speed, he's genuinely an insanely quick and insanely talented Duellist, but anyone approaching him with speed or skill will win a contest due to the form disadvantage he has.

He's a talented Lightsaber wielder, that doesn't make him a phenomenal duellist.

Yes, all valid points but speed isn't exactly his only asset :/

Originally posted by Selenial
Joker just mad I've been shitting on Ahsoka recently 🙂

I'm guessing your lack of ability to actually engage me in a debate leads to quips to make yourself feel better 🙂

Shaak in her prime wins this decently, and then goes on to stomp Ashoka.