Anakin Skywalker vs Darth Vader

Started by SunRazer15 pages

Anakin Skywalker vs Darth Vader

Time for another one of these.

RotS Anakin, in a perfect state of clarity (ie. in the opening stages of his battle against Dooku)

vs

RotJ Vader, in a perfect state of clarity.

1. Sabers

2. Force

3. All-out

Who wins?

Anakin
Either way
Anakin

this has never been done before

Originally posted by carthage
this has never been done before
Originally posted by SunRazer
Time for another one of these.

Vader could use the environment to his advantage and defeat Anakin through trickery and smarts, but Anakin is more skilled. Vader takes force, Anakin takes sabers and all out for a slim majority.

Anakin
Anakin
Anakin

Most of the time.

Anakin sweeps.

Someone who's best feat is beating the Dark Woman shouldn't really be compared to the Dooku Stomper.

Vader's best feat is having the upper hand on the Starkiller clone, not beating the Dark Woman, lol.

Starkiller is sub Kenobi Azronger :/
Ain't no thing defeating him

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Starkiller is sub Kenobi Azronger :/
Ain't no thing defeating him

Lol. In the force?

In sabers maybe. The Force is another matter entirely.

As a whole. If you go by the notion that Kenobi and Maul are equals as Lightsaber Duelists, then Starkiller is well below Kenobi. He's a 50/50 split with both Maul, Obi-Wan, Malgus etc. guys like that because if they close in quick enough he gets completely outclassed in sabers and dies in a minute or two. Obviously if he just starts 'spamming' force attacks which the entire dckhead population of SW debaters thinks he does, he wins.

So you concede Starkiller > Kenobi in the Force, good.

Obviously. But he isn't God tier at all, Dooku would school Starkiller so hard.

Originally posted by Azronger
Vader's best feat is having the upper hand on the Starkiller clone, not beating the Dark Woman, lol.

Whatever high and mighty Force powers Starkiller/Marek have displayed are almost irrelevant to how he fights. He's an abhorrent duelist and has demonstrated poor defences against other force users.

Still better than the Dark Woman.

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Obviously. But he isn't God tier at all, Dooku would school Starkiller so hard.

Overall combat, yes. Raw power, no.

Damn, how times have changed. 🙂

Anakin
Vader
Anakin, usually

Vader in all.