Captain America vs. Rorschach/Nite Owl

Started by h1a820 pages
Originally posted by Nibedicus
Accept my BZ then, you sound confident enough.

That's the reason why I won't do it, because Cap's top feats will be pitted against Rorshach lowest feats. I would only consider it if we use the Rorshach kick feat as his true durability and nothing lower.

Originally posted by h1a8
That's the reason why I won't do it, because Cap's top feats will be pitted against Rorshach lowest feats. I would only consider it if we use the Rorshach kick feat as his true durability and nothing lower.
So you admit you're biased. Wow, you sunk your own credibility.

Originally posted by h1a8
That's the reason why I won't do it, because Cap's top feats will be pitted against Rorshach lowest feats. I would only consider it if we use the Rorshach kick feat as his true durability and nothing lower.

I see, you're too scared to do a battle zone unless you can rig it in your favor.

Basically...

Originally posted by h1a8
That's the reason why I won't do it, because Cap's top feats will be pitted against Rorshach lowest feats. I would only consider it if we use the Rorshach kick feat as his true durability and nothing lower.

Basically you want to use a one off feat for Rorsch whereas we have numerous strength feats from Cap showing consistent striking strength.

How is this still going? Cap was chucking heavily armored Hydra goons like basketballs and lifted a motor with multiple women on it over his head with ease.

H1 is incapable of accepting reality

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
How is this still going? Cap was chucking heavily armored Hydra goons like basketballs and lifted a motor with multiple women on it over his head with ease.

It is baffling isn't it?

Originally posted by h1a8
I didn't even give an extreme argument at all. My argument is that the throat durability should naturally scale with (skin, muscle, tissues, nerves, veins, and joint durability).

For example, if all those parts I named are 1000x as durable as a normal human's then the throat should be CLOSE to 1000x as durable as a normal human's too. There is nothing extreme about my argument.

Nib's argument is actually extreme. He is saying that if those parts are 1000x more durable then we can only give the throat a few times more durable than a human's (since it scales only somewhat). But that's dumb.

Otherwise, a strong human can kill Thor or Hulk with a throat punch since the scaling would be only a little. If a character's tissues and muscles and skin and nerves and veins where shown to be 1000x more durable than a human's then is it reasonable to assume that their throat is about 1000x more durable too?
Anywhere close to 1000x times is reasonable (900x is reasonable but 5 times is not reasonable).

You are the only one I have seen who has gotten that from reading Nibedicus' posts. That's not how his argument comes across to me and, judging by posts from others, not to them either.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Basically you want to use a one off feat for Rorsch whereas we have numerous strength feats from Cap showing consistent striking strength.
H1 might be the worst comic book posted in the history of the sub forum. He's that bad.

this thread needs to go another 200 pages..

hahahahaha

Originally posted by WhiteWitchKing
Cap held a helicopter in place so f#ck Ozy's shitty feats. Cap would kill that Dr Doom wannabe.
And then got choked by a superhuman arm for 12 seconds, the same arm that took 2 seconds to almost put Black widow to sleep, then fell into water from a height of maybe 200 meters, then swam underwater with a 200lbs man (metal arm) like 350-400 meters to safety

His anaerobic feats are huge

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
How is this still going? Cap was chucking heavily armored Hydra goons like basketballs and lifted a motor with multiple women on it over his head with ease.

Caps wins from the first page. Everyone agrees on that. We are arguing something totally different.

Yea, the last 14 pages have been because h1 is butt-hurt over the fact that Cap >> Ozy.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Yea, the last 14 pages have been because h1 is butt-hurt over the fact that Cap >> Ozy.

Caps is a little stronger and more durable than Ozy.
Ozy is faster, has faster perceptions, and is more skilled.

But that has nothing to do with the the argument at present.

Cap is stronger, more durable and skilled, he is also a faster fighter.

Originally posted by h1a8
Caps is a little stronger and more durable than Ozy.
Ozy is faster, has faster perceptions, and is more skilled.

But that has nothing to do with the the argument at present.

Cap would beat Ozy quite soundly.

It wouldn't be quite anything really

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
It wouldn't be quite anything really
You are an idiot.

Originally posted by FrothByte
Cap would beat Ozy quite soundly.

I disagree. Ozy can see bullets in slow motion. Cap's attacks would appear almost as a standstill. Cap wouldn't land a blow. There is no way in hell Cap can beat someone who can catch a bullet. That's too phucking fast.