Anakin vs Vader (sabers only)

Started by chingchangwalla13 pages
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Dunno what that has to do with a duel...

Lmao wrong thread.

Sums up this thread.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Vader's own statements are all made in a mindset that anything Jedi is weak, a much more truthful view point is when he realises he's lost his former power.

So when he thinks he's weaker that counts but when he thinks he's stronger it doesn't count 😬

When he thinks he is weaker, he's truthfully analysing his own power. He reaches out to crush Sidious with all of his rage and might, but he can't even touch him. He realises then that the powers he had were like a memory, he could remember where his power was but could never use it, his connection to that power was gone. His 'furnace heart' which was the source of his power, no longer reacted to his summons, instead he was burning in that furnace.

Vader gets far more powerful than the shade of his former self that realises this, but the raw power he used to weild was just gone, he retained great power, but nothing like what he had before.

Ant has provided the quotes from the novel that make it very apparent that he was once capable of overwhelming the will of the Force itself and accomplishing things impossible for anybody else, that was burned out.

Vader in suit in the films and in rebels doesn't look overtly impressive. He looked downright awful when Luke overwhelmed him in Rotj. Luke was a mess in ESB and even he landed a blow on Vader.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Lucas always did seem to suggest Anakin > Vader. But that's all changed under Disney.

They wasted no time to have him say he's grown more powerful in the Force just a few years after ROTS, and for Pablo to confirm Rebels Vader is Prime Vader, and for OT Vader to have the most beastly telekinetic feats, and to Solo entire Rebel fleets (something Skywalker never displayed), and for Rebels Maul to confirm he can't take Vader e.t.c e.t.c

Tbh.

I also find it hard to believe that in the final seasons of TCW Anakin would have been shown to be the powerhouse he is in the RotS novel. By the end of Season 5 he appears barely above Dooku.

Originally posted by AncientPower
When he thinks he is weaker, he's truthfully analysing his own power. He reaches out to crush Sidious with all of his rage and might, but he can't even touch him. He realises then that the powers he had were like a memory, he could remember where his power was but could never use it, his connection to that power was gone. His 'furnace heart' which was the source of his power, no longer reacted to his summons, instead he was burning in that furnace.

Vader gets far more powerful than the shade of his former self that realises this, but the raw power he used to weild was just gone, he retained great power, but nothing like what he had before.

Ant has provided the quotes from the novel that make it very apparent that he was once capable of overwhelming the will of the Force itself and accomplishing things impossible for anybody else, that was burned out.

The quotes from the novel are not only Pre-Disney's soft revamp but it was right after Anakin just got all burned up.

That's like saying Maul felt weak after he just got split in 2.. Just like it took Maul years to build up his rage and become more powerful than he was previously, same thing happened with Vader.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Tbh.

I also find it hard to believe that in the final seasons of TCW Anakin would have been shown to be the powerhouse he is in the RotS novel. By the end of Season 5 he appears barely above Dooku.

He wasn't above Dooku during TCW tbh. But it was always a good match up.

Seriously? He's obviously referring to his lost potential. Vader goes on to become more powerful after he adjusts to the suit and calls upon his pain to grow more powerful in the dark side. Saying that Vader views his old self is weak because he was a Jedi is quite a reach. To me those quotes make it pretty obvious that Vader>Anakin

Originally posted by AncientPower
"Lord Vader, your skills are unmatched by any Sith before you. Go forth, my boy. Go forth, and bring peace to our Empire." - Darth Sidious, Revenge Of The Sith

Knightfall Vader > All Sith before him in skill.

"You are a true Sith, Lord Vader. Your dedication is unerring and your powers unparalleled." - Darth Sidious, Tarkin

👆 🙂

It's almost as if I'm debating Legends.

"His powers were great now, greater than they had ever been before" seems like a pretty straightforward statement

And this would include Pre suit Vader, so your argument that he views his Jedi self as weak is irrelevant.

Is it me or is there an apparent lack of comprehending the difference between raw power/potential and achieved mastery/power over the Force?

Yeah, Anakin has the potential, BUT HE NEVER REACHED IT. He gave us a glimpse of what it could be in his duel against Dooku, but that was only once. As an overall combatant, Vader is better.

Originally posted by Rebel95
Yeah, Anakin has the potential, BUT HE NEVER REACHED IT. He gave us a glimpse of what it could be in his duel against Dooku, but that was only once. As an overall combatant, Vader is better.
It seems most disagree when comparing Anakin vs. Luke from Rotj. Luke crushed Vader in the suit.

Originally posted by AncientPower
It's almost as if I'm debating Legends.
Apocrypha then. 🙂

Anyway Ant doesn't appear to be:

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Anakin is better in both Canon and Legends by miles.
Schism within the ranks already, and with so few of you. Shame.

LOL

Originally posted by Beniboybling
"You are a true Sith, Lord Vader. Your dedication is unerring and your powers unparalleled." - Darth Sidious, Tarkin

👆 🙂

Damn I completely missed that line in Tarkin 👆

😂

I understand what AP and ant are saying, Anakin has the ability to call upon a power that's beyond Vader, or anyone for that matter. But he never reached the point where he was able to do so at will. Vader is the better and more consistent combatant over all