Spiderman vs Midnighter

Started by DarkSaint859 pages
Originally posted by Sin I AM
Hmmm...u think door > spot?

Oh Lordy, no - the Spot has shown more versatility. Where they ARE equal/similar, however, is that they are both extradimensional - so they don't set the SS off.

Originally posted by cdtm
And how does that work, exactly?

So he'd still need to see?

Not shown. He hasn't needed line of sight to do them either.

Originally posted by carver9
It seems like points tend to go over your head.

Also, even though the hypno implants were there, he was still fighting back. You're making excuses at this point. He could've opened a door.

Again, you're making excuses. If the door is an effective tool, and it is, he would've used it in battle.

Lol...the forum rules states they fight in character. In CHARACTER, MN doesn't use doors. He has far more appearances of fighting it out vs opening up doors. This goes to the point of my previous question...ON AVERAGE, MN does not use doors. You can post all the things you want about Spiderman but on AVERAGE, he uses his spider sense, super speed, super strength, webbing and intellect. Post those scans though.

🙂

Oh carver, lol.

Missing the point? 😛

Do you know what the battle computer does?

This is, unfortunately, an issue in this thread. The Spidey supporters know all about Spidey, and a bit about Midnighter. But the Midnighter supporters know all about Mids, and a fair bit about Spidey.

But I will humour you, carver, and once again own you as per usual. Actually, that is mean. I will educate you, as per usual.

The BC tells him how to win. Agreed? It tells him the winning tactics.

If his fists are good enough to win, then no doors will be used. However, you and others have been telling Zack and I all this stuff about Spiderman - he beats up Firelord, Rhino, Hulk, Doom, FF, etc, and has taken hits from Hulk, Juggy, Venom etc etc, and his webbing has restrained Hulk, etc.

So you're telling me he has ZERO chance in a physical fight. Agreed?

So with zero chance - he uses doors. Why HASN'T he used doors in his other fights? Because he hasn't needed to. Simple as that. He didn't need them when he was kicking Parasite's teeth out. He didn't need them against Etrigan, or the Red Lanterns, or Martian Manhunter, or Grayson - because his BC told him fists were enough. Of course, with Grayson, the Hypnos implants then messed with the BC. Which Spidey does not have here.

What about Afterthought, the guy who curbed him? Why didn't he use doors then?

Firstly, he did. Harley had booby trapped them with Amanda Waller - literally just before he was beaten up, he tanked an explosion point blank whilst saving his boyfriend, Robert (a very good durability feat, btw - thanks for reminding me!)

https://s5.postimg.org/rn1pthzbr/36_15.jpg
https://s5.postimg.org/vxkz2ttsn/36_16.jpg

Secondly - no basic knowledge of his opponent. Unlike here. He had no idea what Afterthought could do.

Again, I must reiterate this point. You have no real idea of what Midnighter the character is. His BC tells him what to do to win. IF, as you assert, he has ZERO chance in a physical match up (after all, Spidey is totes amazeballs, and can totally on average hang with heralds!!!) then it will be used.

If he has a chance to win, then he uses fists. IN CHARACTER. On average, he hasn't needed to, because his physicals are way up there (as I have shown in scans) against his opponents. You're just ignoring his BC, which is kinda like ignoring Reed with prep, lol.

🙂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Oh Lordy

YouTube video

Chime in, Stilt. Is the bug, on average, herald wrecking?

Are you?

Carver is at best, Snapper Carr level. I don't have to be.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Chime in, Stilt. Is the bug, on average, herald wrecking?

Of course not. Firelord is not much of a herald, anyway.

But let's give him that feat. Nighter almost managed to one-shot kill Manhunter, who is in the herald tier. Parker needed to land 20+ blows and the fight lasted entire issue.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Oh Lordy, no - the Spot has shown more versatility. Where they ARE equal/similar, however, is that they are both extradimensional - so they don't set the SS off.

Not shown. He hasn't needed line of sight to do them either.

Oh carver, lol.

Missing the point? 😛

Do you know what the battle computer does?

This is, unfortunately, an issue in this thread. The Spidey supporters know all about Spidey, and a bit about Midnighter. But the Midnighter supporters know all about Mids, and a fair bit about Spidey.

But I will humour you, carver, and once again own you as per usual. Actually, that is mean. I will educate you, as per usual.

The BC tells him how to win. Agreed? It tells him the winning tactics.

If his fists are good enough to win, then no doors will be used. However, you and others have been telling Zack and I all this stuff about Spiderman - he beats up Firelord, Rhino, Hulk, Doom, FF, etc, and has taken hits from Hulk, Juggy, Venom etc etc, and his webbing has restrained Hulk, etc.

So you're telling me he has ZERO chance in a physical fight. Agreed?

