ANH Vader vs TPM Maul

Started by Beniboybling11 pages

Originally posted by Azronger
Fair enough, I do not know enough about ships to make a good counter, so I'll just concede. It's still an enormous feat, ragdolling a 75m ship and levitating multiple ones. Dooku is still on Vader's level.
He didn't ragdoll or levitate anything, he flipped over one vessel and dragged a couple of others across the hangar, on a dark side nexus. It's an impressive feat but I wouldn't say it even puts him above Starkiller who can toss walkers, ragdoll TIE's in mid flight, hurl massive towers as missles and manipulate an ISD. Vader himself being capable of pulling freighters out of the sky some dozen years before his prime and casually launching upward massive metal platforms.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
He didn't ragdoll or levitate anything, he flipped over one vessel and dragged a couple of others across the hangar, on a dark side nexus. It's an impressive feat but I wouldn't say it even puts him above Starkiller who can toss walkers, ragdoll TIE's in mid flight, hurl massive towers as missles and manipulate an ISD. Vader himself being capable of pulling freighters out of the sky some dozen years before his prime and casually launching upward massive metal platforms.

Looking at the text, it seems like he was levitating them:

They were nearing the end of the hangar. He sensed it rather than saw it. The corroded vehicles were more numerous now, lined up like dark, giant phantoms.

Like phantoms..

Phantoms that move...

And despite it being on a a nexus, I doubt RotS Dooku wouldn't be able to do this, since Korriban has lost its potency in modern times, and Dooku was four years pre-prime.

None of that stuff really impresses me more than this. Unless someone does accuarate calcs, I'll consider Dooku and Vader equals as telekinetics.

Ragdolling 75 ships vs Ragdolling a guy who pulverizes 150 ships mmm

Yeah, we gona need calcs for that.

75+ 🙂

Starkiller blew everything on that, whereas Dooku did his feats with ease, and he threw several in rapid succession, IIRC.

Tyranus did also throw them (or their wreckage?) together to create wreckage to block the hangar entrance.

With ease?

He paused by the wreckage of the vehicles that the mysterious Sith had moved so easily.

-- Jedi Quest: The Final Showdown

Dooku is a legit beast, the diminished Nexus on Korriban is obviously nothing like Vjun, and it's more than possible that his learned-power after that point could make up the difference.

He gained power from using holocrons, and his potential in the Force was enigmatic for even Yoda, so it's not hard to imagine that he grew in power in the four or so remaining years of his life, which would be enough to (more than) make up for the pathetically weak nexus of Korriban at the time.

Originally posted by Azronger
Looking at the text, it seems like he was levitating them:

They were nearing the end of the hangar. He sensed it rather than saw it. The corroded vehicles were more numerous now, lined up like dark, giant phantoms.

Like phantoms..

Phantoms that move...

And despite it being on a a nexus, I doubt RotS Dooku wouldn't be able to do this, since Korriban has lost its potency in modern times, and Dooku was four years pre-prime.

Because? The fact they were moving doesn't mean they were levitating.

And for someone of his age, not convinced four years would make that much of a difference, though its probably worth doing more research into the potency of the planet. The most damning point against the Count here being that he's never replicated it anywhere else, certainly he doesn't unleash anything remotely comparable against Yoda.

None of that stuff really impresses me more than this. Unless someone does accuarate calcs, I'll consider Dooku and Vader equals as telekinetics.
I think they are all in the same league when you consider the weight manipulated, forces counteracted, and distance from prime. For example the communications tower Marek launched:

By eyeballing alone I'd say is entering the same size range, and in the same title Vader ragdolls him.

Then we have Marek manipulating an ISD, a vessel infinitely larger than the ones Dooku is playing with. And Vader pulling down a freighter, which are typically 30-40m long, rather than just shifting one, a dozen years before his prime. Personally I find Vader's superiority to a telekinetic powerhouse like Marek in general to be more compelling evidence of power.

Those towers don't look 75m plus, and Dooku was doing it with (much) greater ease.

