Proof that Revan is superior to Nihilus?

Started by DarthAnt665 pages

Mostly I take whichever character exemplifies the franchise (in Old Republic, that’s Revan, in New Hope, it’s Luke), and say “that’s the top contender.”

Revan was one of the strongest Force-wielders ever.

Oh my, what a devastating quote. So I guess Revan = ANH Luke? Shit, you got me man. Owned.

I assume he's referring to that general time-period.

That's not a rebuttal, btw. That's you trying to desperately save face.

Ant - 198,621, Nephthys - 0

Originally posted by Nephthys
Avellone's idea's were never implemented. And pretty sure that second sentence is just you taking what you want to take from it.
His ideas may not have ever been implemented, but they are nonetheless rather useful in interpreting his characters and since your arguments for Nihilus' superiority appear to be entirely within the realm of Avellone's work and contributions to the lore, I don't see the problem with Ant's inferences here tbh. Granted, I don't subscribe to the KMC community's highly dismissive notions of authorial intent, so there's that. 😛

Neph's arguments are completely dismissing several quotes and all author intent.

So, standard Neph.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I assume he's referring to that general time-period.

That's not a rebuttal, btw. That's you trying to desperately save face.

Ant - 198,621, Nephthys - 0

You mean like how Luke is the strongest in the OT for realz definitely no one else can't think of him getting owned by anyone ever nope.

He's talking about which character exemplifies the franchise, which means nothing. "Top contender" is also meaningless. And everyone and their grandma is one of the most powerful ever. All pointless nothings.

Go email him again, ask him to soothe those tears.

Originally posted by Nephthys
He's talking about which character exemplifies the franchise, which means nothing.

Within the context of the power levels of Force users.

It goes back to the point that Revan literally embodies KotOR / SWTOR.

All I'm seeing from you is denial, denial, denial. Pretty 😂

Your quote doesn't give any context because you're only posting the parts of it you want to. But if that is accurate he's clearly moving the point away from actual power by saying that the "top contender" is the one who exemplifies the franchise. Obviously (to most) that has nothing to do with actual power levels. Luke isn't the strongest in the OT any more than Revan is in Kotor.

Top contender meaning MVP of the era. 😐

Ant. Are you seriously trying to argue that Luke in A New Hope is superior to Sidious and Vader?

Which doesn't mean he's the strongest or most powerful? Like.... duh?

I mean. Ant, I like you and all. But be real here for a second.

I don't think he's specifically referring to A New Hope. I think he's referring to Luke Skywalker in general, i.e. the most powerful Jedi ever, in which his origins are shown in A New Hope.

"[n New Hope, it’s Luke"

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
I think he's referring to Luke Skywalker in general, i.e. the most powerful Jedi ever, in which his origins are shown in A New Hope.

And he's referring specifically to franchises not overall.

"Mostly I take whichever character exemplifies the franchise (in Old Republic, that’s Revan, in New Hope, it’s Luke)"

Then the ANH to FOTJ franchise. 👆

Basically, what I *consistently* see here is the Nihilus Brigade constantly undergoing a state of denial and defense, rather than acceptance or offense.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Then the ANH to FOTJ franchise. 👆

You're an idiot.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
a state of denial and defense

The irony is crushing here.

Ant's left reality. 😆