So with zero chance - he uses doors. Why HASN'T he used doors in his other fights? Because he hasn't needed to. Simple as that. He didn't need them when he was kicking Parasite's teeth out. He didn't need them against Etrigan, or the Red Lanterns, or Martian Manhunter, or Grayson - because his BC told him fists were enough. Of course, with Grayson, the Hypnos implants then messed with the BC. Which Spidey does not have here.

What about Afterthought, the guy who curbed him? Why didn't he use doors then?

Firstly, he did. Harley had booby trapped them with Amanda Waller - literally just before he was beaten up, he tanked an explosion point blank whilst saving his boyfriend, Robert (a very good durability feat, btw - thanks for reminding me!)

https://s5.postimg.org/rn1pthzbr/36_15.jpg
https://s5.postimg.org/vxkz2ttsn/36_16.jpg

Secondly - no basic knowledge of his opponent. Unlike here. He had no idea what Afterthought could do.

Again, I must reiterate this point. You have no real idea of what Midnighter the character is. His BC tells him what to do to win. IF, as you assert, he has ZERO chance in a physical match up (after all, Spidey is totes amazeballs, and can totally on average hang with heralds!!!) then it will be used.

If he has a chance to win, then he uses fists. IN CHARACTER. On average, he hasn't needed to, because his physicals are way up there (as I have shown in scans) against his opponents. You're just ignoring his BC, which is kinda like ignoring Reed with prep, lol.

🙂

Doesn't make sense. The Battle computer tells MN how to win right. He should not have lost to After thought IF what you say about his computer is true. It run millions of scenarios...AND it tells him how to win vs an enemy. Why lose against someone like Afterthought? He should have been able to counter every attack, especially with something that runs a million scenarios. Something that per your admission is built to make you take another approach to run into whatever Midnighter has planned for you. Then, crazy thing is, during their second fight, he still didn't resort to door, instead he took a beating and just upped his armor. IF door was as useful as you are making it, he would've used it but he doesn't. Question, what fight since being in DCNU has he used door. Also, you never showed me him taking off limbs. I want to see that as well.

You telling me I have no idea of Mids, it seems like you don't either. Then you bring up Spiderman fighting in character but have as of yet to show us him using door during combat and even if you showed a scene where he did that still doesn't take away from all the times he didn't use it. He could've used it against Martian Manhunter as well and closed the door as soon as he fell in but he didn't. Show me those scans dark.

Originally posted by carver9
Show me those scans dark.

YouTube video

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Hypnos implants, which Dick had. As soon as the God Garden shut them down, Midnighter didn't even need doors - he just kicked the crap out of Grayson.

Please re-read your own scans, lol.

With Afterthought, it was because anything he tried, he was immediately shut down. By a guy who could see 5 seconds into the future.

Also, this is a forum fight, lol. Shall I trawl through Spidey's entire history and ask why he didn't do this, or that, every time he lost? Believe you me, I would find WAY more examples (as I would be able to go all the way back to the 60s).

Case should be closed just b/c of what you said about afterthought. Parker's SS acts similar in that it warns him ahead of time of incoming danger. In some ways I would say that the SS can be viewed as arguably better in that it almost has a min of it's own, reacting and getting Pete out of harms way even before he knows what's going on.

Originally posted by Scarlet315
Case should be closed just b/c of what you said about afterthought. Parker's SS acts similar in that it warns him ahead of time of incoming danger. In some ways I would say that the SS can be viewed as arguably better in that it almost has a min of it's own, reacting and getting Pete out of harms way even before he knows what's going on.

Sad thing is Grifter almost took him out in one hit. Full powered Grifter. When he fight nobodies he does amazingly good but when he fight someone with a name the fight isn't as lop sided

Originally posted by carver9

Sad thing is Grifter almost took him out in one hit. Full powered Grifter. When he fight nobodies he does amazingly good but when he fight someone with a name the fight isn't as lop sided

My bad. Just checked afterthoughts bio and he's just a base human. Mine as well have a tarot card shop. Now combine his gifts with someone with the proportionate strength, speed, reflexes, and agility of a spider and we have a very different scenario.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
they are both extradimensional - so they don't set the SS off.

I don't think there is NEARLY enough evidence presented to claim this as an absolute certainty.

Originally posted by carver9
Doesn't make sense. The Battle computer tells MN how to win right. He should not have lost to After thought IF what you say about his computer is true. It run millions of scenarios...AND it tells him how to win vs an enemy. Why lose against someone like Afterthought? He should have been able to counter every attack, especially with something that runs a million scenarios. Something that per your admission is built to make you take another approach to run into whatever Midnighter has planned for you. Then, crazy thing is, during their second fight, he still didn't resort to door, instead he took a beating and just upped his armor. IF door was as useful as you are making it, he would've used it but he doesn't. Question, what fight since being in DCNU has he used door. Also, you never showed me him taking off limbs. I want to see that as well.

