Lord Scourge vs Darth Baras

1. Sabers

2. Force

3. All-Out

Baras in all, but maybe Sabers.

Scourge has a decent chance against Satele Shan, let-alone Baras, who canonically is just... not on her level.

I hate Scourge shit tons but he might win this.

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
I hate Scourge shit tons but he might win this.

Dull character.

Meh.

Anyway, when you think about it, unless you're over-leveled, you usually have a companion with you during the Scourge fight.

But thats just gameplay mechanics.

Scourge

Considering what I've just learned, Baras gets stomped.

Considering that he lost to act II HoT, Baras solidly, assuming it's with all the amps he had before Wrath II messed it all up for him.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Considering what I've just learned, Baras gets stomped.

Share with the class plz.

Originally posted by Tondemonai
Considering that he lost to act II HoT, Baras solidly, assuming it's with all the amps he had before Wrath II messed it all up for him.

Act II HoT = Lord Scourge > Act I HoT > Satele Shan >> Darth Baras.

Baras had trouble with an inexperienced Shan.

You're forgetting HoT has his companion when he faces Scourge.

Satele (apparently) admits that Act I HoT is superior to her.

Satele by that point is DEFINITELY above Baras, its not something you can even question.

Errr...doesn't Baras engage Satele during the Sack of Coruscant? In a basically inconclusive and brief bout?

Satele should be in her 40 or late 30 during that time too, unless I forgot about something.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Errr...doesn't Baras engage Satele during the Sack of Coruscant? In a basically inconclusive and brief bout?

Satele should be in her 40 or late 30 during that time too, unless I forgot about something.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Then that still makes him weaker then Act I HoT.

I don't share your conclusion. That would make HoT to be far superior to the Wrath. Plus, their clash was so brief that I find it difficult to consider it an irrefutable case in Satele's favour.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
I don't share your conclusion. That would make HoT to be far superior to the Wrath. Plus, their clash was so brief that I find it difficult to consider it an irrefutable case in Satele's favour.

Act I HoT is very inferior to Scourge.

Satele was fighting on par with Malgus, and is implied in the story to be his equal at points, IIRC.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Satele states that the HoT as of Act I is the most powerful Jedi alive, including herself.

Act I HoT is very inferior to Scourge.

Satele was fighting on par with Malgus, and is implied in the story to be his equal at points, IIRC.

Satele was far from fighting on par with Malgus, lol. She even admited she was going to die twice in her entry in the Journal of Gnost Dural.

During the False Emperor Flashpoint Satele explicitly admits the HoT or the party is the only hope to defeat Malgus, clearly excluding herself from the capable lot.

Malgus has much better combat feats and accolades than Satele.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
Satele was far from fighting on par with Malgus, lol. She even admited she was going to die twice in her entry in the Journal of Gnost Dural.

During the False Emperor Flashpoint Satele explicitly admits the HoT or the party is the only hope to defeat Malgus, clearly excluding herself from the capable lot.

Malgus has much better combat feats and accolades than Satele.

Thats because Satele tried to take him out in sabers instead of using her obviously superior TK.

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Thats because Satele tried to take him out in sabers instead of using her obviously superior TK.

So superior that in the only stance both were with their defenses up Malgus was actually the one who force pushed Satele into a tree, broke her lightsaber stance and forced her to commit a tactical mistake that cost her lightsaber and would've cost her life, as she admited it herself.

Yeah, totally superior.

Originally posted by TenebrousWay
So superior that in the only stance both were with their defenses up Malgus was actually the one who force pushed Satele into a tree, broke her lightsaber stance and forced her to commit a tactical mistake that cost her lightsaber and would've cost her life, as she admited it herself.

Yeah, totally superior.