ANH Vader vs TPM Maul

Started by SunRazer11 pages
Originally posted by Beniboybling
I'm sure they were, but it would be impractical to have them all in one hangar. Especially considering that the hangar proper is described as a landing area, not a housing space.

I didn't say they were all in one hangar. Perhaps there were only a couple, with the rest being the 75m ones as you said.

I also edited my post with a bit more info, if you'd care to look at it.

Well yeah my point is that the hangar they were in likely housed ships of similar dimensions.

And yeah in regards to them being "hulking", as I say a vessel twice the size of the Millenium Falcon certainly qualifies. The KOTOR CG would also suggest they didn't have any larger vessels left anyway.

If there were any surviving 215m ships, they'd still have to be housed somewhere.

The KotORCG claims that Revan rebuilt dozens of them with the Star Forge. It's entirely possible that some remained.

Either way, the ease with which Dooku threw the ships, and them smashed them together, would make the feat his best and very impressive, even if it were the 75m cruisers.

I think it's easier and more encompassing to just say "he threw 75m+ cruisers".

I thought Revan built more modern cruisers, these ones appear to be a lot more ancient, and I doubt any of them were housed at Korriban.

And yeah, I agree, the alternative only leaves us with ambiguity, we can at least be certain that some of the ships he threw were of those dimensions.

KotORCG outright states that he rebuilt dozens of Derriphan-class battleships, as well as others.

Ah I see, still no guarantee they were brought to Korriban.

Originally posted by SunRazer
KotORCG outright states that he rebuilt dozens of Derriphan-class battleships, as well as others.

Y he build a bunch of junk ships fer?

He's stupood.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
College chem is ridiculously easy. I got a 99 on the first test and I've been halfassing the class.

At my school it's a weeder.

Vader

Originally posted by relentless1
Vader
Based on ?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
College chem is ridiculously easy. I got a 99 on the first test and I've been halfassing the class.

Great 🙂 . I'm was debating with my ego whether or not I should go to a competitive school, but I decided I would rather be a big fish in a small pond.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Y he build a bunch of junk ships fer?

Because he had the plans? The Star Forge can replicate things pretty quickly, and it's much faster than coming up with new plans (which they still did).

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Ah I see, still no guarantee they were brought to Korriban.

We know the Sith Empire established a base on Korriban and cultivated their apprentices there, which would suggest that they needed a measure of protection. It'd be pretty unwise if they had nothing there. After all, wasn't Korriban their primary base, since the Star Forge was more of a "secret location"?

Sure but that would take the form of a space presence, in fact storing/repairing capital ships on planets was rare, they normally use orbital dockyards instead.

Most capital ships were far larger than the Derriphan-class battleships, though. You're forgetting that Darth Revan's Empire created even larger vessels to serve as their capital ships. The Derriphan-class battleships were the capital ships during the Great Hyperspace War, not the Jedi Civil War. By then, they had better, larger, and more powerful ships - they just kept the Derriphan-class battleships around since they had the plans for them and could easily mass produce them with the Star Forge.

And Korriban had no orbital dockyards during the Old Sith Wars that I recall.

Originally posted by Kurk
Great 🙂 . I'm was debating with my ego whether or not I should go to a competitive school, but I decided I would rather be a big fish in a small pond.

It depends on what you want to do and how much money you have to spare. You don't wanna overdo it though and go to like Devry or something.

Some careers like Investment Banking would really prefer if you went to a top tier school, while others dont really care.

Originally posted by Kurk
Great 🙂 . I'm was debating with my ego whether or not I should go to a competitive school, but I decided I would rather be a big fish in a small pond.

Well I'm hardly in a small pond tbh

Fair enough, I do not know enough about ships to make a good counter, so I'll just concede. It's still an enormous feat, ragdolling a 75m ship and levitating multiple ones. Dooku is still on Vader's level.

That's not Vader level.

bit above Vader tbh.