You telling me I have no idea of Mids, it seems like you don't either. Then you bring up Spiderman fighting in character but have as of yet to show us him using door during combat and even if you showed a scene where he did that still doesn't take away from all the times he didn't use it. He could've used it against Martian Manhunter as well and closed the door as soon as he fell in but he didn't. Show me those scans dark.

It doesn't make sense....because you don't read. I'll break it down for you.

THEY BOOBY TRAPPED THE DOORS.

https://s5.postimg.org/rn1pthzbr/36_15.jpg
https://s5.postimg.org/vxkz2ttsn/36_16.jpg

During the second fight, no doors. Why? AMANDA WALLER HAD BEEN BLOCKING THEM.

Do you even read comics?
https://s5.postimg.org/wsc42lr13/29_09.jpg

Moreover, opening doors is useless anyway against Afterthought - as he can fully see 5 minutes into the future - even down to the exact conversation he's about to have. Which the SS can't do.

Please come back when you've actually read the comics, instead of relying on the Ownage thread lol. Crazy thing is, I've read them. HAve you?

Gotcha.

Wait, so you concede that thread with Surfer NOT showing what he says he can do? Yes or no? Because at the moment, you're having extreme double standards.

https://s5.postimg.org/iikgqpn9z/33_03.jpg
https://s5.postimg.org/xskbxwis7/33_04.jpg
https://s5.postimg.org/3p5t5yfiv/33_05.jpg

'WHEN (not IF), I do it, they find their kneecaps two blocks away.'

He could've - but didn't need to, against Martian Manhunter lol. Why are you not getting this???

Originally posted by Scarlet315
Case should be closed just b/c of what you said about afterthought. Parker's SS acts similar in that it warns him ahead of time of incoming danger. In some ways I would say that the SS can be viewed as arguably better in that it almost has a min of it's own, reacting and getting Pete out of harms way even before he knows what's going on.

Except against Afterthought, he had no doors, and the first time they fought, he had no basic knowledge, and had just taken an explosion point blank. Moreover, Afterthought's power is even better than the SS.

Originally posted by carver9

Sad thing is Grifter almost took him out in one hit. Full powered Grifter. When he fight nobodies he does amazingly good but when he fight someone with a name the fight isn't as lop sided

So....PIS then? Gotcha. Wait, Grifter is....telepathic. He can read minds. I'm SURE Spiderman can read minds too!!!

http://i.imgur.com/RSbxRlN.jpg

What was the point of your scan? Apart to show that Grifter took out Apollo as well? Full powered Grifter is no joke.

Originally posted by Scarlet315
My bad. Just checked afterthoughts bio and he's just a base human. Mine as well have a tarot card shop. Now combine his gifts with someone with the proportionate strength, speed, reflexes, and agility of a spider and we have a very different scenario.

Base humans can smash body armour that Red Lanterns and Etrigan the demon were unable to smash. Yes, I'm sure your bios (which we don't use here on the boards, btw) are great 👆

Originally posted by JayDaDon
I don't think there is NEARLY enough evidence presented to claim this as an absolute certainty.

Exactly!!!

Originally posted by JayDaDon
I don't think there is NEARLY enough evidence presented to claim this as an absolute certainty.

Spot, pretty much the only portal based villain of Spidey.

If there are more portal guys who've gone up against him, feel free to post it.

Because as of now, I've got a pretty solid average.

Also, look how far away the portal is before it hits Spidey.

I do love, however, how a fully powered Grfiter using his TK (and being upgraded, which Mids did not know about) is supposedly a low showing.

This is what Grifter's TK can do:

http://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11118/111188740/4583259-5268011033-grift.jpg
http://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11118/111188740/4583260-7800142262-grift.jpg

Those of you too lazy to read it, he uprooted an entire forest area, and dumped it on someone. Imagine that power, focussed on a punch.

He can penetrate bulletproof armour:
http://static4.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11118/111188740/4583792-0259880303-grift.jpg

So, using that as a low showing? Coolios.

Btw, guess who else has a 'Danger sense' similar to Spiderman?

http://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/12/120679/4220110-grifter-007-(2012)-(digital)-(nahga-empire)-06.jpg

Grifter.

Grifter would crush Spidey, too.

Spider-man.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Spot, pretty much the only portal based villain of Spidey.

If there are more portal guys who've gone up against him, feel free to post it.

Because as of now, I've got a pretty solid average.

Also, look how far away the portal is before it hits Spidey.

That's Spot's powers tho and Spidey said somehow his ss didn't pick up on it. So its still unknown if any and every extra dimensional portal is immune to the Spider sense.