Also, you can't debunk someone's best feat by saying they've never done anything as good, lol. By that logic, you can strip anyone of their best showing.

Likewise, claiming that he's never displayed it in combat is pretty flawed. Vader doesn't show anything close to cathedral busting and his other environmentally destructive showings in fights as well. Likewise, Yoda never displays anything close to his top TK feats against Sidious in the Senate with the pods, etc., etc. - the movies just don't depict telekinetic potency anywhere near the EU, obviously.

Also, Dooku levitated the ships rather than just sliding them across the ground, since it mentions a ship going over Obi-Wan and Anakin's heads. Granted, they did drop, but if the vehicles were just skidding across the floor, it'd still hit them. And when the vehicles shattered, the parts "fell like rain" on the Jedi, so it was obviously overhead.

Not to mention that Dooku flipped one over casually, which is pretty impressive and better than Vader calling a freighter that's about half the size of these cruisers. Then there's the fact that the ships shattered upon hitting the wall, which is proof that they were flying at a pretty high velocity.

Dooku doing all this "so easily" is pretty damn impressive.

Beni, for a gay man, your size-estimation for the dimensions of physical objects isn't what I'd hope it would be. For starters, this is what a forty meter Yacht looks like :

Also, Starkiller breaks free of Vader's rag doll in that title, and in than proceeds to rag doll his master himself.

^seems like something that big would be a "hulking wreck" to me 👆

Originally posted by SunRazer
Starkiller blew everything on that, whereas Dooku did his feats with ease, and he threw several in rapid succession, IIRC.

Starkiller had no time to gather his power, so while he didn't do it with ease it's not his limit either.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Tyranus did also throw them (or their wreckage?) together to create wreckage to block the hangar entrance.

Cool, Starkiller was also guiding the Salvation, and he was just past of shielding himself from atmospheric re-entry 🙂

These feats are not on the same level.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Those towers don't look 75m plus, and Dooku was doing it with (much) greater ease.

Also, you can't debunk someone's best feat by saying they've never done anything as good, lol. By that logic, you can strip anyone of their best showing.

Likewise, claiming that he's never displayed it in combat is pretty flawed. Vader doesn't show anything close to cathedral busting and his other environmentally destructive showings in fights as well. Likewise, Yoda never displays anything close to his top TK feats against Sidious in the Senate with the pods, etc., etc. - the movies just don't depict telekinetic potency anywhere near the EU, obviously.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Also, Dooku levitated the ships rather than just sliding them across the ground, since it mentions a ship going over Obi-Wan and Anakin's heads. Granted, they did drop, but if the vehicles were just skidding across the floor, it'd still hit them. And when the vehicles shattered, the parts "fell like rain" on the Jedi, so it was obviously overhead.

Not to mention that Dooku flipped one over casually, which is pretty impressive and better than Vader calling a freighter that's about half the size of these cruisers. Then there's the fact that the ships shattered upon hitting the wall, which is proof that they were flying at a pretty high velocity.

Dooku doing all this "so easily" is pretty damn impressive.

Fair points, however we don't even have an accurate fix on the size of the ships, 75m is just a guesstimation, I'm not sure how big that tower is but it looks pretty big.

Though to be quite honest, ILS has a point when he says these kinds of comparisons are insufficient, and without accurate calculations we can only make broad comparisons and opinion based conclusions. Hence why I find Vader's general superiority to Starkiller more compelling.

Anyway that wasn't my point, rather that it adds credence to the idea that this was a feat facilitated by the nexus, since he's never depicted as such a telekinetic powerhouse elsewhere - in the movies or the EU. And looking into the source, I'm afraid the power of the planet wasn't as weak as you make it out to be.

First of all it is powerful enough to make the Jedi afraid to go there:

"They are on Korriban."

Anakin felt the dread in the room. He knew of Korriban only through legends. Thousands of years before, it had been the seat of Sith power. The tombs of the ancient Sith Lords were there, and it was still a source of the dark side of the Force. It was a place no Jedi wanted to go.

