ANH Vader vs Kit Fisto

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Those are canon quotes are they not?

No but in cases where the novelizations contradict and are of equal canon you would look towards another source that is not contradicted. I.E. in these particular cases, the movie.

1. If they have contradictions yet all versions were canonized then it means they weren't actually looked at for errors.

2. Not at all. I'll explain to you why taking a possible version of events when there's a third person descriptive version is idiotic and expect you to be enlightened.

It's contradicted and therefore discardable when we have a non contradicted version of events to turn to which is the case here.

Right, and they do contradict one another, often, so why not look to only the movie regarding say Dooku's duel with Anakin & Kenobi? Given how the novels conflict in their recounting of it?

1. An assumption, but in terms of the contradiction here i.e. between the vanilla version and the Wii version, I already explained why that's likely to be the case. Regardless at the end of the day it would come down to an personal opinion, however reasoned, as to which source you choose, and that just doesn't fly in a debate. As of equal canon status, you can only treat them equally.

2. Keep it to yourself, buttface.

It's canon. Suck it poorfag.

Then I don't care about the second quote. Provide the paragraph the first quote appeared in for context please.

Sure. Though if the movie supports one of interpretations in either the Junior novel or the novelization then I don't see why you couldn't look to those sources to elaborate further on the the events that occurred.

1. The events from the Wii version are confirmed in the Prima guide as Zoltan mentioned. Or you can disregard them all for being a contradicted mass of sh!t like I do.

2. Ur a stupid doodie head.

Fug u Beanie.

Why? Its referring to how the EU operated before Disney changed it up.

Regardless, here's the link for the other quote:

http://web.archive.org/web/20011006064339/http://www.starwars.com/community/askjc/steve/askjc20010817.html

OK, as long as you accept that, prepare to die by your own logic in coming months.

1. Of course they are, the Prima Guide is designed to guide the player through all the versions, including the Wii one. Doesn't make it any less constrained by the Wii engine. And you mean look for loopholes to justify your bias.

2. Death is too good for you.

:iwin:

As an excuse for the travesty they were enacting at the time and something they have no authority over ( Legend continuity ).

Fair enough. They make it pretty clear movies are above all. I'll shift my stance in that regard now that I've seen that quote.

Well I've changed that now in regards to the movies at least as the article you linked makes it clears that they're above all in terms of canon.

1. Nah I mean disregard a teaming mass of contradictions for something that is clear and stated.

2. Don't I know it.

As in true hard fax you won't accept.

Good, no more novelisations for you then.

Good, discard then into your trash bin, fuggot.

That Marek > Yoda? Not seeing it.

🙂

Nah, as in a company that has no authority in regards to Legend continuity.

Yep.

I do on the daily.

Causing Sidious to grow desperate after he'd been absorbing the life energy of billions of sentient beings for 2 years and having scoured millions of worlds for Sith knowledge seems better then being outmatched by baseline RotS Sidious.

u r cancer.

🙂