Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Vader's still the more experienced, and proficient duelist - while sporting superior telekinetic power to boot. Before becoming a "far more formidable" combatant, and further increasing that power on RotJ, Vader was able to break through Starkillers defenses and choke him momentarily. The Outlander TK feats aren't on the same planet as Mr Frigate buster.It will be a pretty good fight and all, but Vader wins. 👆
The Outlander is a veteran of the Great Galactic War that lasted 28 years. He is also a veteran of the subsequent Cold War and numerous other events that collectively lasted several more years.
I am not sure what makes Darth Vader more experienced and proficient duelist than the Outlander. The latter would have encountered many Sith in the battlefield and is revered for his exploits.
Darth Vader's (presumed) superiority in Telekinesis is largely irrelevant in this contest because the gap is not large. Darth Vader had his moments with Starkiller but he failed to defeat the latter when it mattered. Similarly, Darth Vader failed to defeat Luke Skywalker when it mattered.
The Outlander's combative strategy is different from that of Starkiller. If he is Light Side, then he is not fond of disintegrating stuff around him (The Outlander is officially promoted as Jedi Knight class by BioWare).
Darth Vader doesn't have any advantage here.