And its dark side presence is profoundly felt by Kenobi from the moment they exit hyperspace:
The instrument panel showed they were about to come out of hyperspace. It was time to enter the coordinates for landing at Dreshdae.

Obi-Wan drifted to the front of the cockpit and the others followed. They stood, looking out into dark space. There were few stars out here, and no planets. Korriban loomed in their vision, a large planet with blood-red clouds obscuring its surface.

"I've heard it called the cradle of darkness," Obi-Wan said. He realized that he had lowered his voice.

He felt it now, the dark side of the Force emanating from the planet's surface. Looking at the faces of the Jedi, he knew they felt it as well. It had a sick sweetness to it, something that seemed to pour through his veins, attracting and repelling him at once. It was the most complicated surge of the dark side he had ever felt.

He struggled to meet it, struggled to clear his mind.

When they land on the planet, the dark side begin to project illusions, and this is just in Dreshdae, where the Sith barely had a presence at all:
Anakin felt a touch on his shoulder and turned. No one was behind him. Perhaps it had been a leaf brushing his shoulder - but he knew, of course, that there were no trees on Korriban.

Another touch - Anakin whipped around. He looked at Ferus, wondering if he was trying to play a trick on him, but Ferus was several meters back, talking to Soara.

He began to pick up a whisper. Then another. He couldn't make out the words, only the intent. Someone was baiting him, cajoling him, laughing at him... or was it his imagination? Was it just the wind whispering through the stones?

They crossed the street and he thought he saw a flash of something - blood coursing down a stone wall. When he blinked, it was gone.

"Master... "

"It is the dark side of the Force, Anakin," Obi-Wan said. "I'm picking it up, too. Ignore it."

But Anakin couldn't ignore it. There was something insistent about the voices. Something that urged him to answer. Although the feeling made him anxious, he also wanted to face it. He wanted to get to the root of this dark power... to match himself against it... to prove, once and for all, that he was as strong as it was.

And when they arrive at the ancient Sith monastery (where the hangar was located) the dark side appears to be even more concentrated:
Anakin looked down. Below them an ancient structure rose out of the steep mountainside and spilled out into a narrow valley. The mountain made two-thirds of the structure impenetrable. The entrance was in ruins, blocked by huge toppled columns and blocks of crumbling stone.

Anakin felt the peculiar stomach-turning wrench he experienced when faced with the tremors of the dark side of the Force. He knew what this wreck of a building was.

The ancient Sith monastery spread out below him, deserted for centuries, and still a presence of evil. Here was where thousands of Sith had once trained - and thousands of hopefuls had once disappeared forever.

There is more, in particular the Valley of the Dark Lord is described as steeped in the dark side, and pretty much blows DMB's Tukata comparison out of water, lmao.

More to the point, the dark side was alive and well on Korriban. Enough to amp Dooku to a notable degree, surely.

Feat analyzing has always been a huge waste of time.

Yeah Dooku's got nothing on Vader TK wise. Let's not forget he's shown vulnerable to TK attacks himself from far inferior foes to Vader (Savage anyone?)

And Dooku's still got nothing next to stopping, levitating and Crushing an attacking AT-AT without the aid of any kind of Nexus.

I know I'm mixing Canon evidences with peoples Legends evidences here. But going by Legends Beni is right that Dooku has nothing on SK's TK feats. And Bader repeatedly proved himself as =/> SK in TK.

If we're not going by feats than the only valid holistic comparison is Dooku >> RotS Kenobi > Old Ben <= Vader. Vader fans are shooting themselves in the foot here because lifting up big shit with TK is the only thing we've seen from Galen/Starkiller otherwise he's the guy who gets slapped by Shadow Gaurds.

.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Valley of the Dark Lord is described as steeped in the dark side, and pretty much blows DMB's Tukata comparison out of water, lmao.

I loved the Tukata scaling 🙁

Originally posted by Darth Thor
But going by Legends Beni is right that Dooku has nothing on SK's TK feats. And Bader repeatedly proved himself as =/> SK in TK.

*Worse.